Engineering Economic Analysis
Engineering Economic Analysis
13th Edition
ISBN: 9780190296902
Author: Donald G. Newnan, Ted G. Eschenbach, Jerome P. Lavelle
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Question
Book Icon
Chapter 8, Problem 24P
To determine

i.

Interest Rates preferred for each payment plan.

Expert Solution
Check Mark

Answer to Problem 24P

Interest rate Best Choice
0% Alternative D
17.84% Alternative A

Explanation of Solution

Given:

Availability of Magazine for $58 for 1 year

Availability of Magazine for $108 for 2 year

Availability of Magazine for $153 for 3 year

Availability of Magazine for $230 for 5 year.

Calculation:

There are four alternatives available for payment.

Year A B C D D-A
1 -58 -108 -153 0 58
2 -58 0 0 0 58
3 -58 -108 0 -230 -172
4 -58 0 -153 0 58
5 -58 -108 0 0 58
6 -58 0 0 -230 -172
7 -58 -108 -153 0 58
8 -58 0 0 0 58
9 -58 -108 0 -230 -172
10 -58 0 -153 0 58
11 -58 -108 0 0 58
12 -58 0 0 -230 -172
13 -58 -108 -153 0 58
14 -58 0 0 0 58
15 -58 -108 0 -230 -172
16 -58 0 -153 0 58
17 -58 -108 0 0 58
18 -58 0 0 -230 -172
19 -58 -108 -153 0 58
20 -58 0 0 0 58
21 -58 -108 0 -230 -172
22 -58 0 -153 0 58
23 -58 -108 0 0 58
24 -58 0 0 -230 -172
25 -58 -108 -153 0 58
26 -58 0 0 0 58
27 -58 -108 0 -230 -172
28 -58 0 -153 0 58
29 -58 -108 0 0 58
30 -58 0 0 -230 -172

The number of periods extended to 30 years because of different useful life. One alternative is available for 5 years and other is for 3 years and another one is available for 2 years. So, the least common factor is 1,2,3 and 5 is 30. This table represents the cash flow of all the four alternatives. Negative value means cash outflow and zero value means neither cash inflow nor cash outflow.

Graph of net present worth of all four alternatives versus interest rate.

Graph:

Engineering Economic Analysis, Chapter 8, Problem 24P

The graph clears the picture and explains that the alternative C and D are not part of the answer. Only alternative A and D is important.

Net Present worth of (Alternative B)-(Alternative A):

NPW=P+A(P/A,i,n)F1(P/F1,i,n)F2(P/F2,i,n)F3(P/F3,i,n)F4(P/F4,i,n)

P = initial Cost

A = annual payment that is uniform all the period

F1 = Future value in 6th year

F2 = future Value in 11th year

F3 = Future Value in 16th year

F4 = future value in 21st year

F5 = Future Value in 26th year

I = rate of return

N = time period

P A F1 F2 F3 F4 F5 i n
$172 $58 $230 $230 $230 $230 $230 ? $30

Time period

6 for F1

11 for F2

16 for F3

21 for F4

26 for F5

0=$172+$58(P/A,i,30)$230(P/F1,i,6)$230(P/F2,i,11)$230(P/F3,i,6)$230(P/F4,i,6)$230(P/F5,i,6)

Interest rate (P/A,i,30) (P/ F1,i,6) (P/ F2,i,11) (P/ F3,i,16) (P/ F4,i,21) (P/ F5,i,26)
15.00% 6.566 0.4343 0.2149 0.1069 0.0531 0.0264
18.00% 5.571 0.3704 0.1619 0.0708 0.0309 0.0135

The rate of return, which is between 15% and 18% is computed by linear interpolation:

IRR=i%low+(i%highi%low)[FlowPFlowFhigh]

i%low = Lower interest rate

i%high = Higher interest rate

Flow = factor of lower interest rate

Fhigh = factor of higher interest rate

IRR=15%+(18%15%)[$189.1$172$189.1$172($171.06$172)]

IRR=15%+3%[$17.1$18.039]

IRR=15%+3%×0.9479

IRR=15%+0.02843

IRR=0.17843

Therefore, the incremental rate of return is 17.84%.

Conclusion:

Choice Table:

Interest rate Best Choice
0% Alternative D
17.84% Alternative A
To determine

ii.

Impact on environment due to glossy paper of magazine.

Expert Solution
Check Mark

Answer to Problem 24P

  1. Lead to highest destruction of forest which had been sustainably managed. As magazine requires higher-grade paper.
  2. Glossy paper of magazine results in contamination of recycling process of paper.
  3. Ultraviolet sealing coating on glossy paper complicated recycling of paper.
  4. Glossy papers are made with toxic chlorine, which leads to soil pollution.

Explanation of Solution

Given:

Subscription of Magazine with different plans.

Concept used:

  • Lead to highest destruction of forest which had been sustainably managed. As magazine requires higher-grade paper.
  • Glossy paper of magazine results in contamination of recycling process of paper.
  • Ultraviolet sealing coating on glossy paper complicated recycling of paper.
  • Glossy papers are made with toxic chlorine, which leads to soil pollution.
  • Conclusion:

  • Lead to highest destruction of forest which had been sustainably managed. As magazine requires higher-grade paper.
  • Glossy paper of magazine results in contamination of recycling process of paper.
  • Ultraviolet sealing coating on glossy paper complicated recycling of paper.
  • Glossy papers are made with toxic chlorine, which leads to soil pollution.
  • Want to see more full solutions like this?

    Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!
    Students have asked these similar questions
    epidemiology. 2 to 3 setences max for each question
    epidemilogy. one paragraph MAX for each question please.
    A firm operates with the production function Q = K2 L. Q is the number of units of output per day when the firm rents K units of capital and employs L workers each day. The manager has been given a production target: to produce 8,000 units per day. She knows that the daily rental price of capital is $400 per unit and the wage rate is $200 day. a. What is the returns to scale of this production function? Show mathematically. b. Currently the firm employs 80 workers per day. What is the firm’s daily total cost if it rents just enough capital to produce at its target? c. Compare the marginal product per dollar spent on K and on L when the firm operates at the input choice in part (b). What does this suggest about the way the firm might change its choice of K and L if it wants to reduce the total cost in meeting its target? Explain your answer very clearly. d. In the long run, how much K and L should the firm choose if it wants to minimize the cost of producing 8,000 units of output a day?…
    Knowledge Booster
    Background pattern image
    Similar questions
    SEE MORE QUESTIONS
    Recommended textbooks for you
    Text book image
    ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
    Economics
    ISBN:9780190931919
    Author:NEWNAN
    Publisher:Oxford University Press
    Text book image
    Principles of Economics (12th Edition)
    Economics
    ISBN:9780134078779
    Author:Karl E. Case, Ray C. Fair, Sharon E. Oster
    Publisher:PEARSON
    Text book image
    Engineering Economy (17th Edition)
    Economics
    ISBN:9780134870069
    Author:William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, C. Patrick Koelling
    Publisher:PEARSON
    Text book image
    Principles of Economics (MindTap Course List)
    Economics
    ISBN:9781305585126
    Author:N. Gregory Mankiw
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Text book image
    Managerial Economics: A Problem Solving Approach
    Economics
    ISBN:9781337106665
    Author:Luke M. Froeb, Brian T. McCann, Michael R. Ward, Mike Shor
    Publisher:Cengage Learning
    Text book image
    Managerial Economics & Business Strategy (Mcgraw-...
    Economics
    ISBN:9781259290619
    Author:Michael Baye, Jeff Prince
    Publisher:McGraw-Hill Education