Phil potential questions
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Concordia University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
266
Subject
Philosophy
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by tinhinanekessai
Phil potential questions
Philo and Cleanthes are characters in a philosophical dialogue who discuss the teleological argument in detail. Who composed this dialogue?
The philosophical dialogue between Philo and Cleanthes discussing the teleological argument is found in David Hume's work "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion." This dialogue
presents a critical examination of the teleological argument for the existence of God, with Philo raising objections and Cleanthes defending the argument.
What does telos mean?
"Telos" is a Greek term that refers to the ultimate purpose, goal, or end towards which something is directed or aimed. In philosophical contexts, it often implies the inherent purpose or aim that guides the development or functioning of a thing or system. The concept of telos is significant in teleological arguments, where the existence of purpose or design in nature is used to infer the existence of a designer or creator.
Is the cosmological argument an a priori argument or an a posteriori argument?
posteriori argument. It relies on empirical evidence and observations about the existence and nature of the universe to argue for the existence of a first cause or necessary being, which is typically identified as God. The argument starts from the observation of contingent beings or events in the universe and reasons that there must be a necessary being outside the universe that caused or explains its existence.
The example of the ‘Lost Island’ was brought up against the ontological argument. Which thinker provided this example and objection?
The objection of the "Lost Island" against the ontological argument was proposed by the monk Gaunilo of Marmoutiers. Gaunilo presented this objection in response to Anselm's ontological argument, suggesting that if one were to apply Anselm's reasoning to other concepts like a perfect island, it would lead to absurd conclusions.
Mackie holds it is rational to believe the existing universe could lack a ____.
argues that it is rational to believe that the existing universe could lack a "supernatural being" or a "creator." He suggests that the existence of such a being is not a necessary assumption and that the universe could exist without it. Mackie is known for his critiques of religious belief and theistic arguments.
What is the ‘watchmaker argument’? Do you think it survives criticism?
watchmaker argument" is a classic teleological argument for the existence of God, associated with Paley. It analogizes the complexity found in the universe to the intricacy of a watch’s mechanism. Basically, a watch we find lying around has parts which are arranged so as to achieve a purpose (to tell the time. Meaning there is a means to an ends arrangements in that specific watch). Just as a watch suggests the existence of a watchmaker, Paley argues that the complexity and design of the universe imply the existence of an intelligent designer (God). Critics argue that the analogy between a watch and the universe is flawed because they are
fundamentally different. Critics suggest that the apparent design and order in the universe can be explained through naturalistic processes such as evolution, cosmology, and natural selection,
without the need for a supernatural designer. infinite Regress: The argument raises questions about the origins of the supposed intelligent designer. If complexity requires a designer, then the designer itself would also require an explanation for its complexity, leading to an infinite regress of designers.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help