Sample PS Analysis
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Pennsylvania State University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
15
Subject
English
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
14
Uploaded by CountUniverse24933
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis Problem-Solution Argumentative Research Paper Analysis
This Sample Analysis serves as your last Reading Response of the semester. Mark your responses in blue
. No late work will be accepted. You may work on your own or with one peer of your choice. In the latter case, only one peer should submit the document. Put your name and your peer’s name on this document. Your grades will be the same in the case of group work.
Name: VEDANT AGARWAL
A.
Addressing the Required Components on the Assignment Sheet
Read the Sample Paper and the Module 3-Part Three Task Overview, Deadlines, and Requirements Page. Has the Sample Paper addressed all the requirements? B. Topic and Argument
1.
In your own words, what’s the author’s argument (Thesis Statement)?
The claim made by the author, or thesis statement, is that music therapy works best in treating teenage mental health issues in the United States. In contrast to traditional medicine and physical exercise, music
therapy has been shown to have positive impacts on patients' emotions and behaviors. The essay provides evidence and justification for this assertion, arguing that music therapy is a more practical and
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis adaptable kind of treatment.
2.
Do you think that this argument is clear and convincing enough? In other words, are you convinced by it? Why or why not?
The essay makes a strong case for music therapy as a successful treatment for teen mental health issues, and it does it in a fairly understandable manner. The author provides examples and relevant research findings to support her claims. However, individual viewpoints and the quality of the evidence offered may have an impact on the overall persuasiveness. To make the argument more compelling overall, it would be helpful to investigate any counterarguments or limitations of music therapy in more detail and respond to them.
3.
What is your comment on the overall quality of this argumentative research paper? Be specific. The reasoning seems pretty compelling to me. The author provides evidence of the influence of music therapy on emotions and behaviors, supporting their claim with significant research papers. To improve persuasiveness, the argument could be strengthened even more by addressing any counterarguments or admitting music therapy's limitations.
The argumentative research paper is of great overall quality. The essay has a well-defined framework with an introduction, a body, and a conclusion. References to reliable sources support the assertions. The
argument is made more understandable by the use of concrete examples and simple language.
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis 4.
If you could provide the author with one comment to better this paper, what would your advice be? In my opinion, to improve the paper's overall quality, a more thorough examination of the opposing views and a little stronger conclusion that highlights the most important issues would be beneficial.
Addressing potential objections or admitting the limitations of music therapy could also strengthen the case overall and increase persuasiveness.
C. Introduction 1.
What is the purpose of introducing the statistics from Moreh and O’lawrence (2016) at the beginning
of the paper? The purpose of the paper's introduction, which includes statistics from Moreh and O'lawrence (2016), is to establish the prevalence and significance of mental health problems among American teenagers. The author uses these figures to illustrate how common the problem is, pointing out that 5 percent of people between the ages of 9 and 17 meet the criteria for major depressive disorder, and that 10 to 15 percent of young adults may experience depression at any given time. This statistical basis establishes the topic's importance and urgency, laying the groundwork for the discussion of potential solutions that follows.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis 2.
Do you think that this purpose has been accomplished successfully? Why or why not?
Indeed, the goal of presenting the data from Moreh and O'lawrence (2016) has been effectively achieved. The data persuasively illustrates the seriousness and prevalence of mental health issues among American youth, setting the stage for the discussion of potential remedies that follows. The author effectively conveys the importance and urgency of the problem by drawing attention to the high number of young adults who suffer from depression, which raises the research paper's relevance. This statistical basis draws the reader in and lays the groundwork for an argument that is persuasive enough to support music therapy as the best course of action. Overall, the introduction successfully accomplishes its goal of presenting the topic of teenage mental health issues in a way that highlights the demand for workable solutions.
3.
What is the purpose of the paragraph that begins with “In this research paper”?
The beginning of the paragraph "In this research paper" outlines the essay's focus and organization. It gives the reader a road map by outlining the main topics that will be discussed. The author states that they will discuss the causes and consequences of mental health issues in American teenagers, assess different approaches, and then make the case that, according to their research, music therapy is the most successful approach. As a guide, this paragraph explains to readers what to expect in terms of content and argumentation as well as the paper's scope. It establishes a precise framework for the sections that follow, allowing information to flow naturally and supporting the research paper's overall structure.
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis D. Solutions
1.
In your own words, what are the three solutions that the author reviews for dealing with mental problems among teenagers?
i)
Music Therapy: The author argues that music therapy is the most effective solution. The benefits of music therapy for controlling emotions and behaviors are covered in detail, along with its adaptability as a therapeutic approach. The author provides numerous research studies to back up this solution.
ii)
Conventional Medicine: The essay provides a brief overview of conventional medicine as a potential treatment for adolescent mental health issues. It states that employing traditional medicine—specifically, prescription drugs—is a typical strategy. The disadvantages of this approach are also discussed, though, including the possibility of unfavorable physical reactions and distractions from regular tasks.
iii)
Physical Activity: As a potential remedy, physical activity is mentioned in passing in the essay. Its methodology is comparable to that of conventional medicine in that it reports potential benefits objectively while critically assessing its disadvantages. Nevertheless, the excerpt omits a thorough examination of physical activity.
