China Public Diplomacy
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Oxford University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
101
Subject
Communications
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
18
Uploaded by mikekyalo64
1
China's Public Diplomacy Spotlight
Student’s Name Institution’s Affiliation Course Code & Title Instructor’s Name Due Date 1
2
China's Public Diplomacy Spotlight
Introduction
To accomplish a nation's foreign policy objectives, public diplomacy is a strategic communication strategy that seeks to shape the views and opinions of foreign publics. Public diplomacy, as opposed to traditional diplomacy, which focuses on contacts between governments, builds ties and improves a nation's standing abroad by interacting with non-state players such as the media, civil society, and the general public. China has been selected as a case
study due to its aggressive approach to public diplomacy and its growing prominence in international affairs. China, the second-biggest economy in the world and a rising global force, understands how critical it is to control views and shape its worldwide image. The nation has made large investments in public diplomacy programs in an effort to establish its power, refute false narratives, and advance a favorable picture of itself abroad.
China's public diplomacy structure consists of a number of government departments, cultural institutions, and media outlets cooperating to provide a unified picture of Chinese culture, values, and policies. The State Council Information Office, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and organizations that promote Chinese language and culture overseas like Confucius Institutes are important participants. This critical assessment will explore China's public diplomacy tactics, looking at their advantages, disadvantages, and effects on how the world views the nation. We may learn more about how China manages the complicated terrain of global public opinion and strategically places itself on the international scene by examining certain programs, alliances, and messaging.
Definition and Theoretical Framework of Public Diplomacy
2
3
Building ties and improving a nation's reputation abroad are the goals of public diplomacy, which entails interacting with non-state players such as the media, civil society, and the general public. The goal of public diplomacy is to sway public opinion abroad, as opposed to traditional diplomacy, which concentrates on exchanges between governments. Through encouraging mutual understanding and collaboration between countries, public diplomacy plays a vital role in international relations. By influencing attitudes and fostering goodwill, it aims to foster an atmosphere that is conducive to a nation's foreign policy goals (d'Hooghe, 2015). For instance, a country that participates in educational or cultural exchanges may be seen more favorably by people from other countries. Modern public diplomacy initiatives are supported by a number of theories and techniques. In order to promote understanding between nations, cultural
diplomacy entails exhibiting a nation's cultural legacy. State-funded news organizations serve as an example of international broadcasting, which enables countries to share stories and information throughout the world. Scholarships and student exchanges are two examples of educational exchange programs that foster interpersonal relationships. China's public diplomacy infrastructure is made up of multiple organizations that collaborate well. The State Council Information Office and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs both play important roles in promoting Chinese language and culture overseas, as do programs like Confucius Institutes. The various Confucius Institutes around the world provide forums for scholarly cooperation, language acquisition, and cross-cultural engagement. By highlighting China's cultural diversity and promoting educational exchanges, these establishments promote a favorable image of the country (d'Hooghe, 2011). They have, however, come under fire for their possible political sway, which raises concerns about how to strike a balance between political discourse and cultural interchange. China's foreign broadcasting endeavors are best demonstrated
3
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
4
by China Global Television Network (CGTN), an international English-language news station. With a Chinese viewpoint on world events, CGTN seeks to offer an alternative story to the media environment dominated by the West. However, it faces scrutiny for alleged bias and state influence.
Theories and Methods of Modern Public Diplomacy
Cultural Diplomacy:
China emphasizes cultural diplomacy heavily in order to present its history, customs, and artistic creations. Positive perceptions are bolstered by the internationalization of traditional Chinese cultural events, art exhibitions, and performances. A careful balance is necessary since cultural endeavors can present difficulties if they are seen as attempts to further a certain political agenda.
International Broadcasting:
China makes use of organizations such as Xinhua News Agency and CGTN to support its foreign broadcasting needs. China hopes to diversify global media narratives by offering news and information from a Chinese perspective (Aoyama, 2022). The efficacy of this strategy is challenged by issues with media independence, transparency, and adherence to journalistic norms.
Educational Exchange:
Through agreements with international universities, student exchange programs, and scholarships, China fosters educational exchange. This improves
interpersonal relationships and promotes understanding across cultural boundaries. But accusations of academic suppression have sparked worries about the possible erosion of academic freedom, especially in Confucius Institutes.
Positive attitudes, increased cultural and educational interactions, and improved global understanding are indicators of successful public diplomacy. Initiatives that are successful create connections, encourage teamwork, and enhance a country's soft power. The danger of coming 4
5
across as propaganda, striking a balance between political goals and cultural promotion, and managing cultural differences are just a few of the difficulties facing public diplomacy. Skepticism and difficulties establishing trust are exacerbated by the Chinese government's stringent information control, limitations on the right to free speech, and accusations of meddling
in academic institutions (Rumi, 2022). The world's perception of China will be greatly impacted by its public diplomacy operations. Goodwill is fostered via constructive cultural exchanges and educational partnerships that lead to a more comprehensive understanding. However, concerns about political influence, media bias, and restrictions on freedom can undermine these efforts, leading to skepticism and a more critical global perception. Historical Background and Development of China’s Public Diplomacy
China's evolving public diplomacy closely reflects the country's changing position in the world. China has traditionally prioritized formal state-to-state ties and has been a state-centric diplomacy. However, a change toward a more all-encompassing and proactive approach to public diplomacy happened as the world observed China's rapid economic expansion and growing worldwide influence. In the latter half of the 20th century, China realized it needed to improve its reputation abroad and strengthen its soft power. China's international reputation was severely damaged by the Tiananmen Square incident in 1989, which led to a reassessment of the country's communication tactics (Wang, 2008). During this time, the first efforts toward public diplomacy were taken, emphasizing cultural and economic exchanges. In the 21st century, China's public diplomacy became more muscular, especially under Presidents Hu Jintao and Xi Jinping. Launched in 2013, the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has emerged as a focal point of China's global engagement strategy, exhibiting infrastructure development and economic 5
6
cooperation. BRI initiatives have progressively incorporated public diplomacy initiatives, highlighting mutual benefits and shared development objectives.
Main Organizations and Institutions
China uses a variety of institutions and organizations as part of its public diplomacy machinery to promote a single message. A key player in organizing and carrying out public diplomacy initiatives is the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA). One important venue for distributing information and forming narratives is the State Council Information Office (SCIO). Since its founding in 2004, Confucius Institutes have played a significant role in advancing Chinese language and culture throughout the world. These organizations work in tandem with overseas colleges and establishments to promote interpersonal interactions (Schliebs et al., 2021). They have, nevertheless, come under fire for possible censorship and influence issues. China Radio International (CRI) is an essential medium for distributing opinions, news, and cultural content throughout the world. Its multilingual operations increase its effect and reach. Additionally, global media outlets like Xinhua News Agency project China's perspective internationally.
Characteristics and Objectives across Historical Periods
1.
Early Initiatives:
China emphasized economic development in its public diplomacy in the late 20th century, presenting itself as a responsible player in the world economy. The "Peaceful Development" campaign and other cultural exchanges attempted to dispel misconceptions. The focus was on stability and economic growth, indicating China's dedication to world prosperity.
2.
Shift towards Soft Power:
China realized the use of soft power in influencing opinions abroad in the twenty-first century. The goal of programs like the Confucius Institutes and 6
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
7
the Chinese language advocacy was to increase cultural impact (Lee, 2021). With the BRI serving as an example, economic cooperation demonstrated China's dedication to shared development and positioned the country as a responsible participant.
3.
Assertive Diplomacy and Information Warfare:
China's public diplomacy became more bold and strategic under President Xi Jinping. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) grew to include media cooperation and information sharing in addition to economic development. China is now able to communicate directly with audiences around the world because to the growing use of social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter for international outreach.
