Code Krishna (4) 21st Nov (1)
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Fliedner College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
301
Subject
Management
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
14
Uploaded by EarlRoseNewt10
Case Study- Individual
Report
CASE STUDY: CRANES LIMITED
Name of the Student:
Student’s Identification Number:
Module Name and ID:
Date of Submission:
Name of the University:
1 | P a g e
Executive Summary
The UK-based Cranes Limited Company is a division of the Kenyan RCT Group. It
provides small- to medium-sized businesses (SME's) with investment property
money. The company is currently having cash flow problems and is very reliant on
the parent company. Cranes Limited is thinking about starting new businesses to
grow the company and raise the necessary money in the UK or Europe. It is thinking
about launching a new information system called the Suite as well as a premier
centre that offers two new service package types: the professional level and the
basic level. The projects are anticipated to bring in money for the company.
2 | P a g e
Table of Contents
Introduction
...................................................................................................................
4
Sources of Funding
.......................................................................................................
4
Investment Proposals
...................................................................................................
6
Management Tools- Budget & BEP Use
......................................................................
7
Company’s Performance Evaluation
............................................................................
9
Budget & Breakeven Value Importance
.......................................................................
9
Some other problems that the Management should consider
...................................
11
Recommendations and Conclusion
............................................................................
11
References
.................................................................................................................
13
3 | P a g e
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Introduction
Due to cash flow issues, Cranes Limited is thinking about taking on additional
projects. If investing in initiatives doesn't seem to be viable, businesses that are
having trouble making ends meet may look for alternative sources of finance. The
breakeven analysis, budgeting, and net present value are suitable methods for
determining whether a project is worthwhile. The project's net present value tells
whether the corporation will gain anything from it. Other methods of investment
appraisal do, however, exist. The breakeven analysis reveals how many goods and
how much sales are needed before the business starts turning a profit. The budgets
are a useful tool for forecasting profits because they represent the expected inflow
and outflow of funds over a given time period (Caprio and Demirgüç-Kunt, 2021).
Even if there are other methods for evaluating projects, the net present value,
breakeven analysis, and cash budgeting will be specifically utilized to evaluate
Cranes constrained projects, and their significance will be covered in great detail.
Additionally, additional funding options for Cranes Limited Sources of Funding
Sources
Disadvantages
Advantages
Bank Loan
The company must be
profitable in order to
qualify for a loan from the
bank; otherwise, the bank
will not provide loans to
such businesses, which
are extremely uncommon
with start-ups.
Due to the possibility of
business relationships with
banks, bank loans are
regarded as a simple way
of finance.
Additionally, compared to
certain alternative forms of
funding, bank loans are
typically less expensive
(Xu, 2021).
Venture Capitalists
The major drawback is
that each company will
have to give up a portion
of its profits or ownership
to the investors.
As the most potential
source of finance, this
technique is currently
acquiring a lot of appeal.
Since capital can only be
4 | P a g e
Additionally, since investor
opinions and business
objectives may diverge,
there may be a conflict of
interest
(Castillo
and
Guasch, 2021).
Finding suitable venture
capitalists is a challenging
task, and it might mean
making changes to the
company because their
objectives might differ
from yours and they might
put pressure on you to
adjust some things.
raised up to a specific
level through other means,
a significant sum can be
raised from this source.
The majority of venture
capitalists are well-known
individuals with extensive
knowledge in a variety of
fields; this opens up new
networking opportunities
and provides experienced
advice.
Own Capital
Shared ownership exists,
and
investors
might
anticipate a portion of the
company's
earnings.
Preference shares receive
payment preference over
equity shares if funds are
generated in the form of
preference shares.
There is no loan involved
with this that the business
must repay. This makes it
the simplest approach. As
a result, the business is
not required to pay any
monthly interest.
Creditworthiness is not a
concern
with
this
approach.
The methods for one company to raise money are covered in the discussion above.
These are not the only ways to raise money; there are other ways as well, such as
borrowing money from family or friends or acquiring bank overdraft advances (Drury,
2005). Every one of the aforementioned methods has pros and cons, so when a
business is choosing a funding source, it should always weigh both the advantages
and disadvantages. Raising capital is a significant decision for any business
5 | P a g e
organization, so the best strategies that are appropriate for the business should be
chosen based on this.
