Mathematical Ideas (13th Edition) - Standalone book
13th Edition
ISBN: 9780321977076
Author: Charles D. Miller, Vern E. Heeren, John Hornsby, Christopher Heeren
Publisher: PEARSON
expand_more
expand_more
format_list_bulleted
Concept explainers
Videos
Textbook Question
Chapter 15.2, Problem 6E
Identifying Violations of the Condorcet CriterionAnswer each question for each voting situation of Exercises 5-10.
(a) Which candidate is a Condorcet candidate?
(b) Which candidate is selected by the plurality method?
(c) Which candidate is selected by the Borda method?
(d) Which candidate is selected by the Hare method?
(e) Which voting method(s) —plurality, Borda, or Hare— violate(s) the Condorcet criterion for this profile of voters?
Repeat Exercise 5 using the following voter profile (from Exercise 12 of Section 15.1).
| Number of Voters | Ranking |
| 4 | a > b > c |
| 2 | b > c > a |
| 4 | b > a > c |
| 3 | c > a > b |
Expert Solution & Answer
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution
Students have asked these similar questions
Consider an election with three candidates with the results:
(CBA) 2
(ACB) 6
(BAC) 5
(BCA) 2
Is there a majority winner? If not, who is the plurality winner? Answer No, B; Yes, A; No, A; No, C; or Yes, B.
Who wins the election using the Borda count method? Answer B; A; C and B tie; C; or A and B tie.
Who wins if they first eliminate the one with the most last-place votes and then have a runoff between the other two? Answer B; A; C and B tie; C; or A and B tie.
Could the two voters with preference (BCA) change the outcome of the election in previous question if they voted insincerely and pretended to have the preference (BAC)? Answer yes or no.
Majority Criterion and Borda Method
A group of teachers are planning a conference. They are
members of Teachers for Tomorrow. They are coming from four
different states. The choices for holding the conference are:
• Atlanta (A),
• Perdido (P),
• Biloxi (B), and
Panama City (C).
Below are the results of the votes of all the teachers.
• Use the Borda method to determine the location the teachers chose.
• Determine if the Borda method violates the majority criterion.
Number of Votes
45
47
50
50
First
P
A
P
Second
P
C
A
Third
A
C
B
Fourth
B
В
C
1. How many votes are there?
2. What is needed to win a majority?
3. Assign the point values to each vote. Fill in the table using the Borda method.
Number of
45
47
50
50
Votes
First (4 pts)
C
P
A
Second (3 pts)
A
A
A
Third (2 pts)
C
P
B
Fourth (1 pt)
B
B
B
C
4. Calculate the total points for each candidate.
Show how you calculate each candidate's total points.
Atlanta (A):
Perdido (P):
Biloxi (B):
Panama City (C):
5. Who won the Borda method?
6.…
Q3
Chapter 15 Solutions
Mathematical Ideas (13th Edition) - Standalone book
Ch. 15.1 - Choosing a Poster Dog by the Plurality Method A...Ch. 15.1 - Choosing a Poster Dog by the Plurality Method A...Ch. 15.1 - Choosing a Poster Dog by Alternative Methods For...Ch. 15.1 - Choosing a Poster Dog by Alternative MethodsFor...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...Ch. 15.1 - Observing the Effect of the Number of Candidates...
Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Applying Four Voting Methods to a Voter Profile...Ch. 15.1 - Holding a Runoff Election One common solution to...Ch. 15.1 - Prob. 20ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 21ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 22ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 23ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 24ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 25ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 26ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 27ECh. 15.1 - The Pairwise Comparison Method Each table...Ch. 15.1 - Prob. 29ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 30ECh. 15.1 - The Borda Method Each table represents a Borda...Ch. 15.1 - Prob. 32ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 33ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 34ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 35ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 36ECh. 15.1 - The Coombs Method The Coombs method of voting is a...Ch. 15.1 - Prob. 38ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 39ECh. 15.1 - Prob. 40ECh. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Majority Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Majority Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Majority...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Majority Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Condorcet...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Condorcet Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Condorcet Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Identifying Violations of the Condorcet Criterion...Ch. 15.2 - Prob. 9ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 10ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 11ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 12ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 13ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 14ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 15ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 16ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 17ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 18ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 19ECh. 15.2 - Irrelevant Alternatives in a Hare Method Election...Ch. 15.2 - 21. Explain why a violation of the majority...Ch. 15.2 - Prob. 22ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 23ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 24ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 25ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 26ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 27ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 28ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 29ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 30ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 31ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 32ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 33ECh. 15.2 - Prob. 34ECh. 15.3 - Find each quantity (to the nearest whole number)...Ch. 15.3 - Find each quantity (to the nearest whole number)...Ch. 15.3 - Find each quantity (to the nearest whole number)...Ch. 15.3 - Find each quantity (to the nearest whole number)...Ch. 15.3 - Solve each problem.
