Excursions in Modern Mathematics (9th Edition)
9th Edition
ISBN: 9780134468372
Author: Peter Tannenbaum
Publisher: PEARSON
expand_more
expand_more
format_list_bulleted
Concept explainers
Videos
Textbook Question
Chapter 1, Problem 69E
The Coombs method. This method is just like the plurality-with-elimination method except that in each round we eliminate the candidate with the largest number of last-place votes (instead of the one with the fewest first-place votes).
a. Find the winner of the Math Club election using the Coombs method.
b. Give an example that illustrates why the Coombs method violates the Condorcet criterion.
c. Give an example that illustrates why the Coombs method violates the monotonicity criterion.
Expert Solution & Answer
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution
Students have asked these similar questions
The students in a class get to decide on the color of the classroom. The two choices are blue and yellow. Polling shows yellow is preferred by a small
majority, 53% for yellow to 47% for blue. However, before the vote is held, a new color choice is added: red. Not a lot of people like red, but there are
some yellow supporters who would actually vote for red. The results of the vote are below.
Blue
Yellow
Red
46%
44%
10%
What statement below is correct about adding a third choice to the plurality vote?
O a
Ob
Oc
d
Red did not win the vote, but it draws enough support away from yellow to make blue the winner, even though a majority of
students preferred yellow over blue when there were two choices.
Red did not win the vote, but it had no effect on drawing enough support away from yellow to make blue the winner, even though
a majority of students preferred yellow over blue when there were two choices.
Red did not win the vote, so because of this, yellow should win the vote over blue.…
Suppose that three candidates—Woodward, Seiple, and Porter—are running in an election that will be decided by the plurality method with a runoff between the top two finishers if none of the candidates receives a majority of the votes. The results of the first ballot (plurality) are given next. Woodward 2315 Seiple 1885 Porter 800 In a runoff election between Woodward and Seiple, what is the smallest percentage of Porter supporters that would need to vote for Seiple in order for Seiple to win the election?
Your class gets to elect a representative for the school council. The two choices are Lizzy and Michael. Polling of the class shows that Polly is
preferred by 53% to 47% over Michael. However, before the vote is held, a new choice for representative is put forth by a student: Rodney.
Many of the students that prefer Polly, would rather have Rodney. The results of the vote are below.
Michael
45%
Polly
Rodney
35%
17%
What statement below is correct about adding a third choice to the plurality vote?
Rodney did not win the vote, but it had no effect on drawing enough support away from Polly to make Michael the winner, even
though a majority of students preferred Polly over Michael when there were two choices.
Rodney did not win the vote, but it draws enough support away from Polly to make Michael the winner, even though a majority of
students preferred Polly over Michael when there were two choices.
Rodney did not win the vote, so because of this Polly should win the vote over Michael.
a…
Chapter 1 Solutions
Excursions in Modern Mathematics (9th Edition)
Ch. 1 - Figure 1-8 shows the preference ballots for an...Ch. 1 - Figure 1-9 shows the preference ballots for an...Ch. 1 - An election is held to choose the Chair of the...Ch. 1 - The student body at Eureka High School is having...Ch. 1 - An election is held using the printed-names format...Ch. 1 - Prob. 6ECh. 1 - Prob. 7ECh. 1 - Table 1-30 shows a conventional preference...Ch. 1 - The Demublican Party is holding its annual...Ch. 1 - The Epicurean Society is holding its annual...