Investment Proposals
Payback Period Technique
This method identifies the incoming cash flows and determines if the invested funds
will be recovered during the investment's lifetime. Using the payback period or
discounted payback period is not very effective in this situation because the present
value computation plainly demonstrates that the initial investment exceeds the
present worth of everything.
Limitation
The main flaw in this approach is that the time value of money theory is not taken
into consideration, which renders it untrustworthy for decision-making.
Net Present Value
The High-End Suite project by Cranes Limited has a negative net present value. In
the first and fifth years, the corporation records negative present value data, whereas
the remaining years record positive present value figures. The initiative should be
rejected by management because it won't benefit the business in any way(Götze et
al.,
2007). As the parent company does not cover the initial cost of the investment
and cannot be used to raise capital, Cranes Limited no longer needs money from it.
The profitability of a project is calculated by estimating the difference between the
present value of cash inflows and outflows over time. In order to help people make
wise decisions, this method compares the value of time and money.
Limitation
The main flaw in this strategy is the need to calculate the return rate, which is difficult
because either a higher or lower rate could give a false impression of a project's
profitability and result in sloppy decision-making.
6 | P a g e
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Internal Rate of Return
When evaluating investments, the internal rate of return technique might be helpful.
Over the course of the project, it is the overall rate of return. When the calculated
internal rate of return exceeds the cost of capital, the project will be increasing the
owner's wealth. However, this approach has some drawbacks
: It is a relative metric and does not
provide an absolute measure to draw conclusions; It does not account for the
duration of the new project or the quantity of the investment; It takes into account a
project's long-term sustainability while ignoring any immediate losses that may occur;
it makes no mention of the gain or fall in shareholder wealth.
The internal rate of return gives an estimate, and since there is a difference between
it and the required rate of return, it may be inaccurate and lead decision-makers
astray. Additionally, there are situations in which the internal rate of return does not
always support wealth maximization (Aryasri, 2021). Another significant drawback of
this approach is that it makes the unrealistic assumption that the generated cash
flow surplus can be used to fund an investment with a positive internal rate of return.
Management Tools- Budget & BEP Use
The top management employs management tools to discover various challenges
that are present in a given project and make the necessary adjustments for a better
outcome. The management can use these tools to help with project planning,
execution, management, and control (Holland, 2021). These tools enable
management to spot gaps in the organization's processes, and as a result,
management can utilize the knowledge to make adjustments that will improve the
efficiency of ongoing activities.
The budget is designed to track the company's cash flow, which will aid in tracking
the influx and outflow of cash and, in turn, aid in better liquidity management. If a
corporation has a high level of liquidity, it will be considerably better able to manage
its operations (Nyarombe et al
., 2021). This allows for the identification of
misappropriated cash flow, which can then be best utilised to increase the value of
the company.
7 | P a g e
A BEP point is the point at which a specific quantity of sold goods is not recorded as
having generated a profit or loss. Cranes Limited can be leaner and use these
resources to eventually reach a certain sales volume if Cranes Limited realize this
before create a product.
Computation of Breakeven Analysis and the Cash Budget
Break Even Point
Particulars
BP (in £)
TP (in £)
Sales Price (per unit)
300
410
Variable Cost (per unit)
-170
-210
Contribution (per unit)
130
200
Fixed cost
123, 400
123,400
Break Even
Point
(Fixed cost
÷
Contribution (per unit))
949.23
617.00
Cash Budget
Month
Janurary
(in £)
Feburary
(in £)
March (in
£)
Sales (in Cash) of BP & TP (60%)
99900.00
99900.00
99900.00
Next month sales (in Cash) of BP & TP
(40%)
-
66600.00
66600.00
Variable Expense
-BP
59500.00
59500.00
59500.00
-TP
31500.00
31500.00
31500.00
Fixed Expense (per month)
41133.00
41133.00
41133.00
Closing Cash Flow
-32,233.00
34,367.00
34,367.00
8 | P a g e
Company’s Performance Evaluation
It is noteworthy that the corporation would report negative current value data for the
first and last years in the High-End Suite. This might be the case because in the first
year, rising overhead costs and working capital were anticipated while the selling
price was not. As a result, in the first year, there is not enough revenue to pay for the
higher overheads. Because all of the working capital was expected to be recovered
this year, the negative present values from the previous year may have been
realized.
