ToshIba, EY
(LO 1, 2, 3)
In 2015, the business press reported that Japan’s Toshiba Corp. over stated its operating profit by 151.8 billion yen ($1.22 billion) over several years through accounting irregularities involving top management. This overstatement represents approximately one-third of Toshiba’s pre-tax profits during the misstatement period. Toshiba had a corporate culture in which one could not go against the wishes of superiors. An investigation report noted that when top management presented ‘challenges’, division presidents, line managers and employees below them continually carried our inappropriate accounting practices to meet targets in line with the wishes of their superiors. Improper accounting included overstatements and booking profits early or pushing back the recording of losses or charges, and such steps often led to even higher targets being set for divisions in the following period.
The report said much of the improper accounting, stretching back to fiscal year 2008, was intentional and would have been difficult for auditors to detect. The audit firm during this misstatement period was EY (Ernst & Young ShinNihon) who incurred significant reputational damage after they were accused of failing to detect the misstatement and fined $17.4 million by Japanese regulators.
The investigation into Toshiba’s accounting practices was initially limited to its home country. However, in 2016 the U.S. Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission began looking into the case since part of the alleged fraud involved a Toshiba unit based in the US (Westinghouse Electric Company).
a. Based on this limited information, does this case represent a business failure, an audit failure, or both?
b. Should auditors be held liable if their client’s business fails or if the financial statements contain a fraud that the auditors did not detect?
c. Under what law would the SEC be likely to pursue this case?
Trending nowThis is a popular solution!
Chapter 4 Solutions
Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course List)
- Gordon Brown Co’s Profit before tax was Rs7 million and a statement of financial position total of Rs23 million.Gordon Brown owns a number of its retail premises, which it revalues annually. This year several of its shops rose sharply in value due to inflated property prices in their locality. Gordon Brown does not revalue its factory premises, which are held in the statement of financial position at Rs 2.7 million. Reproduce a standard audit report to give your views on this situation. *Report to be prepared as per ACCA format.arrow_forwardA company failed to record unrealized gains of $38 million on its debt investments classified as trading securities. Its tax rate is 25%. As a result of this error, total shareholders' equity would be:arrow_forwardA company failed to record unrealized gains of $28 million on its available for sale debt security investments. Its tax rate is 25%. As a result of this error, comprehensive income would be:arrow_forward
- In 2017, Flint Corporation discontinued its retail store operations to focus on its online opportunities. The elimination of these retail operations is properly considered a discontinued operation. During the current year, its store operations lost $ 670,000 (net of tax) while its online operations reported a profit of $ 3,320,000 (net of tax). Flint sold the store operations at the end of the year at a loss of $ 1,340,000 (net of tax). Prepare an income statement for 2017 beginning with line item "Income from continuing operations." FLINT CORPORATION Partial Income Statement $ %24 %24 > > >arrow_forwardSyer Company reports net operating income (loss) for financial reporting and tax purposes in each year as follows: 2016 $ 300 2017 $ 100 Syer's 2020 NOL is driven by an unfortunate obsolescence of its primary product. Given great uncertainty in Syer's future profitability, Syer's management does not believe it is more likely than not that it will be able to realize deferred tax assets in future years. Syer's federal tax rate decreased from 35% to 21% starting in 2018. Required: 1. Assume that Syer does not account for its NOL under the CARES Act. Instead, Syer accounts for its NOL using the general requirement that NOLs be carried forward. Prepare the appropriate journal entry to record Syer's 2020 income taxes, and indicate Syer's 2020 net income(loss). Req 1A A 2018 $0 2. Now assume that Syer does account for its NOL under the CARES Act. Prepare the appropriate journal entry to record Syer's 2020 income taxes, and indicate Syer's 2020 net income(loss). No Complete this question by…arrow_forwardIn 2017, Bramble Corporation discontinued its retail store operations to focus on its online opportunities. The elimination of these retail operations is properly considered a discontinued operation. During the current year, its store operations lost $ 750,000 (net of tax) while its online operations reported a profit of $ 3,210,000 (net of tax). Bramble sold the store operations at the end of the year at a loss of $ 1,360,000 (net of tax). Prepare an income statement for 2017 beginning with line item "Income from continuing operations." BRAMBLE CORPORATION Partial Income Statement %24 %24 > > >arrow_forward