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis 2.
In your words, what are the benefits of the first solution (Conventional Medicine)? What about drawbacks?
The benefits of the first solution, conventional medicine, include its convenience and widespread availability as long as patients follow the doctor's prescriptions. It has also been tested and validated for a very long time by researchers and practitioners in the fields of science and medicine. However, the author points out that one of the disadvantages of traditional medicine is the possibility of unfavorable physical side effects. It is specifically mentioned in the essay that sedatives and analgesics—which can have unfavorable side effects like nausea and vomiting—are frequently prescribed medications for teens' mental health issues. Furthermore, teenagers may become perpetually distracted from their everyday activities due to the necessity for recurrent prescriptions.
3.
Do you think that the benefits and drawbacks of the first solution are presented clearly and convincingly? Why or why not?
The essay presents the advantages and disadvantages of the first solution, conventional medicine, in a fairly understandable manner. The advantages are briefly described and include convenience and historical validation. To provide a deeper understanding, more information could be provided about
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis the disadvantages, particularly the impact on daily activities and the possibility of adverse physical reactions. The essay does present a convincing argument against traditional medicine by highlighting
particular problems, such as the side effects of widely used drugs.Overall, even though the presentation is clear, the case against conventional medicine could be strengthened with a more thorough examination of the disadvantages.
4.
As the most effective solution based on the author’s research, music therapy contains three major advantages: (1) modulating emotions, (2) regulating behaviors, and (3) flexibility. Do you think they are convincing and demonstrate the effectiveness of music therapy? Why or why not?
Yes, the three main benefits of music therapy- emotional modulation, behavior regulation, and flexibility are persuasive and adequately illustrate its efficacy. The essay provides evidence from multiple research studies to bolster these benefits, demonstrating the positive impact of music therapy on the emotions and behaviors of individuals dealing with mental health concerns. The impact of music therapy on emotions, anxiety levels, and general well-being has been empirically supported by a thorough analysis of studies by Gebhardt et al. (2018), Yang et al. (2016), and Gramaglia et al. (2019). Furthermore, the essay persuasively argues that music therapy is a flexible and approachable form of treatment because it can accommodate a wide range of musical genres, including light, classic, and rap.
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis 5.
Which advantage do you think is the most “convincing” one and why?
Out of the three benefits for music therapy, the one that seems most compelling is its emotional modulation capabilities. The essay presents data from research by Gebhardt et al. (2018), Yang et al. (2016), and Gramaglia et al. (2019) that show how music therapy improves patients' feelings and self-image while lowering their levels of anxiety and depression. These results provide a solid and thorough basis for the claim that music therapy has a positive impact on people's emotional health, including children and adolescents with mental health issues. This benefit is strengthened by the thorough examination of various research vantage points and approaches, which makes it a strong component of the case for music therapy as a whole.
6.
Why do you think does the author order the above three advantages in the current way?
The author most likely purposefully arranged the three benefits of music therapy—emotional modulation, behavior regulation, and flexibility—in order to create a coherent and convincing argument. Beginning with emotion regulation, the author highlights an important component of music therapy's effectiveness by highlighting how it affects people's internal states. This emotional regulation is an important prelude to the next benefit, behavior regulation, which brings the conversation to the external expression of the therapeutic effects. Last but not least, flexibility is emphasized as a wide-ranging benefit that applies to all genres and approaches of music therapy,
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis highlighting its capacity to accommodate personal preferences and requirements
.
7.
As an
academic reader
and based on the current information presented in the Sample Paper, are you convinced that music therapy is the most effective solution to the problem?
As an academic reader, the data in the sample paper makes a compelling case for the efficacy of music therapy in treating adolescent mental health issues. The claim that music therapy can modulate
emotions, regulate behaviors, and provide flexibility, making it a flexible and effective treatment method, is supported by the inclusion of research studies and concrete examples. It would be helpful to take into account any potential objections or restrictions that the paper does not fully address in order to assess the effectiveness. A more thorough evaluation would also result from a closer comparison with alternative approaches, particularly traditional medical care and physical activity. However, the study provides a strong basis for thinking of music therapy as a potential means of addressing adolescent mental health issues.
8.
As an
academic writer
, provide the author with one piece of advice on bettering the argument of music therapy. One suggestion to strengthen the case for music therapy would be to more clearly address any potential objections or restrictions. Even though the paper does a good job of outlining the advantages of music therapy, it would be stronger if it acknowledged and addressed any potential objections or restrictions. Think about including a section that responds to and anticipates rebuttals,
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis exhibiting a sophisticated comprehension of the complexities and possible difficulties related to music therapy as a remedy. This would show a more thorough analysis and strengthen the argument's
credibility by indicating that opposing views were carefully considered.
9.
Imagine that you are a health provider/school counselor/school nurse, do you know how to implement music therapy to treat teenagers with mental problems after you finish reading the Sample Paper? Can you describe how to implement it?
Although the sample paper gives a broad summary of music therapy's advantages, it doesn't include specific instructions on how to use music therapy with teenagers who are experiencing mental health
issues. It does, however, make reference to possible courses of action that might be taken in light of specific research.
