ESSAY_ ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Liberty University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
JURI 600
Subject
Philosophy
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
Pages
4
Uploaded by LieutenantComputerArmadillo34
Akeema Wignall
Liberty University
Professor Roach
November 19, 2023
The intersection of military policy and gender equality can be seen in Army Regulation
600-13, which delineates the assignment policy of female officers. The regulation permits female
soldiers to serve in various sectors but imposes restrictions on roles involving unpretentious
combat missions. This scenario was the introduction of the G.I. Jane Bill to Virginia, where a
graduate who applied for an officer position in a combat engagement unit was denied due to her
gender, which is in accordance with AR 600-13. This essay will investigate whether AR 600-13
violates the biblical equality principles in the course materials. Genesis 1:27 states, "So God
created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him, male and female he created
them." They were given equal tasks of ruling and subduing all creatures (Genesis 1:28). It is
evident and one of the most explicit passages of scripture that position both man and woman as
equal. This scripture alone should underscore the biblical stance on equality. However, before
progressing any further, it is imperative to comprehend the inception of such a law by scoping
out the Declaration of Independence and the American Constitution during the birth of a nation.
This is arguably the most renounced line uttered in the Declaration of Independence; we
hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their
Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of
Happiness. This has been a century-long debate as few words in American history are invoked as
often as those from the preamble to the Declaration of Independence, published nearly 250 years
ago
1
. With such a bold declaration regarding human nature and natural rights, the central claim
that “all men are created equal” had profound implications for the American regime of liberty
2
.
This was an endorsement of principles that the common good could be achieved only through
faithful adherence to the principle of equality for all men
3
; nevertheless, common law was well
suited to carry out this fundamental purpose of the Declaration, but not without some
controversy such as the implementation of no special privileges
4
. Special privileges in terms of
the Declaration of Independence based upon church affiliation were forbidden by provisions like
Section III of the Delaware Constitution:
That all persons professing the Christian religion ought forever to enjoy equal
rights and privilege in this enjoy equal rights and privilege in this state unless,
under colour of religion any man disturb the peace, the happiness, or safety of
society
5
.
AR 600-13 deals with a specific special privilege within the army that restricts female
officers from assuming roles involving direct combat. It is within their rights that both Madison
and Hamilton believe that one cannot have a government that grants entitlements’; otherwise, the
government will be controlled by “special privileges” and will cease to be a republican
government
6
. It is telling that in the Constitution now proposed to us, power is reserved to the
people constitutionally to reduce every officer again to a private station: and what a guard is this
6
H
ERBERT
W. T
ITUS
, G
OD
,
MAN
,
AND LAW
: T
HE BIBLICAL PRINCIPLES
105(1998).
5
H
ERBERT
W. T
ITUS
, G
OD
,
MAN
,
AND LAW
: T
HE BIBLICAL PRINCIPLES
104 (1998).
4
Id
.
3
H
ERBERT
W. T
ITUS
, G
OD
,
MAN
,
AND LAW
: T
HE BIBLICAL PRINCIPLES
99 (1998).
2
Amanda Hughes, D
ECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
,
AND PRINCIPLE THAT ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL
-
CONSTITUTING
A
MERICA
C
ONSTITUTING
A
MERICA
- ( Nov 19, 2023),
https://constitutingamerica.org/90day-dcin-declaration-of-independence-and-principle-that-all-m
en-are-created-equal-guest-essayist-tony-williams/).
1
Hillel Italie, C
ENTURIES
-
LONG DEBATE CONTINUES OVER
“
ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL
”( Nov 19,
2023),https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/centuries-long-debate-continues-over-all-men-are-cr
eated-equa.
against their invasion of other rights or abusing of their power!
7
. We know now that the principle
of the common law did not prevail in the United States of America, as Congress refused to
include Jefferson’s charge against King Goeoge; that refusal was followed by several
compromises on the slavery issue
8
.
Throughout the centuries, the teaching of the Bible has provoked an unfavorable
reputation. As some Christians have, at times, interpreted it in some ways that seem to justify
slavery and other human rights atrocities. It has come to some Christians even now teaching that
women must always take subordinate roles in the family and the church, saying men must be the
final authority figures
9
. There is no doubt that this teaching is ultimately out of line with the
model and teachings of Jesus
10
. Without hesitation, it can be asserted that AR 600-13 violates the
biblical principles of equality outlined in the Bible, infringing on Jane’s rights.
The concept of Biblical equality is rooted and grounded in our Savior, Christ the Lord,
and in his book
11
. The American Constitution states that all citizens enjoyed equal political
liberty by giving their consent to representative government at all levels and by participating in
government
12
. The concept of equality, as demonstrated by AR 600-13, deviates from biblical
12
Amanda Hughes, D
ECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
,
AND PRINCIPLE THAT ALL MEN ARE CREATED EQUAL
-
CONSTITUTING
A
MERICA
C
ONSTITUTING
A
MERICA
- (Nov 19, 2023),
https://constitutingamerica.org/90day-dcin-declaration-of-independence-and-principle-that-all-m
en-are-created-equal-guest-essayist-tony-williams/.
11
Id
10
Id
9
Alan G. Padgett, W
HAT IS BIBLICAL EQUALITY
? CBE I
NTERNATIONAL
(Nov 19, 2023),
https://www.cbeinternational.org/resource/what-biblical-equality/.
8
H
ERBERT
W. T
ITUS
, G
OD
,
MAN
,
AND LAW
: T
HE BIBLICAL PRINCIPLES
107 (1998).
7
Id
.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
principles, challenging the notion that everyone possesses equal standing as per the teaching of
the Bible.