5. New Trees for Wisconsin...Ch. 15.3 - Apportioning Computers to Schools Enrollments for...Ch. 15.3 - Assigning Faculty to Courses The English...Ch. 15.3 - 8. Apportioning Sailboats to Resorts The number of...Ch. 15.3 - Prob. 9ECh. 15.3 - 10. Show that the Webster method apportionment of...Ch. 15.3 - Prob. 11ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 12ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 13ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 14ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 15ECh. 15.3 - Find the Huntington-Hill cutoff point for rounding...Ch. 15.3 - Creating a Profile of School Bus Riders Create a...Ch. 15.3 - Prob. 18ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 19ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 20ECh. 15.3 - The standard quotas rounded up to the nearest...Ch. 15.3 - Prob. 22ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 23ECh. 15.3 - Prob. 24ECh. 15.4 - Quota Rule Violations with the Jefferson Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Quota Rule Violations with the Jefferson Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Quota Rule Violations with the Jefferson Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Quota Rule Violations with the Jefferson Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Alabama Paradox with the Hamilton Method In each...Ch. 15.4 - Alabama Paradox with the Hamilton Method In each...Ch. 15.4 - Alabama Paradox with the Hamilton Method In each...Ch. 15.4 - Alabama Paradox with the Hamilton Method In each...Ch. 15.4 - Population Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Population Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Population Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Population Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - New States Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - New States Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - New States Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - New States Paradox with the Hamilton Method In...Ch. 15.4 - Violations of the Quota Rule? For each...Ch. 15.4 - Violations of the Quota Rule? For each...Ch. 15.4 - Violations of the Quota Rule? For each...Ch. 15.4 - Prob. 20ECh. 15.4 - Prob. 21ECh. 15.4 - Prob. 22ECh. 15.4 - Prob. 23ECh. 15.4 - Prob. 24ECh. 15.4 - Prob. 25ECh. 15.4 - 26. The Jefferson and Adams methods are both...Ch. 15 - How many different complete rankings are possible...Ch. 15 - Prob. 2TCh. 15 - Prob. 3TCh. 15 - Prob. 4TCh. 15 - Prob. 5TCh. 15 - Why is the irrelevant alternatives criterion an...Ch. 15 - Prob. 7TCh. 15 - Prob. 8TCh. 15 - Prob. 9TCh. 15 - Prob. 10TCh. 15 - Prob. 11TCh. 15 - Prob. 12TCh. 15 - Prob. 13TCh. 15 - Prob. 14TCh. 15 - Prob. 15TCh. 15 - Prob. 16TCh. 15 - Prob. 17TCh. 15 - Prob. 18TCh. 15 - Prob. 19TCh. 15 - Prob. 20TCh. 15 - Prob. 21TCh. 15 - Prob. 22TCh. 15 - Prob. 23TCh. 15 - Prob. 24TCh. 15 - Prob. 25TCh. 15 - One hundred seats are to be apportioned to 4...Ch. 15 - Prob. 27TCh. 15 - Prob. 28TCh. 15 - Prob. 29TCh. 15 - Explain the Alabama paradox.Ch. 15 - Prob. 31TCh. 15 - Prob. 32T
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, subject and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Similar questions
- Choosing Officers From a pool of 12 candidates, the offices of president, vice-president, secretary, and treasurer need to be filled. In how many different ways can the offices be filled?arrow_forwardLottery Powerball is a lottery game that is operated by the Multi-State Lottery Association and is played in 44 states, Washington D.C., Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The game is played by drawing five white balls out of a drum of 69 white balls (numbered 1-69) and one red powerball out of a drum of 26 red balls (numbered 1-26). The jackpot is won by matching all five white balls in any order and the red powerball. (a) Find the possible number of winning Powerball numbers. (b) Find the possible number of winning Powerball numbers when you win the jackpot by matching all five white balls in order and the red powerball.arrow_forwardConsider the weighted voting system (q: 8, 3, 3, 2}, with q an integer and 9 < q 16. (a) For what values of q is there a dummy? (Enter your answers as a comma-separated list.) (b) For what values ofo do all voters have the same power? (Enter your answers as a comma-separated list (c) If a voter is a dummy for a given quota, must the voter be a dummy for all larger quotas? O Yes O Noarrow_forward
