Healthcare Economic Issues
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Capella University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
6008
Subject
Health Science
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
docx
Pages
6
Uploaded by PresidentIron12521
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
Healthcare Economic Issues
Antonietta Scirocco
Capella University
NHS-FPX6008 Economic Decision-Making in Health Care
Dr. Kathryn Rudd
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
Healthcare Economic Issues
Labor Shortages in Healthcare can be a significant economic issue with vast
consequences. These shortages occur when there is an insufficient number of healthcare
professionals, such as doctors, nurses, and other essential staff, to meet the demands of
healthcare services. This has occurred at most healthcare facilities, especially since the Covid-19
pandemic. Some reasonings behind the shortages are the aging labor force, the facility's inability
to retain staff, and staff moving onto work positions that do not require in-person presence.
Working from home has become the new norm that has pirated many on-the-job laborers away
from the brick-and-mortar facilities.
Labor Shortages
There are many contributing factors to labor shortages, such as burnout, an aging
workforce, and the need for more workforce demand. Many of these factors were highlighted
during the COVID-19 pandemic, whereas the mature nurses close to retirement chose to retire
rather than work under conditions that would endanger their health. Additionally, with COVID-
19, burnout was familiar as many nurses were overworked due to the shortages and unsavory
work conditions. To compensate for the staff shortages during the pandemic, healthcare workers
were often mandated to work longer than regular work shifts and take on more responsibilities
than their scope of practice, which led to higher rates of burnout, lower job satisfaction, and
increased staff turnover. All these situations further exacerbated the labor shortage problems. In
Michaeli’s article “The Healthcare Labor Shortage: Practice, theory, evidence, and Ways
Forward,” he writes in response to the shortage of nurses during the COVID-19 crisis, New York
hospitals raised wages, leading to an increased labor supply as nurses from all over the United
States and even retired New York nurses came to the rescue. [ CITATION Dan22 \l 1033 ]
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
Hence, the birth and sensationalizing of the traveling healthcare providers. Major city hospitals
still have many shortages, and the financial incentives to fill these positions are lucrative. While
the concept of traveling nurses is adaptable to many other platforms and includes highly
incentivized pay scales, there are drawbacks, such as the traveler leaving their permanent facility
with a shortage and many travelers encountering disgruntled staff at the work assignment
because they are being paid so much more than the regular staff. Many hospitals have had to do
market analysis surveys to evaluate how they compare to other hospitals and to retain staff. They
provided them with market adjustments to the pay. Doing this worked twofold for the facility's
benefit: first, the team would be retained because of the higher income, and second, they could
decrease their traveler staff, bringing down the expenditures.
Aging Workforce
The aging workforce is another part of labor shortages. Especially during the COVID-19
pandemic, we saw a massive migration to retirement in older healthcare workers, who might
have worked longer if we did not have the pandemic. The two main reasons for their retirement
besides that they were at the retirement age were fear of contracting COVID-19 with
complicating effects on their health and working in unacceptable conditions like reusing masks
and PPE, longer than regular shift hours, working in unsafe environments that they never worked
in before and lastly, an overwhelming number of patients per caregiver.
According to N. Renuga Nagarajan’s article, “Policy Initiatives to Address the Challenges
of an Older Population in the Workforce,” retaining older workers and simultaneously protecting
their wellbeing is a significant challenge. [ CITATION NRe21 \l 1033 ]
Aging workers believe
that their physical fitness, cognitive status, and lack of knowledge of new technology hinder their
ongoing workforce participation. Consequently, most aging workers’ difficulty in adopting new
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
technology can be traced back to fewer opportunities to access training. This challenges younger
supervisors as to how to create an age-friendly work environment and maintain an anti-age
biases atmosphere.
To retain staff and rehire older workers, healthcare facilities looked to their government
agencies to change antiquated policies. Agencies like the Gerontological Society of America
have worked closely with government agencies to encourage facilities to provide a flexible
workplace, like having flexible hours and no call for workers over a certain age. They have also
created more support systems through in-house education to help the older workers remain
diligent in learning new technology and continuously rehire older workers.
Healthcare Economic Choice Rationale
I chose labor shortages as a healthcare economic issue because I have seen firsthand how
it affected the facility where I work. Older staff have trained me, and I enjoyed working with
them, retired during the COVID-19 pandemic. Additionally, I saw how some of the more senior
staff struggled with the workplace hardships placed upon them that created an unacceptable work
environment. Additionally, I saw new, inexperienced nurses train with our team and then leave to
become travel nurses with more lucrative salaries. I have also worked closely with travel staff,
making salaries three times as much as we were and doing the same work. These conditions
created an unpleasant work environment where many came and went.
Has staff retention seen an upswing at our facility? The answer is yes because the facility
utilized a third-party agency to conduct a market analysis of state salaries compared to ours, and
the verdict was that we were underpaid, and market adjustments were made. While retention has
improved, areas like the emergency room, various intensive care units, and trauma operating
rooms are still understaffed. In speaking with staff from those areas, one of the main reasons was
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
that their work/life balance was interrupted because of longer call schedules and more stressful
shifts, creating burnout quickly.
Conclusion
In conclusion, labor shortages are still a global phenomenon as the “baby boomer”
generation retires, but knowing that people live longer, are more active, and stay healthier. The
aging population is no longer viewed as a burden on society. Burnout is happening less as
employers utilize grid systems for self-scheduling, where employees can submit more agreeable
schedules for a better work-life balance. Lastly, workforce retention has improved, so staffing is
not unbalanced and creates a more positive work environment.
Bibliography
Daniel Tobias Michaeli, M., Julia Caroline Michaeli, M., Sebastian Albers, M., & Thomas
Michaeli, M. M. (2022, March 26).
The Healthcare Labor Shortage: Practice, Theory,
Evidence, and Ways Forward
. Retrieved from SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4067462
HEALTHCARE ECONOMIC ISSUE
Nagarajan, N. R., & Sixsmith, A. (2021). Policy Initiatives to Address the Challenges of an Older
Population in the Workforce.
Springer Science
, 41-56.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help