Ch. 1 - Table 1-31 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-32 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-33 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-34 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-35 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table1-36 shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-25 see Exercise 3 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-26 see Exercise 4 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-25 see Exercise 3 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-26 see Exercise 4 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-31see Exercise 11 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-32 see Exercise 12 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-33 see Exercise 13 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-34 Number of voters 6 6 5 4 3 3 1st A B B...Ch. 1 - Table 1-35 Percent of voters 24 23 19 14 11 9 1st...Ch. 1 - Table 1-36 Percent of voters 25 21 15 12 10 9 8...Ch. 1 - The Heisman Award. Table 1-37 shows the results...Ch. 1 - The 2014 AL Cy Young Award. Table 1-38 shows the...Ch. 1 - An election was held using the conventional Borda...Ch. 1 - Imagine that in the voting for the American League...Ch. 1 - Table 1-31 see Exercise 11 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-32 see Exercise 12 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table1-33 Number of voters 6 5 4 2 2 2 2 1st C A B...Ch. 1 - Table 1-34 See Exercise 14 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table1-39_ shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table1-40_ shows the preference schedule for an...Ch. 1 - Table 1-35 see Exercise 15 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-36 see Exercise 16 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Top-Two Instant-Runoff Voting. Exercises 39 and 40...Ch. 1 - Top-Two Instant-Runoff Voting. Exercises 39 and 40...Ch. 1 - Table 1-31 see Exercise 11 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-32 See Exercise 12 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-33 see Exercise 13 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-34 see Exercise 14 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-35 see Exercise 15 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-36 see Exercise 16 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table 1-39 see Exercise 35 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - Table1-40 see Exercise36 shows the preference...Ch. 1 - An election with five candidates A, B. C, D, and E...Ch. 1 - An election with six candidates A, B, C, D, E, and...Ch. 1 - Use Table 1-41 to illustrate why the Borda count...Ch. 1 - Use Table 1-32 to illustrate why the...Ch. 1 - Use Table 1-42 to illustrate why the plurality...Ch. 1 - Use the Math Club election Example 1.10 to...Ch. 1 - Use Table 1-43 to illustrate why the...Ch. 1 - Explain why the method of pair wise comparisons...Ch. 1 - Prob. 57ECh. 1 - Explain why the plurality method satisfies the...Ch. 1 - Explain why the Borda count method satisfies the...Ch. 1 - Explain why the method of pairwise comparisons...Ch. 1 - Two-candidate elections. Explain why when there...Ch. 1 - Alternative version of the Borda count. The...Ch. 1 - Reverse Borda count. Another commonly used...Ch. 1 - The average ranking. The average ranking of a...Ch. 1 - The 2006 Associated Press college football poll....Ch. 1 - The Pareto criterion. The following fairness...Ch. 1 - The 2003-2004 NBA Rookie of the Year vote. Each...Ch. 1 - Top-two IRV is a variation of the...Ch. 1 - The Coombs method. This method is just like the...Ch. 1 - Bucklin voting. This method was used in the early...Ch. 1 - The 2016 NBA MVP vote. The National Basketball...Ch. 1 - The Condorcet loser criterion. If there is a...Ch. 1 - Consider the following fairness criterion: If a...Ch. 1 - Suppose that the following was proposed as a...Ch. 1 - Consider a modified Borda count where a...
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, subject and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Similar questions
- Four candidates: Rhea , Charles ,John , and Wilson arerunning four Councilor. After the polls close, votes aretallied and the following results are obtained:Candidate and Number of votes:Rhea - 2,567 Charles - 2,445 John - 5,100 Wilson - 2,365b. How many votes were castsc. Using plurality method of voting which candidate wins?d. Did the winner receive a majority of the votes?arrow_forwardSuppose that three candidates-Woodward, Seiple, and Porter-are running in an election that will be decided by the plurality method with a runoff between the top two finishers if none of the candidates receives a majority of the votes. The results of the first ballot (plurality) are given next. Woodward 2315 Seiple Porter 1885 800 In a runoff election between Woodward and Seiple, what is the smallest percentage of Porter supporters that would need to vote for Seiple in order for Seiple to win the election?arrow_forwardUse the plurality with elimination method to determine the winner and compare it to the plurality method. Who wins the preferential vote and the single candidate vote? There are 74 voters and the candidates need 37 votes to win. There are 5 candidates for the house of representatives and you have to rank them by preference. Votes 20 16 12 15 11 1st Emilio Howard Richard Melissa Hannah 2nd Howard Melissa Hannah Hannah Emilio 3rd Melissa Emilio Melissa Richard Richard 4th Hannah Richard Emilio Howard Howard 5th Richard Hannah Howard Emilio Melissa a Plurality with elimination: Richard wins with 43, Plurality: Emilio wins with 20 Plurality with elimination: Melissa wins with 43, Plurality: Emilio wins with 20 Plurality with elimination: Hannah wins with 43, Plurality: Emilio wins with 20 d. Plurality with elimination: Emilio wins with 37, Plurality: Emilio wins with 20arrow_forward
- One of the voting methods requires voters to rank all candidates from the most favorable to the least favorable. Each last-place vote receives 1 point, each next-to-last place vote 2 points, and so on. This voting method is called the _________ method. The candidate with the ______ is the winner.arrow_forwardsolve asap within 15 mins with explanationarrow_forwardUse the Bucklin voting method to determine the winner and compare it to the plurality method. Who wins the Bucklin vote and the single candidate vote? There are 7 voters and the candidates need 4 votes to win. There are 5 candidates for the house of representatives and you have to rank them by preference. Voters A B D E F G Emilio | Hannah Richard Melissa Howard Howard Emilio Howard 1st 2nd Howard Hannah Emilio Emilio Richard Melissa 3rd Melissa Emilio Melissa Richard Richard Hannah Richard 4th Hannah Richard Emilio Howard Hannah Emilio Howard 5th Richard Melissa Howard Hannah Melissa Melissa Hannah a Bucklin method: Howard wins with 5, Plurality: There is no winner b Bucklin method: Melissa wins with 4, Plurality: There is no winner Bucklin method: Richard wins with 4, Plurality: There is no winner d. Bucklin method: Emilio wins with 5, Plurality: There is no winner O000arrow_forward
- Hello, I need help on how to solve or get the answer in the Plurality Method, Plurality with Elimination Method and Borda Count Method using the problem below: The owner of a restaurant decides to poll regular customers to choose which dish she’ll submit to an annual citywide competition. The choices are lemon-crusted salmon (L), crab-stuffed chicken (C), garlic prime rib (G), and wasabi rolls (W). The results are shown in the preference table. # of votes 9 7 6 4 3 C 1 4 3 2 2 G 3 3 2 1 4 L 4 1 4 4 3 W 2 2 1 3 1 Thank you so much!!!arrow_forwardSolve the problem. Which voting method always satisfies the head-to- head criterion? Borda count plurality O pairwise comparison plurality with eliminationarrow_forwardAn employer surveys employees to see which lunch choice they should have at a work picnic. Here are the results: First choice Second choice Third choice 8 voters Tacos 41 11 8 6 voters Pizza Sandwiches Pizza 3 voters Sandwiches Tacos Sandwiches Based on these results, how many points do tacos get using the Borda count method? 3 voters Tacos Pizza Pizza Sandwiches Tacos 45 Pizza wins. Tacos are eliminated in the first round, so pizza moves up in the first column.arrow_forward
- solve question asap within 15 mins with explanationarrow_forwardA voter who has a weight that is greater than or equal to the quota is called a dictator. In a weighted voting system, the dictator has all the power. A voter who is never a critical voter has no power and is referred to as a dummy. This term is not meant to be a comment on the voter’s intellectual powers; it just indicates that the voter has no ability to influence an election. a. dictators : v1,v2 ; dummies : v2,v3 b. dictator : v1; dummies : v2,v3,v4,v5 c. dictator : v1; dummy : v2 d. The system is not valid.arrow_forwardK The English department has the faculty to offer 12 sections in any combination of the three courses: Fiction, Poetry, and Multicultural Literature. The number of sections apportioned to each course is based on the enrollments in the courses. The enrollment figures are in the table. S Fiction 42 Use the Hamilton method to apportion the sections. Courses Enrollment There should be section(s) of Fiction, Poetry 26 section(s) of Poetry, and Multicultural 119 section(s) of Multicultural Literature. M Next 64°F Mostly cloudy 4arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
Holt Mcdougal Larson Pre-algebra: Student Edition...AlgebraISBN:9780547587776Author:HOLT MCDOUGALPublisher:HOLT MCDOUGAL
Holt Mcdougal Larson Pre-algebra: Student Edition...
Algebra
ISBN:9780547587776
Author:HOLT MCDOUGAL
Publisher:HOLT MCDOUGAL
Bayes' Theorem 1: Introduction and conditional probability; Author: Dr Nic's Maths and Stats;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQVkXfJ-rpU;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
What is Conditional Probability | Bayes Theorem | Conditional Probability Examples & Problems; Author: ACADGILD;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxOny_1y2Q4;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
Bayes' Theorem of Probability With Tree Diagrams & Venn Diagrams; Author: The Organic Chemistry Tutor;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OByl4RJxnKA;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY
Bayes' Theorem - The Simplest Case; Author: Dr. Trefor Bazett;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQoLVl31ZfQ;License: Standard Youtube License