- The U.S. Census Bureau conducts annual surveys to obtain information on the percentage of the voting-age population that is registered to vote. Suppose that 713 employed persons and 613 unemployed persons are independently and randomly selected and that 338 of the employed persons and 244 of the unemployed persons have registered to vote. Can we conclude that the percentage of employed workers ( p1 ), who have registered to vote, exceeds the percentage of unemployed workers ( p2 ), who have registered to vote? Use a significance level of α=0.1 for the test. Step 1 of 6 : State the null and alternative hypotheses for the test. Step 2 of 6 : Find the values of the two sample proportions, pˆ1p^1 and pˆ2p^2. Round your answers to three decimal places. Step 3 of 6 : Compute the weighted estimate of p, p‾p‾. Round your answer to three decimal places. Step 4 of 6 : Compute the value of the test statistic. Round your answer to two decimal places.…arrow_forwardUsing the plurality-with-elimination method, who wins the election if candidate E is removed from the ballot?arrow_forwardThe weighted voting systems for the voters A, B, C, ... are given in the form {a: w, w2, wy, wa, .., w,}. The weight of voter A is w1, the weight of voter B is w2, the weight of voter C is w3, and so on. A weighted voting system is given by (18: 9, 7, 4, 2, 1). (a) What is the quota? 18 (b) How many voters are in this system? x voters 41 (c) What is the weight of voter C? (d) What is the weight of the coalition {B, C}? 11 (e) Is {B, C, D, E} a winning coalition? Yes No (f) Which voters are critical voters in the coalition {A, B, D}? A A and B A and D B and D A, B, and D (g) How many coalitions can be formed? 6 x coalitions (h) How many coalitions consist of exactly three voters? 7 x coalitions O O Oarrow_forward
- Votes for each food option 6 voters Tacos Pizza Votes 6 voters 1st choice Pizza 2nd choice Tacos 3rd choice Salad 4th choice Salad Sandwiches If you employed the Instant Runoff Method, what would happen first? Sandwiches 5 voters Sandwiches Pizza Tacos Salad 2 voters Pizza Salad Sandwiches Taco's 4 voters Salad Pizza Sandwiches Tacos Sandwiches are eliminated and Pizza moves up to get five more first place votes. Sandwiches are eliminated and Pizza moves up to get one more first place vote. Pizza is already the winner, with 8 votes. There is no need for an instant runoff. Salad is eliminated and Pizza moves up to get five more first place votes. Salad is eliminated and Pizza moves up to get four more first place votes.arrow_forwardAn election is held among four candidates (A, B, C, and D). Using a voting method we will call the "Yoshida Method ", the winner of the election is candidate A. Due to an irregularity in the original vote count a new election must be held. In the new election nearly everyone resubmitted the same preferences. There were three voters, whoever, who changed their ballots. In the original election they voted "D first, then A second, then B third, then C last," but in the second election they promoted A to vote "A first, D second, B third, C last." In the recount, still using voting method X, candidate B wins the election. Based on the above information, we have just witnessed that the Yoshida Method violates the _______ criterion. Group of answer choices Condorcet Criterion Monotonicity Criterion Independence-of-Irrelevant-Alternatives Criterion (IIA) None of the fairness criteria are violated Majority Criterionarrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
Algebra & Trigonometry with Analytic GeometryAlgebraISBN:9781133382119Author:SwokowskiPublisher:Cengage
Algebra & Trigonometry with Analytic Geometry
Algebra
ISBN:9781133382119
Author:Swokowski
Publisher:Cengage
Propositional Logic, Propositional Variables & Compound Propositions; Author: Neso Academy;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ib5njCwNMdk;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
Propositional Logic - Discrete math; Author: Charles Edeki - Math Computer Science Programming;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rL_8y2v1Guw;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
DM-12-Propositional Logic-Basics; Author: GATEBOOK VIDEO LECTURES;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzUBrJLIESU;License: Standard Youtube License
Lecture 1 - Propositional Logic; Author: nptelhrd;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlUFkMKSB3Y;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
MFCS unit-1 || Part:1 || JNTU || Well formed formula || propositional calculus || truth tables; Author: Learn with Smily;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XV15Q4mCcHc;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY