Writer's Notebook 2.2
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Dallas County Community College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
ENGLISH LI
Subject
English
Date
Jan 9, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
6
Uploaded by MateOysterPerson905
Julisa Moctezuma
Professor Jensen
ENGL 1301-82601
18 December 2023
Annotation Practice
For this assignment, you will annotate an article, a copy of which is pasted below. There are three steps involved. Please read the instructions and follow each step carefully. Before proceeding, turn on Track Changes under the Review tab in Word
. Be sure your Track Changes shows All Markup not just a Simple Markup.
Step 1: Predict and preview
After reading the title and glancing over the text, what do you think the text will be about? What do you understand about the text from the title? What do you know already about this topic? What questions do you have about the text? Type your response to the preview questions here
: After reading the title and glancing at the text I believe this article is about teachers doing uber in the evenings and on the weekends because they cannot survey off of their salary. I understand that this text will help us understand why teache
r feel like they need to uber in order to be able to survive. I already know that a teacher salary is not very high and should be raised just based on the daily stuff they deal with from kids.
The question
s
I have is how much do teachers really make, has it increased due to the cost of living raising, and why don’t teacher make closer to $100
,000 than to $50,000?
Step 2: Read, summarize, and annotate
As you read the article, use the Track Changes function to annotate the text below as follows:
Summarize
. Double-click the last word
of a paragraph, and then click the New Comment button under the Review tab to add a comment box. Type your one sentence
summary (paraphrase) of the paragraph in the box. Summarize every paragraph in the essay. Group short paragraphs of the same topic together for summarizing.
Define Vocabulary
. Double-click any word you do not understand, click New Comment, and provide a definition. Dictionary.com
is a good and quick resource for this. NOTE: Only put the definition for the word in its exact context here (not all the definitions).
Annotate
. Use the functions in Microsoft Word to highlight sections or words and underline sentences or sections that are important, just like you would if you were annotating a hard copy of the essay. Use the following key to annotate your text:
Highlight the main ideas of paragraphs, including the thesis
Underline
supporting details or interesting quotes/facts/ideas
Bold
any counterarguments.
Step Three: Answering questions about the text
After you have finished reading and annotating the text, return to this step and answer the following questions. Type your responses directly beneath each question
.
1.
Why, according to Quart, has teaching “always been a poorly paid profession”?
a.
According to Quart, teaching has “always been a poorly paid profession” because
historical perceptions of teaching are that it is “women’s work.” Since women are paid less than men accounting to the gender norms in our country the pay structure has not had the chance to catch up so that the salary could be within market value for the cost of living.
2.
According to Quart, what is the problem with Uber defining its drivers as “independent contractors”?
a.
According to Quart, the problem with Uber defining its drivers as “independent contractors” is that it makes it where they can lack in protecting their drivers and
not have to provide them with benefits. As a contractor those employees are not
entitled to overtime pay, minimum wages, or any protections with labor laws.
3.
According to the article, what are the primary reasons for so many teachers taking positions
as Uber drivers?
a.
According to the article, the primary reasons many teachers are taking positions as Uber drivers is because their salary does not cover the rising cost of living in the United States
. They become Uber drivers because it is flexible,
and they can do it on their own schedule and as little or as much as they want to to help offset
the struggle of housing cost and insurance cost.
4.
What is your response to this reading? What did the article add to your knowledge or understanding of this topic?
a.
This article helps shed light on the financial struggles teachers in America especially Califor
nia has
to face on a daily basis
. It also highlights the role the gig economy which is exemplified by uber provides in supplementary income. It help
ed me to understand that teachers are undervalued and underpaid which is causing negative attitudes towards the profession of teaching. It taught me that ther
e are ongoing discussions about the gig economy, financial struggles, and labor rights of teachers.
Article to be used:
“Teachers Are Working for Uber Just to Keep a Foothold in the Middle Class,” by Alyssa Quart, The Nation, 7 Sept., 2016, https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/teachers-are-working-
for-uber-just-to-keep-a-foothold-in-the-middle-class/
Matt Barry teaches history and economics to eleventh and twelfth graders at Live Oak High School, a public school in a suburb of San Jose, California
. At 32, he’s in his ninth year on the job, teaching 35 students in each class. But Barry also has a second life that’s becoming increasingly common for American schoolteachers: He spends his after-school hours and weekends as an Uber driver in order to earn extra money.
Barry and his wife, Nicole, are both teachers, and each earns $69,000 per year, which should place them solidly within the middle class.
If Silicon Valley hadn’t sprawled around them, that’s where they would be. But the explosion in wealth that has accompanied the tech boom has sent housing costs well beyond the reach of longtime working- and middle-
class residents. In the town where Barry teaches, the median home price is $800,000, ensuring that the people who spend their days educating Live Oak students will never live near them. In Barry’s own neighborhood of Gilroy, a 20-minute drive from his school, the median home price is $650,000. When Barry’s child is born—Nicole is pregnant—the family will pay an additional $6,000 dollars in health insurance annually; if she takes time off, that will more than double, to $14,400
. Barry shocks his Uber passengers when he tells them about his day job as he shuttles them around ritzy Morgan Hill, where his high school is located
. Between rides, he grades papers. Among teachers, he’s not even the worst off—he and Nicole each earn an income, and they own their home. Even so, they are on the financial edge. “Teachers are killing themselves,” he says. “I shouldn’t be having to drive Uber 8 o’clock on a weekday. I just shut down from the mental toll: grading papers in between rides, thinking of what I could be doing
instead of driving—like creating a curriculum
.”
Yet it’s no accident that Barry is driving for Uber
. For the last two years, the company has sponsored initiatives to encourage teachers to moonlight as chauffeurs. The campaigns differ from city to city and from year to year. In 2014, the Uber campaign’s discomfiting motto
was “Teachers: Driving Our Future.” In 2015, Uber offered teachers in Chicago a summer job; to sweeten the deal, the ride-share company gave a $250 bonus to any teacher who signed up to drive by a certain date and completed 10 car trips. In Oregon, Uber notifies riders when their driver is a teacher and trumpets the fact that 3 percent of each fare goes back to the driver’s classroom. The company also offers a $5,000 bonus to the school with the most active drivers
.
Uber has promoted its teacher/driver initiative as an act of civic altruism, a perfect private-sector remedy to the failures of the public sphere
. An Uber blogger named “Lindsey” gushed: “Every day teachers are asked to do more with less, constantly faced with new challenges and limited resources. Uber opens the door for more possibilities and delivers a meaningful impact to the communities we serve.” Yet beneath this feel-good veneer, there’s a far more troubling reality: Teachers like Matt Barry are “asked to do more with less” because the public, and the politicians who represent us, don’t value teachers enough to pay them more
. This has been true since the dawn of this country’s modern education system. But the consequences have grown particularly acute in boom regions like Silicon Valley, where the mismatch between teacher salaries and local housing costs has become ever more pronounced. In these places, wealthy residents shell out for custom-built houses with swimming pools and “super basements” but are rarely willing to pay higher taxes so that their teachers can afford to pay rent
.
Uber has hailed this arrangement as an “opportunity” for teachers, a chance to boost their earnings while “dedicating their lives to shaping students’ futures.”
It’s supposedly a prime example of the “sharing economy” at work. Yet stripped of their gloss of generosity, Uber’s teacher/driver campaigns also share in a more twisted Silicon Valley fantasy: low taxes, good schools—and your kid’s teacher might drive you home after your expense-
account meal with a venture capitalist
! * * * Teaching has always been a poorly paid profession, particularly considering its educational requirements and responsibilities
. Part of the reason for the lower pay is that at the dawn of the modern public-school system, teaching was considered “women’s work,” and thus the second income in families, according to Richard Ingersoll, a professor of education and sociology at the University of Pennsylvania. That’s no longer the case, but the weak pay that reflects an earlier sexism endures.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
To help make up the shortfall, teachers—even those who earn a 12-month salary—
have often taken on an additional job during summer
. What’s new is the degree of desperation. Teachers who are chronically underpaid in places like Oklahoma are forced to rely on soup kitchens and food stamps in addition to second jobs. In Mandan, North Dakota, Rebecca Maloney, an elementary-school teacher and single mother with three kids, turned to
the crowdfunding site GoFundMe to raise $1,000 for a career-development class at the local university. Meanwhile, teachers working in increasingly expensive locales like San Francisco and Chicago are forced into the lowest echelons of the gig economy or to work other side jobs like bartending in order to survive
. This summer, I spoke to a number of schoolteachers who are now racking up miles as Uber drivers.
