Worksheet for Case Analysis (MGT 302). This worksheet follows the format of the case study videos posted in the Course Policies module. Type each significant symptom in its own cell (left column) and complete the rest of the row, demonstrating your ability to correctly apply management principles. Move on to the last page once you have completed the worksheet. In your analysis, use all applicable theories from the readings through the current week, to gain experience in more holistic use of theory in case analysis. (See the video on case study analysis in Course Policies for more on each column.) Before each symptom, it might help you to ensure you have covered the relevant theory bases to include the category of P-O-L-C and sub-category in which the symptom best fits. Use these (taken from the text organization: P (planning): V (vision & mission); S (strategizing); G (goals & objectives). O (organizing): O (organizational design); C (culture); S (social networks). L (leading): L (leadership); D (decision making); C (communications), GT (groups & teams); M (motivation). C (controlling): S (systems & processes); SHR (strategic human resources).
Q: Please help with the numbers given below! Richardson Ski Racing (RSR) sells equipment needed for…
A: (a) Total Revenue Calculation:To calculate the total revenue from the orders, we'll utilize the…
Q: How can I overcome challenges or setbacks in my career journey without losing confidence?
A: Embrace a Growth Mindset: A growth mindset is about understanding that abilities and intelligence…
Q: Is this statement true or false? It is advisable for entrepreneurs to make detailed cost…
A: The objective of the question is to verify the validity of the statement that entrepreneurs should…
Q: What is relationship within manage work and the Bible in Christian perspective?
A: Approach to solving the question: Detailed explanation: Examples: Key references:
Q: Alpha Beta Gamma Delta Quality 1 3 3 5 Cost 7 7 5 3 Speed 5 5 3 5 Visibility 3 1 Reliability 5 5 57…
A: To construct a project screening matrix and identify the most likely candidate among the four…
Q: People spending more money on experiences such as going to the theatre instead of buying clothes is…
A: The objective of the question is to determine whether the shift in consumer spending habits from…
Q: Sourcing and sustainability in procurement theoretical framework Literature review in relation…
A: Sourcing and sustainability are critical components of modern procurement practices, as…
Q: Base on Aisin Corporation How can I Recommend alternative effective leadership models explaining…
A: 1. For Aisin Corporation, employing leadership approaches such as transformational and servant model…
Q: Diffentiate between planning and organizing short answer
A: Planning and organizing are two essential functions in management, each playing a distinct yet…
Q: Many locations require that renters be paid interest on their security deposits. If you have a…
A: The objective of the question is to calculate the interest earned on a security deposit of $2000 at…
Q: Matt and Kristin are newly married and living in their first house. The yearly premium on their…
A: Cost of Dead-bolt Locks:Matt and Kristin need to install dead-bolt locks on two exterior doors.Cost…
Q: b 8. The potential energy of a particle in a certain field has the form U=3, where a and b are…
A: The image depicts a scenario where a particle resides in a field with potential energy described by…
Q: Planning is the foundational cornerstone of success in virtually every endeavor. Whether in personal…
A: The objective of this question is to understand the role of effective planning in mitigating risks…
Q: Which topic should be discussed prior to the employee's return from abroad Question 21Answer a.…
A: The question is asking about the topics that should be discussed with an employee before they return…
Q: Abu Dhabi International Book Fair and Event Management Established in 1983, from an event first…
A: The Abu Dhabi International Book Fair (ADIBF) as a symbol of literary festival in the Middle East,…
Q: Would you rather do business in a country that uses civil law or common law? Why?
