Statistics: The Art and Science of Learning from Data (4th Edition)
4th Edition
ISBN: 9780321997838
Author: Alan Agresti, Christine A. Franklin, Bernhard Klingenberg
Publisher: PEARSON
expand_more
expand_more
format_list_bulleted
Concept explainers
Textbook Question
Chapter 11.5, Problem 41PB
Keeping old dogs mentally sharp In an experiment with beagles ages 7–11, the dogs attempted to learn how to find a treat under a certain black-colored block and then relearn that task with a white-colored block. The control group of dogs received standard care and diet. The diet and exercise group were given dog food fortified with vegetables and citrus pulp and vitamin E and C supplements plus extra exercise and social play. All 12 dogs in the diet and exercise group were able to solve the entire task, but only 2 of the 8 dogs in the control group could do so. (Background material from N. W. Milgram et al., Neurobiology of Aging, vol. 26,2005, pp. 77–90.)
- a. Show how to summarize the results in a
contingency table . - b. Conduct all steps of Fisher’s exact test of the hypothesis that whether a dog can solve the task is independent of the treatment group. Use the two-sided alternative hypothesis. Interpret.
- c. Why is it improper to conduct the chi-squared test for these data?
Expert Solution & Answer
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionStudents have asked these similar questions
Determine whether the study depicts an observational study or an experimental study.
A study was done to see if sugar consumption can cause hypoeractivity in children. The researcher took four groups of children and assigned different amounts of sugar the children had to consume. After a certain period of time, they assessed whether or not the children were hyperactive.
Do people feel hungrier after sampling a healthy food? The authors of a consumer research paper carried out a study to answer this question. They
randomly assigned volunteers into one of three groups. The people in the first group were asked to taste a snack that was described as a new
health bar containing high levels of protein, vitamins, and fiber. The people in the second group were asked to taste the same snack but were told it
was a tasty chocolate bar with a raspberry center. After tasting the snack, participants were asked to rate their hunger level on a scale from 1 (not
at all hungry) to 7 (very hungry). The people in the third group were asked to rate their hunger but were not given a snack.
The data in the table are consistent with summary quantities given in the paper (although the sample sizes in the actual study were larger).
Treatment
Group
Healthy
Tasty
5 8 7
Hunger Rating
No Snack 3 4
4
4 1 4 2
7 3
6
2
5 6 5 5
4 7
5
2
3
4
6
4
4
Sample
Mean
5.6667
3.4444
4.2222
Sample…
Do people feel hungrier after sampling a healthy food? The authors of a consumer research paper carried out a study to answer this question. They randomly assigned volunteers into one of three groups. The people in the first group were asked to taste a snack that was described as a new health bar containing high levels of protein, vitamins, and fiber. The people in the second group were asked to taste the same snack but were told it was a tasty chocolate bar with a raspberry center. After tasting the snack, participants were asked to rate their hunger level on a scale from 1 (not at all hungry) to 7 (very hungry). The people in the third group were asked to rate their hunger but were not given a snack.
The data in the table are consistent with summary quantities given in the paper (although the sample sizes in the actual study were larger).