Challenges and Future Implications
Despite many noteworthy successes, China's public diplomacy continues to face obstacles that could affect its course going forward. Human rights, censorship, and a perceived lack of transparency in communication tactics are among the main causes for concern. Chinese diplomats' assertiveness on social media has sometimes drawn criticism, highlighting the fine line that needs to be drawn in the pursuit of successful international engagement (Custer et al., 2019). China's public diplomacy will succeed or fail based on how well it handles these obstacles. It is impossible to overestimate the significance of open and inclusive communication as China gains more clout in international affairs. The country's ambassadors need to respond to concerns and criticism from abroad by projecting a complex, cooperative image that appeals to a wide range of viewers. China's public diplomacy must strike a balance between upholding international norms and advancing national objectives (Asif, 2022). Maintaining this equilibrium
will be essential to forming favorable opinions around the world and bolstering China's standing as a cooperative and responsible global player. As China continues to gain prominence and 7
8
influence, how the country is viewed internationally will be greatly influenced by how its public diplomacy continues to develop.
Key Aspects of China’s Public Diplomacy Strategy
Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)
The Belt and Road Initiative, an enormous infrastructure and economic development project spanning many continents, is at the center of China's public diplomacy activities. The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a fundamental component of China's effort to expand its influence globally by promoting economic connectivity and cooperation. China wants to show itself as a kind actor advancing global development by combining infrastructure development, financial investments, and diplomatic outreach. The BRI's capacity to forge alliances and strengthen economic ties is what makes it effective in influencing China's perception abroad (Ingenhoff, Calamai & Sevin, 2021). China advances its economic interests and promotes cooperation and goodwill by funding important infrastructure projects around the world.. However, challenges such as concerns over debt dependency and the environmental impact of some projects have sparked criticism, impacting the overall effectiveness of the initiative.
Major-Power Diplomacy
The goal of China's major-power diplomacy is to forge alliances with other important nations, both established and developing. China is positioned as a responsible and cooperative international actor by this strategy, which places an emphasis on cooperation and mutual gain. China can handle global issues collaboratively by engaging in major-power diplomacy, demonstrating its dedication to a peaceful international order. China seeks to advance multilateralism and fortify diplomatic ties through organizations like the BRICS alliance and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) (Yang, 2020). But this plan is challenged by 8
9
geopolitical conflicts, especially those with the US. In order to overcome these obstacles and change how the world views China's influence on international relations, skillful diplomacy is needed to strike a balance between collaboration and rivalry.
Cultural Exchanges Abroad
China's all-encompassing public diplomacy policy places a strong emphasis on cultural diplomacy, which uses a variety of platforms including Confucius Institutes and other cultural organizations. These activities, which promote a good appreciation of China's rich cultural heritage, values, and customs, play a key role in influencing worldwide perceptions of the country. Confucius Institutes, which act as platforms for the international transmission of Chinese language and cultural instruction, are at the forefront of these initiatives. They play a major role in fostering interpersonal relationships, promoting intercultural dialogue, and creating links between China and the rest of the globe. Nonetheless, there are obstacles in the way of these programs' success (USC Center on Public Diplomacy, 2012). Confucius Institutes have come under fire for allegedly invading academic space and pushing a particular political viewpoint. For China's cultural diplomacy efforts to be successful over the long term, a careful balance between fostering cross-cultural understanding and honoring different points of view must be struck. In order to make sure that cultural soft power is in line with the values of respect for one another and collaboration, it is necessary to navigate the complexity of international relations, accept criticism, and address issues. In the end, China's capacity to successfully traverse these obstacles and project a complex and inclusive image to the world will determine how effective its cultural diplomacy is as it continues to increase its worldwide influence.
Implementation in Different Regions and Countries
9
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
10
China employs flexible public diplomacy methods that are tailored to the distinct features
of many regions and nations. The BRI has gained traction in Africa, offering much-needed economic and infrastructural help. Major-power diplomacy is used in Southeast Asia to promote economic cooperation and regional stability. Cultural exchanges are customized to fit specific locales, guaranteeing their applicability and resonance to a wide range of audiences (Hessarbani, 2011). But problems still exist. Concerns about debt diplomacy and doubts about China's motives have emerged in some areas. Major-power diplomacy may be impacted by geopolitical rivalry, necessitating the use of nuanced strategies. Building long-lasting partnerships and favorable perceptions requires China to modify its policies in response to regional issues and local peculiarities.