- The following items (in millions) appear on the 2020 income statement for Tyson Foods, Inc. Sales Cost of Sales Gross Profit* Selling, General and Administrative Expense Other (Income) Expense Interest income Interest expense Other, net Total Other (Income) Expense Year ended Oct. 03, 2020 $43,185 37,801 5,384 2,270 (10) 485 (131) 344arrow_forwardIn 2017, Monty Corporation discontinued its retail store operations to focus on its online opportunities. The elimination of these retail operations is properly considered a discontinued operation. During the current year, its store operations lost $750,000 (net of tax) while its online operations reported a profit of $3,430,000 (net of tax). Monty sold the store operations at the end of the year at a loss of $1,340,000 (net of tax). Prepare an income statement for 2017 beginning with line item “Income from continuing operations.”arrow_forwardAfter many years of success, Kaputnik Co. recorded net operating losses for the years year 13 through year 16, totaling $250 million, resulting in the recording of large deferred tax assets based on the assumption of a rapid return to profitability. However, attempts by management to revamp its outmoded business model have so far failed. A radical final attempt to save the company will be implemented in year 18. It will entail selling off the vast majority of Kaputnik’s asset groups while maintaining a small but promising segment. The projected outlook for the near term is a modest net profit of $5 million over the next three years, beyond which it is impossible to determine if Kaputnik Co. will even still be in existence. The enacted tax rate has been 35% for the last several years and is expected to be 21% in year 17 and future years. No addition to the deferred tax asset balance will be recorded for year 17, during which Kaputnik recorded a $70 million net operating loss, nor has…arrow_forward
- After many years of success, Kaputnik Co. recorded net operating losses for the years year 13 through year 16, totaling $250 million, resulting in the recording of large deferred tax assets based on the assumption of a rapid return to profitability. However, attempts by management to revamp its outmoded business model have so far failed. A radical final attempt to save the company will be implemented in year 18. It will entail selling off the vast majority of Kaputnik's asset groups while maintaining a small but promising segment. The projected outlook for the near term is a modest net profit of $5 million over the next three years, beyond which it is impossible to determine if Kaputnik Co. will even still be in existence. The enacted tax rate has been 35% for the last several years and is expected to be 21% in year 17 and future years. No addition to the deferred tax asset balance will be recorded for year 17, during which Kaputnik recorded a $70 million net operating loss, nor has…arrow_forwardIn 2017, Pronghorn Corporation discontinued its retail store operations to focus on its online opportunities. The elimination of these retail operations is properly considered a discontinued operation. During the current year, its store operations lost $630,000 (net of tax) while its online operations reported a profit of $3,530,000 (net of tax). Pronghorn sold the store operations at the end of the year at a loss of $1,380,000 (net of tax). Prepare an income statement for 2017 beginning with line item “Income from continuing operations.” PRONGHORN CORPORATIONPartial Income Statementchoose the accounting period December 31, 2017For the Year Ended December 31, 2017For the Quarter Ended December 31, 2017 select an income statement item Discontinued OperationsEarnings Per ShareIncome From Continuing OperationsLoss From Disposal of Store Operations Net of TaxLoss…arrow_forwardIn 2017, Blue Spruce Corporation discontinued its retail store operations to focus on its online opportunities. The elimination of these retail operations is properly considered a discontinued operation. During the current year, its store operations lost $ 600,000 (net of tax) while its online operations reported a profit of $ 3,080,000 (net of tax). Blue Spruce sold the store operations at the end of the year at a loss of $ 1,120,000 (net of tax). Prepare an income statement for 2017 beginning with line item “Income from continuing operations." BLUE SPRUCE CORPORATION Partial Income Statement $ %24 %24arrow_forward
- Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course L...AccountingISBN:9781337619455Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. RittenbergPublisher:Cengage Learning
- Financial Reporting, Financial Statement Analysis...FinanceISBN:9781285190907Author:James M. Wahlen, Stephen P. Baginski, Mark BradshawPublisher:Cengage Learning