TreatmentGroup
Hunger Rating
SampleMean
SampleStandardDeviation
Healthy
5
8
7
4
7
3
4
7
6
5.6667
1.7321
Tasty
4
1
5
2
6
2
5
3
4
3.5556…
Chapter 11 Solutions
Statistics: The Art and Science of Learning from Data (4th Edition)
Ch. 11.1 - Gender gap in politics? In the United States, is...Ch. 11.1 - Prob. 2PBCh. 11.1 - Williams College admission Data from 2013 posted...Ch. 11.1 - Prob. 4PBCh. 11.1 - Marital happiness and income In the GSS, subjects...Ch. 11.1 - What is independent of happiness? Which one of the...Ch. 11.1 - Sample evidence about independence Refer to the...Ch. 11.2 - Life after death and gender In the 2012 GSS, 605...Ch. 11.2 - Happiness and gender For the 2 3 table on gender...Ch. 11.2 - Prob. 10PB
Ch. 11.2 - Marital happiness and income In Exercise 11.5 when...Ch. 11.2 - First and second free throw independent? In pro...Ch. 11.2 - Cigarettes and marijuana The table on the...Ch. 11.2 - Prob. 14PBCh. 11.2 - Help the environment In 2010 the GSS asked whether...Ch. 11.2 - Prob. 16PBCh. 11.2 - Aspirin and heart attacks A Swedish study used...Ch. 11.2 - z test for heart attack study Refer to the...Ch. 11.2 - Severity of fever after flu shot The study...Ch. 11.2 - Prob. 20PBCh. 11.2 - Testing a genetic theory In an experiment on...Ch. 11.2 - Birthdays by quarters Based on a random sample of...Ch. 11.2 - Checking a roulette wheel Karl Pearson devised the...Ch. 11.3 - Democrat, race, and gender The two tables show...Ch. 11.3 - Death penalty associations Table 11.10, summarized...Ch. 11.3 - Smoking and alcohol The table refers to a survey...Ch. 11.3 - Sex of victim and offender For murders in the...Ch. 11.3 - Smelling and mortality A recent study (Pinto et...Ch. 11.3 - Vioxx In September 2004, the pharmaceutical...Ch. 11.3 - Egg and cell derived vaccine When comparing the...Ch. 11.3 - Risk of dying for teenagers According to...Ch. 11.3 - Marital happiness The table shows 2012 GSS data on...Ch. 11.3 - Party ID and gender The table shows the 2012 GSS...Ch. 11.3 - Chi-squared versus measuring association For the...Ch. 11.4 - Standardized residuals for happiness and income...Ch. 11.4 - Prob. 36PBCh. 11.4 - Prob. 37PBCh. 11.4 - Prob. 38PBCh. 11.4 - Prob. 39PBCh. 11.4 - Prob. 40PBCh. 11.5 - Keeping old dogs mentally sharp In an experiment...Ch. 11.5 - Prob. 43PBCh. 11.5 - Prob. 44PBCh. 11.5 - Prob. 46PBCh. 11 - Female for president? When recent General Social...Ch. 11 - Prob. 48CPCh. 11 - Down and chi-squared For the data in the previous...Ch. 11 - Prob. 50CPCh. 11 - Prob. 51CPCh. 11 - Prob. 52CPCh. 11 - Prob. 53CPCh. 11 - Prob. 54CPCh. 11 - Prob. 55CPCh. 11 - Prob. 56CPCh. 11 - Seat belt helps? The table refers to passengers in...Ch. 11 - Prob. 58CPCh. 11 - Prob. 59CPCh. 11 - Prob. 60CPCh. 11 - Prob. 61CPCh. 11 - Prob. 62CPCh. 11 - Prob. 63CPCh. 11 - Prob. 64CPCh. 11 - Clarity of diamonds Does the clarity of a diamond...Ch. 11 - Benfords Law When looking at a collection of...Ch. 11 - Prob. 67CPCh. 11 - Prob. 68CPCh. 11 - Prob. 70CPCh. 11 - Prob. 71CPCh. 11 - Prob. 72CPCh. 11 - Prob. 73CPCh. 11 - Prob. 74CPCh. 11 - Prob. 75CPCh. 11 - Prob. 76CPCh. 11 - Prob. 77CPCh. 11 - Prob. 78CPCh. 11 - Prob. 79CPCh. 11 - Statistical versus practical significance In any...Ch. 11 - Prob. 81CPCh. 11 - Multiple response variables Each subject in a...Ch. 11 - Standardized residuals for 2 2 tables The table...Ch. 11 - Prob. 84CPCh. 11 - Prob. 85CPCh. 11 - Prob. 86CPCh. 11 - Prob. 87CPCh. 11 - Prob. 88CPCh. 11 - Voting with 16 A recent survey of Austrian high...
