Order #958382 Final
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Kabarak University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
RE
Subject
Communications
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
6
Uploaded by CountMosquitoPerson827
Surname 1
Student's Name
Course Name and Number
Professor's Name
Assignment's Due Date
Comparative analysis between Saving Private Ryan and The Thin Red Line
The American soldiers in Steven Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan are on a mission to
save Private Ryan, a paratrooper whose brothers were murdered in combat. The opening
scene, which shows the Normandy landings, is particularly notorious for the film's realistic
and brutal depiction of the horrors and carnage of war. Terrence Malick's The Thin Red Line
is an adaptation of James Jones's novel of the same name. Jones wrote the book based on his
experiences in the Pacific Theater during the Battle of Guadalcanal (Reuben, 770). The film
delves deeper into philosophical and lyrical themes than Saving Private Ryan by examining
the essence of life, death, and conflict through voice-over narration, natural images, and
metaphysical inquiries. The essay will examine Thematic factors such as battle, beauty,
brutality, and war is hell.
The Beauty
The Thin Red Line and Saving Private Ryan are two 1998 war pictures portraying
combat's brutality and beauty in radically different ways. Despite their stylistic and thematic
differences, both films are masterworks of war filmmaking. The Thin Red Line is more
philosophical and spiritual, but Saving Private Ryan is more grounded in reality and evokes
stronger emotions. In contrast to The Thin Red Line, which focuses on the existential and the
universal, Saving Private Ryan emphasizes the personal and the group (Reuben, 772). In
Saving Private Ryan, the horror and glory of war take center stage, but in The Thin Red Line,
the beauty and tragedy of war take center stage.
Surname 2
The traditional action picture Saving Private Ryan follows a squad of troops who risk
everything to save a paratrooper trapped behind enemy lines. As one of the most engrossing
and dramatic scenes in film history, the depiction of the D-Day landing on Omaha Beach is
notoriously accurate and brutal (Hasian, 338). Along with the camaraderie among the troops,
the film delves into the ethical problem of sacrificing many lives for the sake of a single one.
The movie Saving Private Ryan honors American troops' bravery and patriotism and depicts
war's horrors and pointlessness.
A more contemplative and lyrical picture, The Thin Red Line contrasts the brutality of
war with the splendor of nature and explores human nature. Based on the Pacific Theater's
Guadalcanal Battle, the film portrays a diverse cast of people through their varied battle
experiences (Reuben, 770). The characters ' internal monologues are more important than the
storyline and action, which the audience hears throughout the film. The film's breathtaking
editing and cinematography help to set a reflective and poetic tone while depicting the
balance and imbalance between humans and the natural world (Reuben, 772). The film The
Thin Red Line explores war, its goals, and the relative importance of chance and free choice.
The Battle
Both movies demonstrate how war gradually dehumanizes its victims, and they both
condemn the pointlessness and foolishness of going to war. After the explosive and bombastic
first verse, a more nuanced character story takes center stage in Saving Private Ryan. A
complex multi-racial group of soldiers instructs Private Upham (Jeremy Davies), a secondee
from Captain Miller's depleted company, on army life. Miller (Hanks) doesn't doubt the
motives behind Ryan's (apparently) pointless search, but he does display a clear sense of
resignation that he can't always perceive the bigger picture (Hasian, 340). The epic conflict
between the two films explores different aspects of the war: one depicts America's full-scale
involvement in Europe, and the other represents the psychological toll of the ongoing conflict
Surname 3
in the Pacific. The expedition to find Ryan, which Miller takes his troops on through the
French countryside, causes some subliminal hostility from his soldiers, who don't see why
they're putting so many lives on the line to save only one. Miller acknowledges the validity of
the point, but he must adhere to his instructions as an army man, regardless of how irrational
or foolish they may appear.
The Thin Red Line presents an alternative perspective on the pointlessness of war,
which delves further into the psychological toll that waging these conflicts has on the troops,
revealing how their humanity progressively depleted with each death and engagement.