A: The preference between doing business in a country that uses civil law or common law largely depends…
Q: In an M/M/1 queueing system, the arrival rate is 7 customers per hour and the service rate is 12…
A: The objective of the question is to calculate the probability of different scenarios in an M/M/1…
Q: A Midsize Pharmaceutical CompanyJennifer Childs is the owner and chief executive officer of a…
A: Jennifer could gather additional data or information:Market Analysis:Gathering market research would…
Q: Draw the stress relaxation curves of the following models: b. c. a. σ b www d. www b www b
A: I understand you sent an image containing the question, but as per my policy, I can't directly…
Q: Let A = {0, 1, 2, 3} and define a relation R on A as follows: R = {(0, 0), (0, 2), (0, 3), (2, 2),…
A:
Q: In this task you will evaluate how effectively a Deputy Branch Manager conducts a one- to -one…
A: A detailed and comprehensive explanation with examples and citations for evaluating the…
Q: As a Corridor Management Officer, you will be required to circulate applications to otherfunctional…
A: 1. Describe the situation:The project involved the construction of a new residential complex. During…
Q: _________ is unlikely to follow a bell-shape because ______________, but ________ will follow a…
A: for any queries message me happy learning
Q: A B C 20 12345690022===≈ Year Quarter Revenue 2010 1 7,131.00 2010 2 6,566.00 2010 3 7,560.00 2010 4…
A: Analyzing Amazon Revenue Data1. Exponential Smoothing Model (a=0.7, Initial Value=7,131):a. Forecast…
Q: Change management refers to the structured approach organizations take to transition individuals,…
A: Effective communication during organizational change involves transparent, consistent messaging…
Q: The managerial task of developing a strategic vision for a company: Question 20Answer…
A: The objective of the question is to understand the primary focus of developing a strategic vision…
Q: A Midsize Pharmaceutical Company Jennifer Childs is the owner and chief executive officer of a…
A: Jennifer should approach the decision-making process by considering various factors and evaluating…
Q: What artifacts can you see at work? What do these artifacts tell you about your employer? Give me…
A: ArtifactAn artifact is an object made by humans, typically with historical, cultural, or…
Q: On page 335 of HR5 by Denisi and Griffin, In the closing case "Driving Employee Motivation" how…
A: There are a number of criteria that can be used to evaluate Nussbaum's incentive program, which is…
Q: Marketing was born because selling wasn't enough” is now available. Do you agree with the analysis…
A: References:Rust, R. T. (2020). The future of marketing. International Journal of Research in…
Q: If an economy can produce a maximum of 10 units of good X and the opportunity cost of 1X is always…
A: In economics, the concept of opportunity cost refers to the value of the next best alternative that…
Q: An Ethical Dilemma Jayla just landed an internship with Acme Incorporated in the payroll department.…
A: Business ethics is the aspects of business that define the standards or directives that assist in…
Q: Which of the following is NOT true about the EV truck completion between GM and Ford?…
A: The objective of the question is to identify the incorrect statement about the competition between…
Q: Problem 09.052 - Circuit analysis to find source current in a R, L, C circuit If Vo 8260° V in the…
A: The question seems to be misplaced. The question is related to Electrical Engineering, specifically…
Q: with the Bill of Rights and Amendments 11-27 What wuld be 3 rights that appear in both…
A: i. Approach to solving the question: To solve this question, I took the following approach:1.…
Q: correct answer please
A: Step 1:Computation of the cost of goods available for sale under a periodic system:Cost of goods…
Q: In the context of Negotiation and Conflict Management, provide Recommendation for Pollution and…
A: Taking into consideration the fact that the present global trade is one of the cornerstone for the…
Q: Of the students who scored 70 on the final, about what percentage of students score below 75 on the…
A: To solve this problem, we need to find the percentage of students who scored below 75 on the…
Q: Examine the possible cash-flow issues and operational improvement possibilities of at least two KPIs…
A: Here's a more detailed explanation of each key performance indicator (KPI) and its implications,…
Q: Which of the following is true of functional area strategies? Answer D) They address…
A: The objective of the question is to identify the correct statement about functional area strategies.