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, statistics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Similar questions
- Do people feel hungrier after sampling a healthy food? The authors of a consumer research paper carried out a study to answer this question. They randomly assigned volunteers into one of three groups. The people in the first group were asked to taste a snack that was billed as a new health bar containing high levels of protein, vitamins, and fiber. The people in the second group were asked to taste the same snack but were told it was a tasty chocolate bar with a raspberry center. After tasting the snack, participants were asked to rate their hunger level on a scale from 1 (not at all hungry) to 7 (very hungry). The people in the third group were asked to rate their hunger but were not given a snack. The data in the table are consistent with summary quantities given in the paper (although the sample sizes in the actual study were larger). Find the test statistic and P-value. (Use technology. Round your test statistic to two decimal places and your P-value to three decimal places.)…arrow_forwardDo people feel hungrier after sampling a healthy food? The authors of a consumer research paper carried out a study to answer this question. They randomly assigned volunteers into one of three groups. The people in the first group were asked to taste a snack that was billed as a new health bar containing high levels of protein, vitamins, and fiber. The people in the second group were asked to taste the same snack but were told it was a tasty chocolate bar with a raspberry center. After tasting the snack, participants were asked to rate their hunger level on a scale from 1 (not at all hungry) to 7 (very hungry). The people in the third group were asked to rate their hunger but were not given a snack. The data in the table are consistent with summary quantities given in the paper (although the sample sizes in the actual study were larger). Treatment Group Hunger Rating Sample Mean Sample Standard Deviation Healthy 5 7 7 4 7 3 4 7 6 5.6 1.59 Tasty 4 1 5 2 6 2 5 3 4 3.6 1.67 No Snack 3 4 5…arrow_forwardMany students at Matt's school claim they can think more clearly while listening to their favorite kind of music. Matt thinks music interferes with thinking clearly. To test this, he recruits 84 volunteers and randomly assigns them to two groups. The “Music” group listens to their favorite music while playing a “matching” memory game. The “No Music” group plays the same game in silence. Below are summary statistics for the number of turns it took each subject to complete the game (fewer turns indicates a better performance). (a) Is there convincing evidence that listening to music increases the number of turns required to finish the memory game? (b) Suppose Matt allowed people to choose whether or not they were in the group that listened to music while playing the game? Give an example of a problem that might arise if the subjects were allowed to do this.arrow_forward
- A phamaceutical company wants to test the effectiveness of a new allergy drug. The company identifies 250 females 30-35 years old who suffer from severe allergies. The subjects are randomly assigned into two groups. One group is given the new allergy drug and the other is given a placebo that looks exactly like the new allergy drug. After six months, the subjects' symptoms are studied and compared. Answer parts (a) through (c) below. O B. The experimental units are the symptoms from the drug. The treatment is the new allergy drug. O C. The experimental unit is the new allergy drug. The treatments are the severe allergies the patients suffer from. O D. The experimental units are the 30- to 35-year-old females being given the treatment. The treatment is the new allergy drug. (b) Identify a potential problem with the experiment design being used and suggest a way to improve it. Choose the correct answer below. O A. There may be a bias on the part of the patients since they do not know if…arrow_forwardIn a study of reading comprehension, sixth grade students read a short story about baseball. The students are divided into two groups based on their knowledge of baseball. Within each group, half of the students are high scorers on a test of verbal IQ, while the remaining students are low scorers. She found: Low baseball High baseball Low IQ-V 20 25 High IQ-V 20 30 Which is a correct interpretation of the results? Higher levels of baseball knowledge improves reading comprehension. This effect is weaker for those with high verbal IQs. Higher levels of baseball knowledge improves reading comprehension. This effect is stronger for those with high verbal IQs. The direction of the effect of baseball knowledge changes in direction from participants wit low IQ to participants with high IQ. there are no main effects and no interactions.arrow_forwardDoes the example represent an observational study or an experiment? Car accident data is obtained from the Ohio database. It is found that more accidents happened at night.arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Glencoe Algebra 1, Student Edition, 9780079039897...AlgebraISBN:9780079039897Author:CarterPublisher:McGraw HillHolt Mcdougal Larson Pre-algebra: Student Edition...AlgebraISBN:9780547587776Author:HOLT MCDOUGALPublisher:HOLT MCDOUGALCollege Algebra (MindTap Course List)AlgebraISBN:9781305652231Author:R. David Gustafson, Jeff HughesPublisher:Cengage Learning
Glencoe Algebra 1, Student Edition, 9780079039897...
Algebra
ISBN:9780079039897
Author:Carter
Publisher:McGraw Hill
Holt Mcdougal Larson Pre-algebra: Student Edition...
Algebra
ISBN:9780547587776
Author:HOLT MCDOUGAL
Publisher:HOLT MCDOUGAL
College Algebra (MindTap Course List)
Algebra
ISBN:9781305652231
Author:R. David Gustafson, Jeff Hughes
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Sampling Methods and Bias with Surveys: Crash Course Statistics #10; Author: CrashCourse;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rf-fIpB4D50;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
Statistics: Sampling Methods; Author: Mathispower4u;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6ApdTvgvOs;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY