Concept explainers
Do you think the skeletons of Liang Bua Cave should be called a new species? Does it matter?
To review:
The consideration one would make while placing the skeleton from the Liang Bua cave in a different species and the reason for the necessity of the distinction.
Introduction:
Skeletons of fourteen prehistoric hominids were discovered in a cave called Liang Bua in 2004, named LB 1 to 14. These skeletons resemble the genus Australopithecus but also has similarities to the Homo species. They were classified as new species and named Homo floresiensis. However, some scientists argue that these specimens do not represent new species and are related to Homo sapiens.
Explanation of Solution
The prominent argument against accepting LB1 as another species was that the brain size was smaller than the modern humans. In case, they were different species evolved from H. erectus, their brain size should not have been affected. However, there are other factors to be considered. The factors that help in defining LB1 as different species are as follows:
1. Facial characteristics like heavy brow ridges, sloping forehead, and small chin are distinctive. The shape of the LB1 wrist resembled H. habilis (homo), which was necessary for absorbing the impact of shock and provide stability while using heavy tools. H. habilis is extinct for 1.6 million years.
2. The toes are short and in line like humans. The foot lacks arch is longer in proportion to the human foot. So their gait was high-stepping and running was poor. So, it is estimated that the LB1 evolved from H. erectus and diverged from the line of evolution that gave rise to modern humans.
3. LB1 skeletons were found in a cave with other skeletons of same characteristics, some tools, and skeleton of Stegodon, a small relative of modern elephants. This means the LBs could use tools, hunt and had coordination abilities that facilitate a hunt and interaction within the group. Their brain size may be small, but they could accomplish such tasks.
When all this information is taken into account, it can be safely estimated that LB1 represents a different species. Differentiating LB1 as a different species is very important. Some of the arguments to support the necessity of this distinction are as follows:
1. Naming LB1 as a different species showed that just the brain size is not an indicator of the difference in species. The coordination of different LB individual has overcome challenges from reduced brain size.
2. Naming LB1 as a different species paved a way for taking entire characteristics of the specimen before differentiating it into one species or another.
3. Evidence suggests the species had a larger brain before migrating to the island. So it will be worth finding whether the brain size was reduced as an evolutionary measure. The differentiation established an offshoot of H. erectus survived for a long period and may have interacted with the H. sapiens.
Therefore, based on all the information available on the LB1 skeleton, they do represent a different species. This distinction is necessary as it proved brain size is not the only indicator in the differentiating between different species.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 22 Solutions
Human Biology: Concepts and Current Issues (8th Edition)
- Are horses and donkeys members of the same species? Why?arrow_forwardWhich of the following is true about the phylogeny of birds and reptiles. Question 35 options: a) Birds are more closely related to amphibians then they are to reptiles. b) Birds are a type of reptile, but are not related to dinosaurs. c) Birds and reptiles are the least related vertebrates. d) Birds are a type of reptile and are descended from a group of dinosaurs.arrow_forward(1) What is the most common way for a dead organism to avoid decomposition? (2) Why do researchers look for fossils in places that are now dry and barren instead of other places like forests or grasslands? (3) What kind of dating from the lecture or textbook would be the best method for finding the number of years ago when a volcanic rock was formed? (4) Why is the pelvis of a biped shorter and wider than the pelvis of a quadruped? (5) Does the overall shape of Lucy’s pelvis resemble the human pelvis or the chimpanzee pelvis more? Do not think of the size, but compare the outlines of each bone. This is Lucy's skelton below.arrow_forward
- Did dinosaurs and humans ever exist at the same time?arrow_forwardHow old was the world thought to be when Darwin began his voyage? How old is it thought to be now?arrow_forwardThe fossils in line 4 are blank the ones in line 1 of the diagram. A) much older B) much younger than C) slightly older than D) slightly younger thanarrow_forward
- Who gave the scientific name homo sapiens to man?arrow_forwardMegan, a paleontologist, is working with a new fossil collection of trilobites from the paleozoic era. Part of her research is figuring out how many species of trilobites are in this new collection. What species concept will Megan not be able to use while doing her work? Biological species concept O Phylogenetic species concept O Megan will be able to use all of them Morphological species concept O Megan will not be able to use any of themarrow_forwardWhat is the difference between primitive and advanced species and why is it now considered wrong to call a species primitive?arrow_forward
- How does genetic analyses of fossils help us understand human evolution better than just examining skulls?arrow_forwardWhich of the following is responsible for the early predominant image of Neanderthals as brutish cavemen? a). They had small brain cases with stocky bodies and were always recovered from cave sites b). The fossil evidence reveals that they had little cognitive capacity and had a hunched over posture c). An early fossil find of an Individual suffering from arthritis was assembled and taken as the type specimen foer all Neanderthals, mistakenly giving the idea that Neanderthals were an ape-like, hunched-over species.d). None of the above are truearrow_forward1). There is quite a bit of variation in fossils attributed to the species Homo habilis. Some of the fossils have larger brains (750cc) and flat, wide faces. If separated out from Homo habilis, these fossils would be placed in the genus and species called ................ 2) In order to get Johnny's Child to be placed in the genus Homo, the Leakeys downgraded the Cerebral Rubicon from 700cc to ..............ccarrow_forward
- Human Anatomy & Physiology (11th Edition)BiologyISBN:9780134580999Author:Elaine N. Marieb, Katja N. HoehnPublisher:PEARSONBiology 2eBiologyISBN:9781947172517Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann ClarkPublisher:OpenStaxAnatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781259398629Author:McKinley, Michael P., O'loughlin, Valerie Dean, Bidle, Theresa StouterPublisher:Mcgraw Hill Education,
- Molecular Biology of the Cell (Sixth Edition)BiologyISBN:9780815344322Author:Bruce Alberts, Alexander D. Johnson, Julian Lewis, David Morgan, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, Peter WalterPublisher:W. W. Norton & CompanyLaboratory Manual For Human Anatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781260159363Author:Martin, Terry R., Prentice-craver, CynthiaPublisher:McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.Inquiry Into Life (16th Edition)BiologyISBN:9781260231700Author:Sylvia S. Mader, Michael WindelspechtPublisher:McGraw Hill Education