They can rely on money for long-term survival and break their reliance on the parent
firm because the project doesn't seem to be highly profitable. As a result, the
business must keep considering its choices for introducing new items. This is based
on a break-even analysis by Premier Center. The cash inflow at the end of the period
is shown in the cash budget. The Premier Center project could therefore be
advantageous for the business.
Budget & Breakeven Value Importance
According to a study by (Alnasser et al.,
2021), Success in planning and decision-
making in activity organisation and break-even analysis are statistically related. The
break-even point is the point at which expenses equal all contributions. The study's
findings support the use of break-even analysis as a crucial tool for making decisions
because it is efficient, precise, and significant. Break-even analysis is the most
crucial tool for managers to create and implement new projects, claims Patton's
essay from 2021. In order to effectively carry out projects that are deemed important
in a company's strategic plan, break-even analysis is allegedly helpful in identifying
expected revenues and expenses at a specific time. Break-even analysis revolves
around the link between volume, cost, and profit at a specific level. This method
ought to be applied to ascertain when and at what level of sales a business will begin
turning a profit. Cranes Limited Company can then determine whether the required
level is high and whether it is worthwhile to start selling the product. It reveals the
point at which the business would experience losses as well as the contribution
margin necessary to pay for its fixed expenses.
9 | P a g e
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Budgets
Budgets can be utilized for product mix decisions, financial decision-making, and
performance evaluation, according to a study by (Stevcevska-Srbinoska, 2021).
Even if the author notes the opposing viewpoints on budgeting, it is clear that it
benefits businesses more than it does harm. It emphasizes the value of budgets in
the planning, management, and coordination of corporate operations. (Lidia, 2021)
provides an example of how budgets can identify problems and prompt decision-
makers to take action. Additionally, it illustrates how budgets help to increase
efficient resource management. A valuable instrument for anticipating the inflow and
outflow of cash in a corporation is a budget, especially a cash budget. According to
an article by (Eton et al.,
2021), cash budgets make ensuring that business
expenses are in accordance with cash flows. Additionally, it makes it more likely that
extra cash will be detected. The individuals in charge of planning and making
decisions can then assess if there is sufficient intake to maintain the organization
through budgets. Budgets also help in estimating how much will be spent on
overhead and costs. Knowing these numbers will enable management to take action
to cut costs and overhead in the company. Budgets are crucial decision-making tools
for management because they forecast the amount of profit anticipated in a future
period.
Importance to Business
When this is accomplished, Cranes Limited will be able to pinpoint the exact
moment at which it breaks, either winning or losing. This makes it simple for
the business to decide how many units to sell. Sales below the break-even
point cause the company to lose money, while sales over the break-even
point for the company to make money (Omoshagba and Zubairu, 2021). Each
business will thereafter have access to the information required to produce its
goods. By scheduling the production of each product in advance, businesses
are able to allocate resources where they are needed.
The budget aids management in long-term planning and early project needs
evaluation so that the proper policies may be written and resources can be
distributed in accordance with those policies. In this sense, it is deemed to be
a crucial managerial tool for the company. Further monitoring can be done to
ensure that the procedure is being followed, and if there are any violations,
10 | P a g e
they can be fixed right away. Cash flow budgets will be created on a monthly,
quarterly, or annual basis so that undesirable cash flows can be identified and
used more effectively.
Some other problems that the Management should consider
Top management should also take into account a variety of additional factors or
matters in order to increase company profitability and assess its business
performance, such as:
Funding Sources
: The management needs to take very careful note of this
important problem. After carefully weighing the source's benefits and
drawbacks, choose the one that is most appropriate for your business. This
will aid in lowering the capital's risk in relation to the company.
