Why is a meta-analysis stronger evidence for a null effect of sugar on hyperactivity?

Phlebotomy Essentials
6th Edition
ISBN:9781451194524
Author:Ruth McCall, Cathee M. Tankersley MT(ASCP)
Publisher:Ruth McCall, Cathee M. Tankersley MT(ASCP)
Chapter1: Phlebotomy: Past And Present And The Healthcare Setting
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1SRQ
icon
Related questions
Question

Why is a meta-analysis stronger evidence for a null effect of sugar on hyperactivity?

Instructions: Using the following information and prompts from your textbook author's blog, read
through the information provided and then as a group, determine the best responses.
Here's something "everybody says": Kids will become hyperactive if they eat too much sugar. This folk
belief is as much a part of North American cultural wisdom as learning styles and the catharsis
hypothesis. But this column in the New York Times explains that, like learning styles and catharsis, the
idea of a "sugar high" is also a myth.
The physician who wrote the column traced the modern idea of sugar causing hyperactivity to 1975. But
then the author describes a randomized clinical trial on this question. Here's the description:
An extraordinarily rigorous study settled the question in 1994. Writing in the New England
Journal of Medicine, a group of scientists tested normal preschoolers and children whose parents
described them as being sensitive to sugar. Neither the parents, the children nor the research
staff knew which of the children were getting sugary foods and which were getting a diet
sweetened with aspartame and other artificial sweeteners. Urine was tested to verify compliance
with the diets. Nine different measures of cognitive and behavioral performance were assessed,
with measurements taken at five-second intervals.
The original study was, indeed, ambitious. The authors provided all food to the homes of the children in
the study so they could completely control what sweeteners were being used. The study took place over
nine weeks in a repeated-measures design--the diets were based on sucrose (sugar) one week, aspartame
another week, and saccharine during another week. The researchers measured the children's cognitive
performance and mood throughout the study.
The study concluded that sugar does not affect children's behavior or cognitive function.
An editorial that accompanied the study put a fine point on that conclusion, stating "there is no
evidence that sugar alone can turn a child with normal attention into a hyperactive child."
Transcribed Image Text:Instructions: Using the following information and prompts from your textbook author's blog, read through the information provided and then as a group, determine the best responses. Here's something "everybody says": Kids will become hyperactive if they eat too much sugar. This folk belief is as much a part of North American cultural wisdom as learning styles and the catharsis hypothesis. But this column in the New York Times explains that, like learning styles and catharsis, the idea of a "sugar high" is also a myth. The physician who wrote the column traced the modern idea of sugar causing hyperactivity to 1975. But then the author describes a randomized clinical trial on this question. Here's the description: An extraordinarily rigorous study settled the question in 1994. Writing in the New England Journal of Medicine, a group of scientists tested normal preschoolers and children whose parents described them as being sensitive to sugar. Neither the parents, the children nor the research staff knew which of the children were getting sugary foods and which were getting a diet sweetened with aspartame and other artificial sweeteners. Urine was tested to verify compliance with the diets. Nine different measures of cognitive and behavioral performance were assessed, with measurements taken at five-second intervals. The original study was, indeed, ambitious. The authors provided all food to the homes of the children in the study so they could completely control what sweeteners were being used. The study took place over nine weeks in a repeated-measures design--the diets were based on sucrose (sugar) one week, aspartame another week, and saccharine during another week. The researchers measured the children's cognitive performance and mood throughout the study. The study concluded that sugar does not affect children's behavior or cognitive function. An editorial that accompanied the study put a fine point on that conclusion, stating "there is no evidence that sugar alone can turn a child with normal attention into a hyperactive child."
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Phlebotomy Essentials
Phlebotomy Essentials
Nursing
ISBN:
9781451194524
Author:
Ruth McCall, Cathee M. Tankersley MT(ASCP)
Publisher:
JONES+BARTLETT PUBLISHERS, INC.
Gould's Pathophysiology for the Health Profession…
Gould's Pathophysiology for the Health Profession…
Nursing
ISBN:
9780323414425
Author:
Robert J Hubert BS
Publisher:
Saunders
Fundamentals Of Nursing
Fundamentals Of Nursing
Nursing
ISBN:
9781496362179
Author:
Taylor, Carol (carol R.), LYNN, Pamela (pamela Barbara), Bartlett, Jennifer L.
Publisher:
Wolters Kluwer,
Fundamentals of Nursing, 9e
Fundamentals of Nursing, 9e
Nursing
ISBN:
9780323327404
Author:
Patricia A. Potter RN MSN PhD FAAN, Anne Griffin Perry RN EdD FAAN, Patricia Stockert RN BSN MS PhD, Amy Hall RN BSN MS PhD CNE
Publisher:
Elsevier Science
Study Guide for Gould's Pathophysiology for the H…
Study Guide for Gould's Pathophysiology for the H…
Nursing
ISBN:
9780323414142
Author:
Hubert BS, Robert J; VanMeter PhD, Karin C.
Publisher:
Saunders
Issues and Ethics in the Helping Professions (Min…
Issues and Ethics in the Helping Professions (Min…
Nursing
ISBN:
9781337406291
Author:
Gerald Corey, Marianne Schneider Corey, Cindy Corey
Publisher:
Cengage Learning