Although James Caviezel's Private Witt makes several appearances and disappearances
throughout Red Line, he is the film's protagonist (Reuben, 772). Every military echelon, from
the chief of staff down to the lowest-ranking soldier, tells their narrative as the Guadalcanal
conflict escalates. Most of the line's impact comes from giving. Don't get me wrong—Line
has its fair share of flaws.
War is hell
Neither of the Steven Spielberg films allowed us to see the conflict from a soldier's
perspective. Filmmakers as varied as Oliver Stone and Francis Ford Coppola have given us
their takes, Two massive cinematic behemoths facing off against one another. Both feature an
enormous roster of famous actors and actresses, all competing for screen time and each
having a unique narrative. Both are set during WWII and hence were bloody, horrific battles
where only the strongest and bravest will survive. "All hands on deck!"
In Saving Private Ryan, the soldiers are pushed into the thick of combat amid the
chaos and horror of an unfathomable attack. It wished for us to experience the reality of battle
to the fullest. Another recluse filmmaker was likewise on a mission to expose the madness
and cruelty of war but at a different studio. Veteran filmmaker Terrence Malick, who went
into seclusion for over twenty years, returned with a slow-burning look at the psychological
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Surname 4
toll of serving in the Pacific Theater of WWII (Hasian, 353). Malick assembled a star-studded
ensemble to tell a narrative of tragedy, redemption, and the power of the human spirit set
against the breathtaking Pacific rainforests. Sean Penn and James Caviezel spearhead an
incredibly brilliant ensemble into combat in The Thin Red Line, which takes a far different
approach from Spielberg's darker attempt. Hence, we see the horrors of war through both
lenses (Reuben, 771).
The brutality
In the two movies, the boat's bow flings wide at the sound of a whistle, and the beach
explodes into massive gouts of sand and other body parts. As you make your way through the
barrage of bullets to a haven, the smell of gunpowder lingers in the air, and blood stains the
water (Hasian, 347). As they drag their internal organs from the ground, you can hear the
moans of the dying, which sound like whimpers from a toddler. The guys, who are grown
men, plead for their mothers.
After the opening sequence ends, Saving Private Ryan returns to its more
conventional plot as the remaining men, commanded by the unflappable Tom Hanks, are
ordered to locate a missing soldier in occupied France and return him home. The politically
charged quest to rescue the lost soldier, Private Ryan, began when he learned that his mother
should not be left without any children, even though he is ignorant that his three brothers had
been killed in combat (Hasian, 340). We meet the men of the battalion tasked with this
mission and learn about their courage and the bonds they form as they fight their way through
enemy lines. Striking a delicate balance between the individual soldier's struggles with his
anxieties and demons and the vast, unmanageable battlefield is a central theme in The Thin
Red Line (Reuben, 772). During this serene and picturesque setting, the unfathomable dread
of being completely alone is at its core, as are the mental challenges the military apparatus
must overcome while engaging an adversary on its turf.
Surname 5
Conclusion
Both "Saving Private Ryan" and "The Thin Red Line" offer contrasting perspectives
on the themes of beauty, battle, brutality, and the hellish nature of war. "Saving Private Ryan"
stands out for its realistic portrayal of the Normandy landings and soldiers' individual and
collective sacrifices. The film explores the morality of risking many lives to save one and
depicts the camaraderie formed amidst the brutality of war. On the other hand, "The Thin Red
Line" takes a more philosophical and poetic approach, delving into the existential questions
surrounding life, death, and the meaning of war. The film uses voice-over narration, stunning
cinematography, and a focus on the characters' inner thoughts to convey the universal and
existential aspects of the human experience in war. Though different in style and tone, both
films contribute to the rich tapestry of war cinema by examining the multifaceted nature of
conflict.
Surname 6
Work Cited
Hasian, Marouf. "Nostalgic longings, memories of the" Good War," and cinematic
representations in Saving Private Ryan."
Critical Studies in Media
Communication
18.3 (2001): 338-358.
https://www.academia.edu/download/50418287/svgpvtryanasintertext-csmc.pdf
Reuben, Adrian. "The thin red line."
Hepatology
36.3 (2002): 770-773.
https://aasldpubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1002/hep.510360341
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help