Rhetorical Strategies in Gay.edited
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Nairobi Institute of Technology - Westlands *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
MISC
Subject
Arts Humanities
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
3
Uploaded by dannetke
Surname 1
Analyzing the Rhetorical Strategies in Gay's "The Illusion of Safety”
Student
Institution
Professor
Date
Introduction
In Roxane Gay's essay "The Illusion of Safety/The Safety of Illusion," the author tackles
the complex and nuanced topic of Safety, examining how society's obsession with the illusion of
Safety perpetuates harmful narratives. This analysis will evaluate the rhetorical strategies
employed by Gay, including an assessment of the context and rhetorical situation and a close
analysis of the rhetorical appeals—ethos, pathos, and logos—used to support her argument.
Gay's stance in the essay revolves around critiquing the societal obsession with Safety
and highlighting its detrimental consequences (
Luhmann, 73)
. She argues that pursuing an
illusionary notion of Safety hinders progress and perpetuates inequality, urging readers to
question and challenge existing power structures and social norms. Gay successfully develops
and supports her case through a variety of techniques. She crafts a compelling tale that connects
readers through colorful language, recurrent phrases, and real-world situations.
Ethos
Through the disclosure of her own experiences and points of view, Gay demonstrates her
expertise and trustworthiness, therefore enabling readers to form an emotional connection with
her. Her treatment of real-world incidents, such as the massacres at Columbine and Sandy Hook,
generates a feeling of immediacy and highlights the need to do an in-depth analysis of security.
Surname 2
Pathos
The author utilizes emotional appeals to evoke empathy and concern in the reader. She
uses powerful metaphors and analogies, such as describing Safety as a "gossamer shroud" and
"façade of comfort," to convey the fragility and superficiality of the notion of Safety. These
metaphors elicit an emotional response and prompt readers to question their understanding of
Safety.
Logos
Gay employs logical reasoning and evidence to support her argument. She provides
statistics and examples of how the illusion of Safety can be detrimental, such as the racial
profiling certain communities in the name of security. By appealing to logic, she highlights the
flaws in the prevailing notion of Safety and encourages readers to critically analyze its
implications.
One key passage encapsulates Gay's argument: "Safety is an optical illusion (
Luhmann,
73)
. There are a thousand ways to die, and we are lucky if we only die once." This statement
challenges the conventional idea of Safety and exposes its inherent limitations. By highlighting
the inevitability of death and the multitude of risks we face daily, Gay effectively questions the
illusion of Safety. Recurring phrases, such as "illusory safety," "safe spaces," and "threat to our
safety," emphasize the central theme of the essay and reinforce the notion that Safety is a
construct that often masks deeper societal issues.
To show the harmful effects of emphasizing Safety above all other concerns, Gay uses
real-world instances, such as the terrorist events of September 11, 2001, and the heightened
monitoring of historically neglected populations. The tangible evidence strengthens her
assertions these instances show, contributing to her argument's overall persuasiveness.
Surname 3
Gay's message is highly effective due to her adept use of rhetorical strategies. By
employing ethos, pathos, and logos, she appeals to readers' emotions, intellect, and empathy
(
Luhmann, 73)
. The personal anecdotes and real-world examples create a sense of authenticity
and urgency, compelling readers to reflect critically on their understanding of Safety.
Furthermore, the essay's structure and language are engaging, capturing and maintaining the
reader's attention. The combination of strong arguments, vivid imagery, and rhetorical appeals
effectively conveys Gay's stance and encourages readers to challenge prevailing societal
narratives.
In conclusion, Roxane Gay's essay "The Illusion of Safety/The Safety of Illusion"
effectively utilizes rhetorical strategies to challenge the prevailing notion of Safety. Using ethos,
pathos, and logos strategically, Gay establishes her credibility, evokes emotional responses, and
presents logical reasoning to support her argument. The essay's powerful metaphors, real-world
examples, and recurring phrases enhance the persuasiveness of her message, urging readers to
critically examine the illusion of Safety. By questioning societal norms and emphasizing the
detrimental consequences of prioritizing Safety above all else, Gay successfully encourages
readers to reevaluate their understanding of Safety and consider the broader implications of this
obsession.
Work Cited
Luhmann, Susanne. "Un-settling Queer Pedagogy–The Illusion of 'Safe Space.'
"
Queering MINT: Impulse für eine dekonstruktive Lehrer_innenbildung
(2016): 73.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help