These include John Daniels, a history teacher at James Lick High School in east San Jose, California, who has started giving rides for Uber in his Toyota 4Runner on Thursday and Friday nights, and Anthony Arinwine, a first-grade teacher at Malcolm X Academy in San Francisco, who spends 20 hours per week driving for the company in his Nissan Altima.
“My rent was increasing, and the cost of utilities was going up,” he explains. “My normal
salary”—$70,000—“didn’t have a lot left over compared to previous years.” Though San Francisco boasts some of the highest rents in the state, with the median rent for a one-
bedroom apartment at $3,500 a month compared to a statewide median of $1,750, San Francisco’s school district ranks 528th in terms of teacher pay out of the 821 districts in California
. As Arinwine watched his rent for a one-bedroom apartment in the East Bay jump from $1,300 to $1,500 and then to $2,000, he began driving for the ride-share company, often
late into the night. Despite driving on the side, he eventually had to give up the apartment. Now he’s renting a room from a friend. “I’m not able to buy a house. I may have to move to a state that’s less expensive, unless I get married and have a dual income,” says Arinwine. His parents, a civilian worker in the military, now retired, and a clerk at the police department, only attended “some junior college.” Yet he describes them as more financially comfortable dwelling in Orange County, where they lived until recently, than he is in the Bay Area. “I couldn’t afford to have a child on my income. I can’t imagine giving kids what they need to be
happy. I thought I’d not be worrying about money by now,” adds Arinwine, who is 46. “I thought I’d be making my way to retirement
.” For Uber, the struggles of these economically challenged teachers represent a dual opportunity: a marketing coup as well as a ready labor force
. When Uber started to take off three years ago, the company’s CEO, Travis Kalanick, claimed that working for Uber could be a full-time job, with drivers making as much as $100,000 a year. But when reporters examined Uber drivers’ pay stubs, they discovered this was far from the truth. In recent years, with the help of former Obama campaign manager David Plouffe, who was hired in 2014 as a senior vice president, Uber has been trying to market itself as the ride service that employs struggling middle-class people, not only teachers but municipal workers, nurses, journalists, and academics. (Plouffe has since been replaced and is now serving as a “strategic
adviser” to the company.) “Uber has been extremely clever at finding occupations like this—
they say that this is your neighbor driving for extra money,” notes Steven Hill, author of
Raw Deal: How the “Uber Economy” and Runaway Capitalism Are Screwing American Workers
. When I reached out to Uber for comment, Michael Amodeo, an Uber spokesman, directed me to an essay that Plouffe had written for Medium
that gave Uber’s PR strategy a civic-minded bent. Freelancing for Uber, writes Plouffe, serves as the “pay raise they [the drivers] have not received in their other jobs.” In an e-mail, Amodeo asserted that “What we’ve learned is that teachers and educators see Uber as a flexible way to make money with their car
.” * * *
Little of the desperation I heard from drivers comes across in Uber’s marketing campaign. Instead, the company’s website teems with cherry-picked profiles of middle-class Uber drivers who ride-share as a way to collect extra spending money. Monique, a schoolteacher in New Orleans with “12 years of teaching experience under her belt,” turned to Uber to “help during the 2015 holiday season.” For nurse-cum–Uber driver Rory, “Driving is
just ‘a hobby.’… Rory is, in fact, a full-time nurse at Hartford Hospital, working the night shift from 7pm-7am 3 days a week. Though he has a tough schedule, he enjoys having four days off
in a row”—which he uses to drive for Uber to “help with my car payments.” Another of the drivers profiled is a frustrated special-education teacher sick of doing “paperwork” rather than working with children; she started driving for Uber to help pay for a renovation for her porch. These testimonies, accompanied by inspirational videos of real-life driver/teachers on YouTube, fit nicely with Uber’s portrait of its “UberEducators” as wholesome, hardworking professionals. But they also telegraph something else: that Uber’s workers have turned to driving not as a full-time profession, but as a second job
. This is a useful message for Uber, which has been working hard to push the idea that its 450,000 drivers are independent contractors, not employees of the company