Critical Assessment of China's Public Diplomacy Strategies
Alongside its rise to prominence on the world scene, China has made a determined attempt to influence opinions abroad through public diplomacy. This critical evaluation will present a dialectical viewpoint, looking at the efficacy of China's public diplomacy tactics, highlighting instances of success, and recognizing the constraints and difficulties it encounters.
Effectiveness of China's Public Diplomacy Strategies:
1.
Soft Power Initiatives:
China uses soft power projects as a tactic to increase its influence in the world. The widespread establishment of Confucius Institutes, which are devoted to advancing Chinese language and culture, is one noteworthy example. These institutes serve as centers of cultural interchange and are essential to building goodwill and enhancing China's soft power (Chang & Yang, 2020). Millions of people have actively interacted with Chinese language and culture through these platforms, demonstrating their success and helping to cultivate a positive foreign view of China. China continues to
10
11
increase its worldwide impact and cultivate a favorable reputation on the international scene by deliberately employing outreach programs in education and culture.
2.
Belt and Road Initiative (BRI): A key component of China's complex diplomatic and economic strategy is the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). As a strategic undertaking, it entails significant financial outlays for cross-continental infrastructure projects that promote economic interdependence and expand China's worldwide influence. The BRI highlights China's commitment to global development by acting as an economic accelerator and a public diplomacy weapon (Huang & Wang, 2020). However, criticisms have been made, especially with relation to concerns about debt-trap diplomacy and the geopolitical consequences of China's growing influence. Notwithstanding the objections, China's desire to take the lead in the world stage through a web of interconnected economic projects is reflected in the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which continues to have a considerable influence on international affairs.
3.
Vaccine Diplomacy:
China used a multipronged effort to combating the COVID-19 epidemic, most notably by actively engaging in vaccine diplomacy. China sought to demonstrate its commitment to global public health and establish itself as a responsible international player by strategically distributing vaccinations to developing countries (Bjola, Cassidy & Manor, 2019). Although this program received praise from all around the world and gained diplomatic favor, doubts about vaccination efficacy, transparency, and the underlying motivations driving China's distribution efforts surfaced. These worries have given China's vaccination diplomacy a more nuanced dynamic and prompted inquiries about the country's motivations as well as the wider ramifications of its participation in the international pandemic response.
11
12
Criticisms and Challenges:
1.
Political Sensitivity:
Political sensitivities pose significant obstacles to China's public diplomacy, especially when it comes to human rights. China's attempts to portray itself as
a responsible global participant have been clouded by incidents like the Hong Kong protests and the persecution of the Uighur minority, which have garnered considerable international condemnation (Becard & Menechelli, 2019). These disputes highlight the fundamental tension that exists between China's domestic policies and its goals of projecting a favorable image abroad. It is essential for China to address these issues if it hopes to promote positive ties and dispel doubts on the international scene. China's diplomatic success depends on striking a careful balance between internal governance and external expectations as the world closely examines its activities.
2.
Transparency Issues:
A significant obstacle to China's public diplomacy openness is the country's alleged disinformation tactics and information access restrictions. Skepticism is heightened by the control over narratives, particularly when it comes to incidents like the first COVID-19 response. The world community is suspicious of China because of its lack of transparency. In order to increase credibility and trust in its public diplomacy efforts, openness must be established (Xu, 2021). China may overcome these obstacles and boost its diplomatic efforts on the international scene by resolving concerns, granting
unrestricted access to information, and improving communication. In the end, adopting transparency turns into a crucial strategic requirement for China's diplomacy and ties with
other countries.
3.
