What is the dilemma? Do you agree with the Judge's decision? Would you call the Judge's ruling a decision based on duty-based (Kantian) Ethics or outcome-based (Utilitarian) Ethics, and why? What is your own moral reasoning for what you think should have been done?

Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
5th Edition
ISBN:9780134477961
Author:Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Publisher:Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Chapter1: The Science Of Psychology
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1TY
icon
Related questions
Question
Texas has a law that prohibits the removal of mechanical life-support such as a ventilator from a pregnant patient.
In November 2013, when Marlise Munoz was 14 weeks pregnant she was found unconscious in her Texas home. With her husband and family in deep
distress, they rushed her to a hospital where she was placed on a machine to keep her alive. Soon thereafter, doctors at the hospital pronounced her
brain dead. Her husband and family eventually asked that she be removed from life support, but Texas law prohibits removing a pregnant woman from
life support if it threatens the life of the fetus. A Texas Judge has now ordered that the 22-week pregnant woman removed from life support, as
requested by the family. For background, click here: LINK.
There are two types of death: 1) when the heart stops beating and 2) when the entire brain ceases to function.
What is the dilemma? Do you agree with the Judge's decision? Would you call the Judge's ruling a decision based on duty-based
(Kantian) Ethics or outcome-based (Utilitarian) Ethics, and why? What is your own moral reasoning for what you think should have
been done?
Transcribed Image Text:Texas has a law that prohibits the removal of mechanical life-support such as a ventilator from a pregnant patient. In November 2013, when Marlise Munoz was 14 weeks pregnant she was found unconscious in her Texas home. With her husband and family in deep distress, they rushed her to a hospital where she was placed on a machine to keep her alive. Soon thereafter, doctors at the hospital pronounced her brain dead. Her husband and family eventually asked that she be removed from life support, but Texas law prohibits removing a pregnant woman from life support if it threatens the life of the fetus. A Texas Judge has now ordered that the 22-week pregnant woman removed from life support, as requested by the family. For background, click here: LINK. There are two types of death: 1) when the heart stops beating and 2) when the entire brain ceases to function. What is the dilemma? Do you agree with the Judge's decision? Would you call the Judge's ruling a decision based on duty-based (Kantian) Ethics or outcome-based (Utilitarian) Ethics, and why? What is your own moral reasoning for what you think should have been done?
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Recommended textbooks for you
Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
Psychology
ISBN:
9780134477961
Author:
Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Publisher:
PEARSON
Cognitive Psychology
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
ISBN:
9781337408271
Author:
Goldstein, E. Bruce.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning,
Introduction to Psychology: Gateways to Mind and …
Introduction to Psychology: Gateways to Mind and …
Psychology
ISBN:
9781337565691
Author:
Dennis Coon, John O. Mitterer, Tanya S. Martini
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Psychology in Your Life (Second Edition)
Psychology in Your Life (Second Edition)
Psychology
ISBN:
9780393265156
Author:
Sarah Grison, Michael Gazzaniga
Publisher:
W. W. Norton & Company
Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research a…
Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research a…
Psychology
ISBN:
9781285763880
Author:
E. Bruce Goldstein
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Theories of Personality (MindTap Course List)
Theories of Personality (MindTap Course List)
Psychology
ISBN:
9781305652958
Author:
Duane P. Schultz, Sydney Ellen Schultz
Publisher:
Cengage Learning