Based on the phylogentic tree attached Question 1 The placement of Melibe digitata and Melibe viridis is: a) Suspicious because long branch attraction may be a factor b) Suspicious because the branch is not fully shown c) Suspicious because it belongs to an unresolved clade with Cuthonia divae and Lomanotus sp. E d) Not suspicious because it has a Bayesian posterior probability of the maximum 1 Question 2 The estimate of phylogenetic relationships of Marionia sp. 10 is sufficient evidence on which to base its status as a distinct species: a) Clearly, yes b) Clearly, no c) Maybe, but it depends on the bootstrap support uniting two samples on the tree d) Maybe, but it depends on evidence from other data sources Question 3 The sister group of Tritoniopsis alba with three asterisks to its right-hand side is: a) Tritoniopsis sp. b) Both Tritoniopsis sp. c) Tritoniopsis alba (without asterisks) d) Tritoniopsis frydis e) Both Tritoniopsis sp. and Tritoniopsis alba (without asterisks), and Tritoniopsis frydis

Aquaculture Science
3rd Edition
ISBN:9781133558347
Author:Parker
Publisher:Parker
Chapter4: Management Practices For Finfish
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 10E
icon
Related questions
icon
Concept explainers
Question

Based on the phylogentic tree attached

Question 1 The placement of Melibe digitata and Melibe viridis is:

a) Suspicious because long branch attraction may be a factor

b) Suspicious because the branch is not fully shown

c) Suspicious because it belongs to an unresolved clade with Cuthonia divae and Lomanotus sp. E

d) Not suspicious because it has a Bayesian posterior probability of the maximum 1

Question 2 The estimate of phylogenetic relationships of Marionia sp. 10 is sufficient evidence on which to base its status as a distinct species:

a) Clearly, yes

b) Clearly, no

c) Maybe, but it depends on the bootstrap support uniting two samples on the tree

d) Maybe, but it depends on evidence from other data sources

Question 3 The sister group of Tritoniopsis alba with three asterisks to its right-hand side is:

a) Tritoniopsis sp.

b) Both Tritoniopsis sp.

c) Tritoniopsis alba (without asterisks)

d) Tritoniopsis frydis

e) Both Tritoniopsis sp. and Tritoniopsis alba (without asterisks), and Tritoniopsis frydis