Cost Composition
: Management should be mindful of the cost structure in
order to lower costs per unit produced, which will inevitably boost profitability.
That company's personnel should receive training to boost their motivation
and productivity, which will cut down on unproductive hours (Peterson and
Fabozzi, 2021).
Each business should seize every financial opportunity by applying the
financial evaluation method and making choices that will benefit the
shareholders.
Recommendations and Conclusion
The management needs to do market research and think about charging more up
front for the High-End Suite so that it won't influence customers' decisions and so
that it can be utilized to offset rising overhead costs. The business might start a
discount offer to entice customers to pay in cash right away rather than risk
becoming debtors. As long as the discount doesn't significantly lower revenues to the
point where they can't pay for costs or lower cash collections over the course of the
three months, this could increase the total inflow of cash during that time.
When compared to the High-End Suite, the Premier Center is the preferable choice
because it will result in a positive cash inflow for the company. Despite the relatively
high breakeven point, it will undoubtedly turn a profit from the sale of its goods at
11 | P a g e
both the basic and professional levels. Therefore, I would advise management to
move forward with the project for the premier center instead of the High-End Suite.
12 | P a g e
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
References
Alnasser, N., Shaban, O.S. and Al-Zubi, Z., 2021. The Effect of Using Break-
EvenPoint in Planning, Controlling, and Decision Making in the Industrial Jordanian
Companies. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social
Sciences, 4(5), p.626.
Aryasri, A.R., 2021. Managerial Economics and Financial Analysis. Tata McGraw-Hill
Education 3.
Caprio, G., and Demirgüç-Kunt, A., 2021. The Role of Long-Term Finance: Theory
and Evidence. The World Bank.
Castillo, L.L., and Guasch, J.L., 2021. Overdraft Facility Policy and Firm
Performance: An Empirical Analysis in Eastern European Union Industrial Firms. The
World Bank.
Drury, C., 2005. Management Accounting for Business. Cengage Learning EMEA
Eton, M., Mwosi, F., and Ogwel, P.B., 2021. Cash Budgeting and Organizational
Performance of Private Firms in Uganda: A Case of Kabale District, Western
Uganda.
Götze U, Northcott D, Schuster P 2007. Investment Appraisal Springer Science &
Business Media.
Holland, R., 2021. Break-Even Analysis. University of Tennessee
Lidia, T.G., 2021. Difficulties of the Budgeting Process and Factors Leading to The
Decision to Implement This Management Tool. Procedia Economics and Finance,
15, pp.466-473
Nyarombe, F., Kipyegon K., Kamar, I. and Gwaro., S., 2021. An Investigation of
Capital Budgeting Techniques on Performance: A Survey Of Selected Companies in
Eldoret Town.
13 | P a g e
Omoshagba, T.P., and Zubairu, U.M., 2021. A Systematic Review of the Field of
Debt Financing. Covenant Journal of Entrepreneurship, 1(3).
Patton, R.W., 2021. The Business Side.: In Health and Fitness. Breakeven Analysis
is an Important Business Planning Tool. ACSM's Health & Fitness Journal, 3(3),
p.36.
Peterson, P.P., and Fabozzi, F.J., 2021. Capital budgeting: Theory and Practice.
John Wiley & Sons.
Stevcevska-Srbinoska, D., 2021. The Advantages of Budgets: A Survey of
Macedonian Legal Entities. Business and Economic Research, 8(2), pp.33-55.
Xu, H., 2021, July. Using the Net Present Value Rule to Make Value-Creating
Investment Decisions. International Conference on Chemical, Material and Food
Engineering. Atlantis Press. 14 | P a g e
Related Documents
Recommended textbooks for you
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781285869681/9781285869681_smallCoverImage.gif)
Purchasing and Supply Chain Management
Operations Management
ISBN:9781285869681
Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. Patterson
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Recommended textbooks for you
- Purchasing and Supply Chain ManagementOperations ManagementISBN:9781285869681Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. PattersonPublisher:Cengage Learning
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781285869681/9781285869681_smallCoverImage.gif)
Purchasing and Supply Chain Management
Operations Management
ISBN:9781285869681
Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. Patterson
Publisher:Cengage Learning