Q: Consider the internal and external challenges Rakefet faced, how she chose to address them head-on…
A: Throughout the course of her journey, Rakefet, in her role as a leader, encountered a wide variety…
Q: How do analyze data using process and informative evaluation for program improvements
A: The objective of this question is to understand how to analyze data using process and informative…
Q: Isaiah would rather take the bus to work than walk, but he'd rather take a train than walking or…
A: Isaiah's Preferences:Isaiah's preferences violate the transitivity assumption of rational choice…
Q: What is the importance of mastering putting together a business plan and learning about fincancial…
A: Mastering the art of putting together a comprehensive business plan, understanding financial…
Q: In crafting a company's strategy: Question 11Answer C) managers need to come up with…
A: The best answer here is C) managers need to come up with some distinctive "aha" element to the…
Q: Question 4: (a) Show that if M is a discrete metric space and A is dense in M, then A = M. (b) Show…
A: (a) To show that if M is a discrete metric space and A is dense in M, then A = M: We assume the…
Q: An electric vehicle company is debating whether to replace its original model, Model X, with a…
A: To calculate the difference in net present values (NPV) between producing Model Y and producing…
Q: Consider yourself the data manager of an IT company and write a formal report to your correspondence…
A: Being a data manager of an IT company, first, let me prepare a formal report for the correspondence,…
Q: Referring to the comparison of the Pearson and Spearman correlations on both correlation size and…
A: for any queries message me happy learning
Q: Compare the Pearson and Spearman correlations on both correlation size and significance level
A: FOR ANY QUERIES, PING ME HAPPY LEARNING
Worksheet for Case Analysis (MGT 302). This worksheet follows the format of the case study videos posted in the Course Policies module. Type each significant symptom in its own cell (left column) and complete the rest of the row, demonstrating your ability to correctly apply management principles. Move on to the last page once you have completed the worksheet. In your analysis, use all applicable theories from the readings through the current week, to gain experience in more holistic use of theory in case analysis. (See the video on case study analysis in Course Policies for more on each column.) Before each symptom, it might help you to ensure you have covered the relevant theory bases to include the category of P-O-L-C and sub-category in which the symptom best fits. Use these (taken from the text organization: P (planning): V (vision & mission); S (strategizing); G (goals & objectives). O (organizing): O (organizational design); C (culture); S (social networks). L (leading): L (leadership); D (decision making); C (communications), GT (groups & teams); M (motivation). C (
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps
- Create a Group Control System Step 1. From into groups of three to five students. Each group will assume that another student group has been given an assignment of writing a major paper that will involve research by individual group members that will be integrated into the final paper. Each group member has to do his or part. Step 2. Your assignment is develop a list of rules and identify some statistics by which to control the behavior of members in that group. Brainstorm and discuss potential to govern member behavior and consequences for breaking those rules. Step 3. First, select the five rules that you think are most important for governing group member behavior. Consider the following situations that rules might cover; arriving late for a meeting: missing a meeting: failing to complete a work assignment; disagreements about desired quality of work; how to resolve conflicts about paper content; differences in participation , such as one person doing all the talking and someone else talking hardly at all; how to handle meetings that start late; the use of an agenda and handling deviations from the agenda; and any other situation that your group a cover. Step 4. Now consider what statistics could be developed to measure the behavior and outcome of the group pertaining to those five rules. What kinds of things could be counted to understand how group is performing and whether members are the following rules? Step 5. Discuss the following questions. Why are rules important as a means of control? What are the advantages and disadvantages of having many rules (hierarchical control) versus few rules (decentralized control) for a student group? How can statistics help a group ensure? appropriate behavior and a high-quality product? Step 6. Be prepared to present your conclusions to the Class.Chris Dykstra, responsible for loss prevention at Electronics took a deep breath before he launched into making his case for the changes that he was proposing to the company's shoplifting policy. He knew that convincing Ross Chenoweth was going to be a hard sell. Ross, the president and CEO was the son of the founder of the local, still-family-owned consumer electronics chain based in Phoenix, Arizona. He'd inherited not only the company, but also, his father's strict moral code. "I think it's time to follow the lead of other stores," Chris began. He pointed out that most Other retailers didn't bother calling the police and pressing charges unless the thief had shoplifted merchandise worth more than $50 to $100. In contrast, Westwind currently had a zero-tolerance policy toward theft that Ross's father had put in place when he started the business. Chris wanted to replace that policy with one that prosecuted only individuals between IS and 65 who had stolen more than $20 worth of goods, and who had a previous history of theft at Westwind. In the case of first-time culprits under IS or over 65, he argued for letting them Off With a strict warning, regardless of the value of their ill-gotten goods. Repeat offenders would be arrested. "Frankly, the local police are getting pretty tired Of having to come to Our stores every time a teenager sticks a CD in his jacket pocket," Chris pointed out. "And besides, we just afford the costs associated with prosecuting everyone." Every time he pressed charges against a shoplifter who'd made Off with a $10 item, Westwind lost money. The company had to engage a lawyer and pay employees Overtime for their court appearances. In addition, Chris was looking at hiring more security guards to keep up with the workload. Westwind was already in a losing battle at the moment with mass retailers who were competing all too successfully on price, so passing on the costs of its zero-tolerance policy to Customers wasn't really an option. " Let's concentrate on catching dishonest employees and those organized-theft rings. They're the ones who are really hurting us," Chris concluded. There was a long pause after Chris finished his carefully prepared speech. Ross thought about his recently deceased father, both an astute businessman and a person for whom honesty was a key guiding principle. If he were sitting here today, he`d no doubt say that theft was theft—that setting a minimum was tantamount to saying that stealing was acceptable, just as long as you steal too much. He looked at Chris. "You know, we've both got teenagers. Is this really a message you want to send out, especially to kids? You know as well as I do that there's nothing they like better than testing limits. It's almost an invitation to see if you can beat the system." But then Ross faltered as he found himself glancing at the latest financial figures on his desk—another in a string of quarterly losses. If West-wind went under, a lot of employees would be looking for another way to make a living. In his heart, he believed in his father's high moral standards, but he had to ask himself: Just how moral could Westwind afford to be? Continue Westwind's zero-tolerance policy toward shoplifting. It's the right thing to do—and it Will pay Off in the end in higher profitability because the chain's reputation for being tough on crime Will reduce overall losses from theft.Chris Dykstra, responsible for loss prevention at Electronics took a deep breath before he launched into making his case for the changes that he was proposing to the company's shoplifting policy. He knew that convincing Ross Chenoweth was going to be a hard sell. Ross, the president and CEO was the son of the founder of the local, still-family-owned consumer electronics chain based in Phoenix, Arizona. He'd inherited not only the company, but also, his father's strict moral code. "I think it's time to follow the lead of other stores," Chris began. He pointed out that most Other retailers didn't bother calling the police and pressing charges unless the thief had shoplifted merchandise worth more than $50 to $100. In contrast, Westwind currently had a zero-tolerance policy toward theft that Ross's father had put in place when he started the business. Chris wanted to replace that policy with one that prosecuted only individuals between IS and 65 who had stolen more than $20 worth of goods, and who had a previous history of theft at Westwind. In the case of first-time culprits under IS or over 65, he argued for letting them Off With a strict warning, regardless of the value of their ill-gotten goods. Repeat offenders would be arrested. "Frankly, the local police are getting pretty tired Of having to come to Our stores every time a teenager sticks a CD in his jacket pocket," Chris pointed out. "And besides, we just afford the costs associated with prosecuting everyone." Every time he pressed charges against a shoplifter who'd made Off with a $10 item, Westwind lost money. The company had to engage a lawyer and pay employees Overtime for their court appearances. In addition, Chris was looking at hiring more security guards to keep up with the workload. Westwind was already in a losing battle at the moment with mass retailers who were competing all too successfully on price, so passing on the costs of its zero-tolerance policy to Customers wasn't really an option. "Let's concentrate on catching dishonest employees and those organized-theft rings. They're the ones who are really hurting us," Chris concluded. There was a long pause after Chris finished his carefully prepared speech. Ross thought about his recently deceased father, both an astute businessman and a person for whom honesty was a key guiding principle. If he were sitting here today, he`d no doubt say that theft was theft—that setting a minimum was tantamount to saying that stealing was acceptable, just as long as you steal too much. He looked at Chris. "You know, we've both got teenagers. Is this really a message you want to send out, especially to kids? You know as well as I do that there's nothing they like better than testing limits. It's almost an invitation to see if you can beat the system." But then Ross faltered as he found himself glancing at the latest financial figures on his desk—another in a string of quarterly losses. If West-wind went under, a lot of employees would be looking for another way to make a living. In his heart, he believed in his father's high moral standards, but he had to ask himself: Just how moral could Westwind afford to be? Adopt Chris Dykstra's proposed changes and show more leniency to first-time offenders. It is a more cost effective approach to the problem than the current policy, plus it stays close to your father's Original intent.
- Chris Dykstra, responsible for loss prevention at Electronics took a deep breath before he launched into making his case for the changes that he was proposing to the company's shoplifting policy. He knew that convincing Ross Chenoweth was going to be a hard sell. Ross, the president and CEO was the son of the founder of the local, still-family-owned consumer electronics chain based in Phoenix, Arizona. He'd inherited not only the company, but also, his father's strict moral code. "I think it's time to follow the lead of other stores," Chris began. He pointed out that most Other retailers didn't bother calling the police and pressing charges unless the thief had shoplifted merchandise worth more than $50 to $100. In contrast, Westwind currently had a zero-tolerance policy toward theft that Ross's father had put in place when he started the business. Chris wanted to replace that policy with one that prosecuted only individuals between IS and 65 who had stolen more than $20 worth of goods, and who had a previous history of theft at Westwind. In the case of first-time culprits under IS or over 65, he argued for letting them Off With a strict warning, regardless of the value of their ill-gotten goods. Repeat offenders would be arrested. "Frankly, the local police are getting pretty tired Of having to come to Our stores every time a teenager sticks a CD in his jacket pocket," Chris pointed out. "And besides, we just afford the costs associated with prosecuting everyone." Every time he pressed charges against a shoplifter who'd made Off with a $10 item, Westwind lost money. The company had to engage a lawyer and pay employees Overtime for their court appearances. In addition, Chris was looking at hiring more security guards to keep up with the workload. Westwind was already in a losing battle at the moment with mass retailers who were competing all too successfully on price, so passing on the costs of its zero-tolerance policy to Customers wasn't really an option. " Let's concentrate on catching dishonest employees and those organized-theft rings. They're the ones who are really hurting us," Chris concluded. There was a long pause after Chris finished his carefully prepared speech. Ross thought about his recently deceased father, both an astute businessman and a person for whom honesty was a key guiding principle. If he were sitting here today, he`d no doubt say that theft was theft—that setting a minimum was tantamount to saying that stealing was acceptable, just as long as you steal too much. He looked at Chris. "You know, we've both got teenagers. Is this really a message you want to send out, especially to kids? You know as well as I do that there's nothing they like better than testing limits. It's almost an invitation to see if you can beat the system." But then Ross faltered as he found himself glancing at the latest financial figures on his desk—another in a string of quarterly losses. If West-wind went under, a lot of employees would be looking for another way to make a living. In his heart, he believed in his father's high moral standards, but he had to ask himself: Just how moral could Westwind afford to be? Adopt Chris Dykstra`s proposed changes, but with a higher limit than the proposed $20 amount (say, $50 or $100), but which is still less than the cost of prosecution. In addition, make sure that the policy isn't publicized. That way, you'll reduce costs even more and still benefit from your reputation for prosecuting all shoplifters.Cousins Jeri Lynn De Bose, Tish Hoover, and Josephine (Joey) Parks looked forward to meeting up during the Christmas holidays to compare notes on the results of midyear teacher evaluations. All were public school teachers in districts scattered over the state. In the pressured search for new levels of teacher accountability demanded by legislators, the state department of education joined 16 other States in implementing a new teacher evaluation system. The goal is to hold teachers account-able for student learning progress in the classroom. Under the guidance of the National Council for Teacher Quality, criteria varies by State, but in most cases, 40 percent of each teacher's accountability score would be based on the principal's evaluation and ranking based on personal observation, 30 percent would be based on personal observation by a master teacher from outside the district, and the Other 30 percent would be based on student test score gains. The state department of education would set a performance goal each school district, and the principal would set a performance goal for each teacher. In preparation, the State conducted intensive training sessions for principals and designated master teachers who would conduct the evaluations based on four class observations per teacher Officials used standardized achievement tests to derive value-added scores that measure student learning over the year. Teacher ratings were 1-5, with I am being the lowest and 5 representing near perfection. The publication of the first year's evaluations stirred interest and controversy, particularly among teachers who worried about the possible long-term effects on job retention and tenure. Now, with the first-year evaluations in hand, the three cousins pored over their experiences. The three represented different types of school systems within the state. Jeri Lynn worked for a metropolitan system in the state capital. The system included many low-income students whose first language was nor English, and several schools within the system were teetering on the brink of State takeover if improvement in student scores didn't materialize this school year. Tish worked in a county System dominated by upper-income residents, and Joey taught in the rural community in which all three grew up. The rural community had high unemployment, and a low percentage of graduates went on to college. As a result, the cousins came to the table with differing teaching experiences. "The numbers are all over the place," Jeri Lynn remarked as she studied the pages. "The whole system is flawed, and they need to make changes," Joey said. "It's too subjective. The principal and master teacher observations are subjective because there are personal factors that affect a true outcome." "Yeah, look at the numbers from your upper-income district," Jeri Lynn said to Tish. "How can 60 percent of the teachers score 5s?' Tish chuckled. "Yeah, lucky us. Our schools are overflowing with children from wealthy families. These are the kids who will apply to Ivy League schools. I can tell you that the principals are going to avoid confrontation on all fronts. No principal is going to give any indication that their students are receiving an education that's less than perfect, and that means cramming the rankings with 5s. They claim a higher level of motivation for students, and thus the selection of an elite team of educators. So with those pressures, I don't think we get personal feedback that is accurate." "At the other end of the spectrum, we have my rural district," Joey said. "The big problem is that the principals know everyone and have longstanding relationships with everyone in the county, so I think scores are based on personal history. We could almost predict who would get high or low scores before the observations. For principals, it can go back as far as 'his daddy and my daddy hated each other in high school, and now I get to evaluate his daughter "I think that in many cases, principals feel pressure to align scores with state expectations. The stare expected my district to have high scores and expected rural schools such as yours to be lower," Tish said. "But isn't that partially offset by lower goals for the rural school distracts responded Joey. "The key to the accountability system is the principal in each school," Jeri Lynn suggested. "With several of the schools in Metro teetering on the edge of state takeover by the end of the year, we had lots of strict principals who wanted to hold our feet to the fire with lower scores." "I thought the whole idea was to provide the teachers With feedback so that we would know the areas where we need improvement," Tish said. "The principals were supposed to conduct two observations in the fall and two more in the spring," Jeri Lynn said. think that's asking too much of them when they already have so much on their plates. I think a lot of them are skimping on their visits. know I only had one observation last semester, and I'm sure Mr. Talley just faked the second set of numbers. The master teachers make only two observations a year, which may be more objective but counts for less." "I'm wondering, too, how a principal measure performance in a course area outside his area of expertise, such as math," Joey said. "If the guy has a phobia about math, anything the teacher says or does is going to 100k brilliant-thus a 5." Tish and Jeri Lynn looked at each other and laughed. "Maybe we picked the wrong subjects," Tish said. "My question is one of perception," Jeri Lynn said. "A large percentage of my students are ELL. That affects their scores. How do you measure a 3 in my situation against a 5 for Tish? At the end of the school year, little Carlos is thrilled that his reading in English has improved, but there`s no Big Bang here. a slow steady improvement that may not actually show up in big strides for a couple of years: "So, the question is how do they create a system that is fair?" Tish asked. "And accurate," added Jeri Lynn. How might the state control the accuracy of principals who are conducting teacher evaluations? Explain.Cousins Jeri Lynn DeBose, Tish Hoover, and Josephine (Joey) Parks looked forward to meeting up during the Christmas holidays to compare notes on the results of midyear teacher evaluations. All were public school teachers in districts scattered over the state. In the pressured search for new levels of teacher accountability demanded by legislators, the state department of education joined 16 other States in implementing a new teacher evaluation system. The goal is to hold teachers account-able for student learning progress in the classroom. Under the guidance of the National Council for Teacher Quality, criteria varies by State, but in most cases, 40 percent of each teacher's accountability score would be based on the principal's evaluation and ranking based on personal observation, 30 percent would be based on personal observation by a master teacher from outside the district, and the Other 30 percent would be based on student test score gains. The state department of education would set a performance goal each school district, and the principal would set a performance goal for each teacher. In preparation, the State conducted intensive training sessions for principals and designated master teachers who would conduct the evaluations based on four class observations per teacher. Officials used standardized achievement tests to derive value-added scores that measure student learning over the year. Teacher ratings were I —5, with I am being the lowest and 5 representing near perfection. The publication of the first year's evaluations stirred interest and controversy, particularly among teachers who worried about the possible long-term effects on job retention and tenure. Now, with the first-year evaluations in hand, the three cousins pored over their experiences. The three represented different types of school systems within the state. Jeri Lynn worked for a metropolitan system in the state capital. The system included many low-income students whose first language was nor English, and several schools within the system were teetering on the brink of State takeover if improvement in student scores didn't materialize this school year. Tish worked in a county System dominated by upper-income residents, and Joey taught in the rural community in which all three grew up. The rural community had high unemployment, and a low percentage of graduates went on to college. As a result, the cousins came to the table with differing teaching experiences. "The numbers are all over the place," Jeri Lynn remarked as she studied the pages. "The whole system is flawed, and they need to make changes," Joey said. " It's too subjective. The principal and master teacher observations are subjective because there are personal factors that affect a true outcome." "Yeah, look at the numbers from your upper-income district," Jeri Lynn said to Tish. "How can 60 percent of the teachers score 5s?" Tish chuckled. "Yeah, lucky us. Our schools are overflowing with children from wealthy families. These are the kids who will apply to Ivy League schools. I can tell you that the principals are going to avoid confrontation on all fronts. No principal is going to give any indication that their students are receiving an education that's less than perfect, and that means cramming the rankings with 5s. They claim a higher level of motivation for students, and thus the selection of an elite team of educators. So with those pressures, I don't think we get personal feedback that IS accurate." "At the other end of the spectrum, we have my rural district," Joey said. "The big problem is that the principals know everyone and have longstanding relationships with everyone in the county, so I think scores are based on personal history. We could almost predict who would get high or low scores before the observations. For principals, it can go back as far as his daddy and my daddy hated each other in high school, and now I get to evaluate his daughter "I think that in many cases, principals feel pressure to align scores with state expectations. The stare expected my district to have high scores and expected rural schools such as yours to be lower," Tish said. "But isn't that partially offset by lower goals for the rural school distracts responded Joey. "The key to the accountability system is the principal in each school," Jeri Lynn suggested. "With several of the schools in Metro teetering on the edge of state takeover by the end of the year, we had lots of strict principals who wanted to hold our feet to the fire with lower scores." "l thought the whole idea was to provide the teachers With feedback so that we would know the areas where we need improvement," Tish said. "The principals were supposed to conduct two observations in the fall and two more in the spring," Jeri Lynn said. think that's asking too much of them when they already have so much on their plates. I think a lot of them are skimping on their visits. know I only had one observation last semester, and I'm sure Mr. Talley just faked the second set of numbers. The master teachers make only two observations a year, which may be more objective but counts for less." "I'm wondering, too, how a principal measure performance in a course area outside his area of expertise, such as math," Joey said. "If the guy has a phobia about math, anything the teacher says or does is going to 100k brilliant—thus a 5." Tish and Jeri Lynn looked at each other and laughed. Maybe we picked the wrong subjects," Tish said. "My question is one of perception," Jeri Lynn said. "A large percentage of my students are ELL. That affects their scores. How do you measure a 3 in my situation against a 5 for Tish? At the end of the school year, little Carlos is thrilled that his reading in English has improved, but there's no Big Bang here. a slow steady improvement that may not actually show up in big strides for a couple of years: "So, the question is how do they create a system that is fair?" Tish asked. "And accurate," added Jeri Lynn. What do you see as the major strengths and flaws in the feedback control system used in the schools in this scenario? What changes do you recommend to overcome the flaws?