.82
.75
.97
.67
.86
.55
.82
.99
55
74
.99
-Bathydoris aioca
1
99
1
Berthella martensi
.98
75
74
H
.91
.91
1
H
.91
.91
.99
1
1
77
-Babakina anadoni
1
1
Aeolidia papillosa
Aeolidiella alderi
Caloria elegans
-Pruvotfolia longicirrha
-Pruvotfolia pselliotes
Favorinus branchialis
Favorinus elenalexiarum
-Phyllodesmium macphersonae
Phyllodesmium parangatum
Sakuraeolis enosimensis
Caloria indica
Flabellina exoptata
Flabellina pedata
1
-Piseinotecus gaditanus
Piseinotecus sp
1
-Dermatobranchus sp 21
Cuthona divae
Lomanotus sp E
1 Notobryon thompsoni
Notobryon wardi
Scyllaea pelagica
Dirona albolineata
Armina semperi
Armina sp E
Doto coronata
Doto koenneckeri
Hancockia californica
Dendronotus frondosus
Dendronotus regius
-Leminda millecra
Marionia arborescens
Marionia arborescens
Marionia sp
Marionia sp 6
Marionia distincta
Marionia distincta
Marionia sp 5
Marionia sp 10.
Marionia sp 10
Marionia sp 10
Marionia levis
Marionia levis
1-Marionia sp 3
-Tritonia sp 4
Marionia blainvillea
Marionia sp
Tritoniid 189311C
Tritoniid 189311B
Tritoniid 189311A
Tritoniid 189459
Tritonia sp 2
Tritoniid 189262A
Tritonia sp
Tritonia sp 1
1 Tritonia sp
Tritonia sp
- Marianina rosea
Tritoniopsis sp
Tritoniopsis sp
Tritonopsilla alba
Tritoniopsis frydis
-Tritonopsilla alba ***
Tritoniid 189419
Tritonia antarctica
Tritonia antarctica
Tritonia festiva
Tritonia sp
Tritonia sp
-Tritonia sp F
Tritonia nilsodhneri
Tritonia nilsodhneri
Tritonia nilsodhneri
-Tritonia nilsodhneri
1 Tritonia hamnerorum
1Tritonia hamnerorum
1
Tritoniidae
Melibe digitata
Trivettea papalotla
-Melibe viridis
Tritonia pickensi
-Tritonia pickensi
Trivettea papalotla
Bornella calcarata
Bornella stellifer
-Chromodoris fentoni
Tambja marbellensis
4
Figure 3. Phylogeny of concatenated mitochondrial 16S rRNA, cytochrome c oxidase 1 and
nuclear histone 3 for tritoniid cladobranchs including Trivettea papalotla. Bayesian posterior
probabilities are shown above branches. Branch length of the Melibe clade is ~2.3 relative to
scale bar. Source: Invertebrate Systematics 29(3) 215-222
http://dx.doi.org/10.1071/IS15002. The three asterisks relate to Question 10 part 6.
Cladobranchia
Transcribed Image Text:.82 .75 .97 .67 .86 .55 .82 .99 55 74 .99 -Bathydoris aioca 1 99 1 Berthella martensi .98 75 74 H .91 .91 1 H .91 .91 .99 1 1 77 -Babakina anadoni 1 1 Aeolidia papillosa Aeolidiella alderi Caloria elegans -Pruvotfolia longicirrha -Pruvotfolia pselliotes Favorinus branchialis Favorinus elenalexiarum -Phyllodesmium macphersonae Phyllodesmium parangatum Sakuraeolis enosimensis Caloria indica Flabellina exoptata Flabellina pedata 1 -Piseinotecus gaditanus Piseinotecus sp 1 -Dermatobranchus sp 21 Cuthona divae Lomanotus sp E 1 Notobryon thompsoni Notobryon wardi Scyllaea pelagica Dirona albolineata Armina semperi Armina sp E Doto coronata Doto koenneckeri Hancockia californica Dendronotus frondosus Dendronotus regius -Leminda millecra Marionia arborescens Marionia arborescens Marionia sp Marionia sp 6 Marionia distincta Marionia distincta Marionia sp 5 Marionia sp 10. Marionia sp 10 Marionia sp 10 Marionia levis Marionia levis 1-Marionia sp 3 -Tritonia sp 4 Marionia blainvillea Marionia sp Tritoniid 189311C Tritoniid 189311B Tritoniid 189311A Tritoniid 189459 Tritonia sp 2 Tritoniid 189262A Tritonia sp Tritonia sp 1 1 Tritonia sp Tritonia sp - Marianina rosea Tritoniopsis sp Tritoniopsis sp Tritonopsilla alba Tritoniopsis frydis -Tritonopsilla alba *** Tritoniid 189419 Tritonia antarctica Tritonia antarctica Tritonia festiva Tritonia sp Tritonia sp -Tritonia sp F Tritonia nilsodhneri Tritonia nilsodhneri Tritonia nilsodhneri -Tritonia nilsodhneri 1 Tritonia hamnerorum 1Tritonia hamnerorum 1 Tritoniidae Melibe digitata Trivettea papalotla -Melibe viridis Tritonia pickensi -Tritonia pickensi Trivettea papalotla Bornella calcarata Bornella stellifer -Chromodoris fentoni Tambja marbellensis 4 Figure 3. Phylogeny of concatenated mitochondrial 16S rRNA, cytochrome c oxidase 1 and nuclear histone 3 for tritoniid cladobranchs including Trivettea papalotla. Bayesian posterior probabilities are shown above branches. Branch length of the Melibe clade is ~2.3 relative to scale bar. Source: Invertebrate Systematics 29(3) 215-222 http://dx.doi.org/10.1071/IS15002. The three asterisks relate to Question 10 part 6. Cladobranchia
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Phylogenetics
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, biology and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Aquaculture Science
Aquaculture Science
Biology
ISBN:
9781133558347
Author:
Parker
Publisher:
Cengage