The paper suggests that exposing teenagers to particular music genres according to their symptoms or preferences could be one way to implement music therapy. To determine stress or depression levels, a doctor, school counselor, or nurse, for example, could play music for a set amount of time (five to thirty minutes) and keep an eye on physiological markers like blood pressure and heart rate. This implementation strategy is consistent with the research that Davis and Jones (2014) reviewed.
The essay also makes the case for regular integration of music therapy as a supplemental treatment with traditional medicine. Thus, in line with the flexibility benefit mentioned in the paper, a medical professional or counselor may think about including music therapy sessions in the overall treatment
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis plan for teenagers with mental health issues.
Although the paper offers a basic understanding of the advantages of music therapy, additional professional training and consultation with knowledgeable music therapists would be necessary to successfully apply this therapeutic approach in a clinical or educational setting.
E. Organization and Structure 1. One of the most remarkable jobs the author has done is to organize the Sample Paper in a clear, logical, and coherent manner. Identify three places where you think that the author has done a great job in terms of effective organization and structure. Then, discuss why they are effective.
The Sample Paper is deftly arranged by the author in multiple important categories. First of all, the introduction is well-written, starting with powerful data to grab the reader's interest and highlight the importance of the topic. Next, the goal of the research paper is stated in detail, offering a framework for the discussion that follows. Second, the author demonstrates effective organization in the section outlining the benefits of music therapy by presenting the three main benefits—emotional modulation, behavior regulation, and flexibility—in a logical order. This produces a logical progression from fundamental elements to more general attributes. Finally, the conclusion is notable for providing a succinct yet powerful synopsis of the main ideas along with a forward-looking viewpoint. the entire essay. The author demonstrates a sophisticated grasp of the larger healthcare context by addressing the research's scope and restating the main point. Together, these examples highlight the author's information organization abilities and help to create a coherent, logical, and clear essay structure.
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis 2. What is one piece of advice you could give to the author to better the organization and structure? (Trust me, there is actually room for improvement)
The way the Sample Paper is organized is excellent, however there is room for improvement in the thorough examination of the author's limitations and counterarguments. A section of the essay that specifically addresses any potential objections or disadvantages with music therapy would be beneficial. Through proactive acknowledgment of opposing views and thoughtful rebuttals, the author can improve the argument's overall persuasiveness. This addition would further strengthen the essay's structure by demonstrating a thorough understanding of the difficulties involved in music therapy and by adding to a stronger and well-rounded discussion.
F. Language and Mechanics 1.
Fundamentally, the sense of “argumentation” and “persuasion” is delivered and realized through language. In other words, in many cases, it is our language that makes our argument convincing. Identify three places where the author uses convincing language, such as specific words and phrases. Then, discuss why they are convincing. Throughout the Sample Paper, the author skillfully uses persuasive language in a number of different
sections. Specific language in the introduction, such as "10 to 15 percent of young adults can be depressed at any given time" and "5 percent of those 9 to 17 years of age meet the criteria for major
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis depressive discord," creates a sense of urgency and offers a strong statistical foundation for the argument that follows. The author regularly emphasizes empirical support in the discussion of the benefits of music therapy by using terms like "research demonstrates," "results for the test group manifest," and "experimental study." This phrasing strengthens the accuracy of the statements and gives the argument more weight by establishing its foundation in empirical data. Furthermore, the author employs comparative language when addressing the adaptability of music therapy, noting that
it is "more advantageous than the previously discussed two solutions: using conventional medicine and encouraging physical exercise." By highlighting music therapy's advantages over other options, this comparative language effectively positions music therapy as a superior option and strengthens the argument's persuasiveness.
2.
Identify one place where the author could have used more convincing language. Then, offer your suggestion. The author could have addressed potential objections or restrictions regarding music therapy in one place by using stronger language. The essay acknowledges in passing that music therapy is not a perfect substitute for all conventional medications, but it could use a more thorough explanation of any potential drawbacks or objections. The author could, for example, acknowledge that music therapy may not be universally effective for all people or that its effects may vary depending on the type and severity of mental health issues in order to anticipate and address any potential skepticism. The author would make the case more compelling overall and show a more sophisticated hold of the complexities related to music therapy by clearly recognizing and addressing any possible
ESL 15
Sample PS Analysis counterarguments.
G. Final Reflections
Finally, discuss two major lessons you have learned from reading and analyzing the Sample Paper. Be specific. A key takeaway from dissecting the Sample Paper is how crucial it is to make an argument that is coherently organized. In the introduction, the author does a good job of introducing the subject, supplying pertinent data to demonstrate the issue's importance, and outlining the goal and format of the research paper. A cogent and persuasive argument is enhanced by the logical flow of ideas, particularly when outlining the benefits of music therapy.
The value of responding to potential objections or restrictions in persuasive writing is yet another important lesson. Despite the fact that the paper presents a compelling case for music therapy, it might be stronger if it made clear any potential objections and offered meaningful rebuttals. In order to create a
more thorough and compelling argument, this lesson emphasizes the value of considering opposing points of view and exhibiting a nuanced understanding of the subject.