Consistency with Traditional Foreign Policy:
China's ability to effectively use public diplomacy depends on how well its messaging fits in with conventional wisdom in 12
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
13
foreign affairs. Even with the promotion of peaceful growth, contradictions nevertheless occur, most notably with regard to territorial claims and the South China Sea issue. China's assertiveness in these areas raises questions about the genuineness of its efforts in
public diplomacy. China has to promote transparency and cooperation while coordinating
its foreign policy through concrete diplomatic measures in order to gain credibility (Huang & Wang, 2020). China's foreign policy will be enhanced and international partners' trust will grow with a more unified strategy that tackles issues related to territorial conflicts. In the end, China needs a coherent public diplomacy strategy that is based on reliable foreign policy procedures in order to successfully negotiate challenging geopolitical situations.
China's strategy for public diplomacy reveals a complex interaction between its achievements and challenges. Interestingly, the use of soft power instruments, like Confucius Institutes, has shown to be effective in promoting cross-cultural understanding and elevating China's stature internationally. In a same vein, the Belt and Road Initiative has produced economic benefits but is under investigation due to its geopolitical ramifications, which calls for careful navigating to allay worries. Although commendable in theory, concerns about openness and potential conflicts of interest have made China's vaccine diplomacy unpopular (Goldsmith, Horiuchi & Matush, 2021). This emphasizes how crucial it is for China to openly confront these issues in order to strengthen its reputation internationally. Human rights concerns are one persistent roadblock that seems to be encountered by critical voices and challenges alike. China's
efforts to improve its reputation internationally hinge on its ability to handle political sensitivity on this front. China needs to put genuine discussion and transparent involvement first in order to improve its standing internationally (Baser & Öztürk, 2021). It is crucial that both foreign 13
14
messaging and internal activities are consistent since any inconsistency could damage its reputation. China's public diplomacy methods are still being refined, but negotiating the difficult terrain of global perceptions will require a balanced and responsive approach.
Conclusion In summary, China's public diplomacy tactics show a sophisticated and changing strategy
meant to influence views abroad. The nation understands the value of reaching out to audiences around the world in addition to practicing traditional state-centric diplomacy. China's public diplomacy is complex, encompassing cultural activities, worldwide broadcasting, and educational exchanges. Positive international interaction has been facilitated by China's emphasis
on cultural diplomacy, as is demonstrated by programs like Confucius Institutes. But there are problems when artistic projects are seen as politically driven, which calls for careful consideration. International broadcasters who aim to provide a Chinese perspective on a global scale, like CGTN, are under fire for allegedly being biased and having state control. People-to-
people exchanges are promoted through educational exchange programs, which are a pillar of China's public diplomacy. However, worries about academic independence draw attention to the fine balance, especially inside Confucius Institutes.
China's public diplomacy has changed over time in response to difficulties and changes in
the world. Economic cooperation and infrastructure development are demonstrated by China's projects such as the Belt and Road Initiative, which represent a shift from state-centric approaches to a more broad and proactive strategy. Building relationships with international players is the goal of major-power diplomacy, and cultural exchanges help people get a better knowledge of Chinese culture. Even with achievements, problems still exist. Concerns around human rights, censorship, and openness affect how effective China's public diplomacy is. The 14
15
strategy's legitimacy is called into question by the confrontational tone on social media, geopolitical concerns, and inconsistent dispute resolution practices. The central tenet that promotes global economic integration and cooperation is the Belt and Road Initiative. On the other hand, concerns about the effects on the environment and debt dependency highlight the necessity for cautious execution. China established itself as a responsible global player during the COVID-19 epidemic through its vaccine diplomacy. But problems with transparency and questions about motivations limited its impact. China needs to manage these challenges by addressing political sensitivities, improving openness, and coordinating domestic policies with foreign message. Achieving credibility and consistency will be essential to China's public diplomacy's long-term effectiveness in influencing favorable opinions around the world. Building long-lasting partnerships and promoting understanding on the international scene will need a proactive and flexible approach to public diplomacy, especially as China maintains its prominent position in world affairs.
15
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
16
References
Aoyama, R. (2022). Structural Changes in Chinese Foreign Policy: From “Prosperous Nation Diplomacy” to" Strong Nation Diplomacy".
Japan Review
,
4
(2), 79-90.
Asif, M. (2022). Confucius Institute as an instrument for the promotion of Chinese public and cultural diplomacy in Pakistan.