. As employees, drivers would be entitled to a minimum wage, overtime pay, and basic labor protections, and full-time drivers could be eligible for benefits—things that would strike at the very core of Uber’s business model. Many drivers, along with leading labor advocates, don’t agree that Uber’s drivers are independent contractors and have begun challenging the company in court
. Uber is currently fending off nearly a dozen lawsuits alleging that it has misclassified its workers, including a sprawling class-action suit filed on behalf of drivers in California and Massachusetts. (In April, the company agreed to settle with the plaintiffs, promising $100 million in exchange for the right to continue classifying the drivers as contractors, but in August the judge rejected the settlement.) When I asked Amodeo via e-mail whether Uber drivers were employees or contractors, his answer was curt: “People who drive with Uber are independent contractors…. They value their independence—the freedom to push a button rather than punch a clock.” It remains to be seen whether Uber, valued at $62.5 billion at the end of 2015, will get
its way. What is clear is that the continuing crisis in teachers’ pay won’t be going away with the touch of an app
T
. * * * Uber is hardly the first company to exploit the financial vulnerability of teachers—and the desperation of public schools more broadly—to score PR points
. Amazon, Boeing, Bank of
America, and other corporations have played the part of school benefactor, offering everything from reward programs to school supplies. And their largesse is often welcome. In a world in which teachers can’t pay their rent—and students don’t have access to basics like textbooks—they may have no other choice. And yet, there must be other options—other answers for teachers besides grading papers while idling at red lights
. In recent years, a handful of local governments have begun to offer partial solutions, most notably in the form of housing-assistance programs for teachers
. In Los Angeles, Milwaukee, and Hertford, North Carolina, among other places, school districts have invested in faculty housing as a way to keep up with the cost of real estate. Three years ago, Newark opened Teachers Village, a six-building complex that includes residential housing marketed to
teachers as well as retail stores. Thanks to the oil boom, the cost of living in Williston, North Dakota, rose sharply, and the school district offered subsidized housing in response. “The cost
of housing went up to $2,000 dollars a month, [while] first-year teachers made about $30,000
to $32,000 a year,” says Kelly Hagen, a communications director for North Dakota United, a state teachers union. “When the teachers weren’t living together in the affordable housing, they were sometimes living in the most decrepit places and not able to afford food
.”
Affordable teacher housing is one fix. But the larger problem of undervalued—and underpaid—teachers persists
. “It should be a warning sign to us that teachers have to grade papers between giving lifts,” says the University of Pennsylvania’s Ingersoll. “Just look at high-test-scoring Asian nations, where teachers are in the top of their college classes and are well paid. How do we compare?” Matthew Hardy, communications director for the United Educators of San Francisco, has seen the fallout of this country’s failure to support its teachers. “Due to the cost of housing, the district is unable to recruit and maintain professionals. Too many of them just leave to go to higher-paying suburbs or out of state.”
Jodi Zipkoff is a special-education paraprofessional at San Francisco’s Mission High School who drives for Lyft (Uber’s chief competitor
) because, she says, if she wants to live in San Francisco, she has no other choice: She makes just over $20 an hour working with public-
school students with cerebral palsy, and makes more money ride-sharing than she does helping kids. She drives for Lyft seven days a week, 30 to 35 hours a week, during the summer, plus weekends during the school year. When I catch up with Matt Barry, the history teacher and expectant father, at the end of the summer, he says he’s not driving anymore
. “
You don’t make much money in the summer, and the surges have gone down,” he explains. Since he and his wife are expecting their first child, however, he’s come up with another way to make a little extra money—he and Nicole rented their house out to golf caddies for the US Women’s Open
.
______
Alissa Quart is the executive editor of the Economic Hardship Reporting Project and author of the poetry book Monetized
as well as three non-fiction books including Branded
and Republic of
Outsiders
. She writes the Outclassed column for The Guardian
and her next non-fiction book will be published in 2018.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help