Asian Journal of Management, Entrepreneurship and Social Science
,
2
(03), 39-69.
Baser, B., & Öztürk, A. E. (2021). Positive and negative diaspora governance in context: From public diplomacy to transnational authoritarianism. In
Erdoğan’s Turkey
(pp. 80-95). Routledge.
Becard, D. S. R., & Menechelli, P. (2019). Chinese Cultural Diplomacy: instruments in China’s strategy for international insertion in the 21st Century.
Revista Brasileira de Política Internacional
,
62
.
Bjola, C., Cassidy, J., & Manor, I. (2019). Public diplomacy in the digital age.
The Hague Journal of Diplomacy
,
14
(1-2), 83-101.
Chang, C. C., & Yang, A. H. (2020). Weaponized Interdependence: China's Economic Statecraft and Social Penetration against Taiwan.
Orbis
,
64
(2), 312. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7102596/
Custer, S., Sethi, T., Solis, J. A., Lin, J. J., Ghose, S., Gupta, A., ... & Baehr, A. (2019). Silk Road Diplomacy.
Williamsburg, VA: AidData at William & Mary. https://docs. aiddata. org/ad4/pdfs/Silk_Road_Diplomacy_Report. pdf
.
d’Hooghe, I. (2011). The Expansion of China’ s Public Diplomacy System. In: Wang, J. (eds) Soft Power in China. Palgrave Macmillan Series in Global Public Diplomacy. Palgrave Macmillan, New York. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230116375_2
16
17
d'Hooghe, I. (01 Jan. 2015). China's Public Diplomacy. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill | Nijhoff.
https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004283954
Goldsmith, B. E., Horiuchi, Y., & Matush, K. (2021). Does public diplomacy sway foreign public opinion? Identifying the effect of high-level visits.
American Political Science Review
,
115
(4), 1342-1357.
Hessarbani Anja Lejli, (2011). PUBLIC DIPLOMACY of People’s Republic of China. Sarajevo School of Science and Technology.
https://www.culturaldiplomacy.org/academy/content/pdf/participant-papers/2011-
symposium/Public-Diplomacy-of-People's-Republic-of-China-Anja-L-Hessarbani.pdf
Huang, Z. A., & Wang, R. (2020). ‘Panda engagement’in China’s digital public diplomacy.
Asian Journal of Communication
,
30
(2), 118-140.
Huang, Z. A., & Wang, R. (2020). ‘Panda engagement’in China’s digital public diplomacy.
Asian Journal of Communication
,
30
(2), 118-140.
Ingenhoff, D., Calamai, G., & Sevin, E. (2021). Key influencers in public diplomacy 2.0: A country-based social network analysis.
Social Media+ Society
,
7
(1), 2056305120981053.
Lee, S. T. (2021). Vaccine diplomacy: nation branding and China’s COVID-19 soft power play.
Place Branding and Public Diplomacy
, 1-15.
Rumi Aoyama. (2022). China’s Public Diplomacy. Waseda University. Retrieved from; https://crawford.anu.edu.au/pdf/ajrc/conferences/public_diplomacy/Aoyama.pdf
Schliebs, M., Bailey, H., Bright, J., & Howard, P. N. (2021). China's public diplomacy operations: understanding engagement and inauthentic amplifications of PRC diplomats on Facebook and Twitter.
17
18
USC Center on Public Diplomacy. (2012). China and Public Diplomacy: A CPD reader. Retrieved from; https://www.diplomacy.edu/resource/china-and-public-diplomacy-a-cpd-
reader/
Wang, Y. (2008). Public Diplomacy and the Rise of Chinese Soft Power. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 616(1), 257-273. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716207312757
Xu, L. (2021). The Southern Film Corporation, opera films and the PRC's cultural diplomacy in Cold War Asia, 1950s–1960s 1. In
Chineseness and the Cold War
(pp. 25-44). Routledge. Yang, Y. (2020). Looking inward: How does Chinese public diplomacy work at home? The British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 22(3), 369-386. https://doi.org/10.1177/1369148120917583
18
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help