**Two Mutually Exclusive Design Alternatives**Two mutually exclusive design alternatives are being considered. The estimated cash flows for each alternative are given below. The Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is 10% per year. The decision-maker can select one of these alternatives or decide to select none of them. Make a recommendation based on the following methods.| | **Design Y** | **Design Z** ||-----------------------|--------------|---------------|| **Investment cost** | $140,000 | $275,000 || **Annual revenue** | $43,705 | $86,582 || **Annual cost** | $7,881 | $27,683 || **Useful life** | 15 years | 15 years || **Salvage value** | $14,700 | $33,000 || **Net PW** | $135,999 | $180,890 |### Recommendations:a. **Based on PW method**: Design ___ is more economical.b. **Modified B/C Ratio**: - The modified B/C ratio of Design Y is ___ (Round to two decimal places). - The modified B/C ratio of Design Z is ___ (Round to two decimal places).c. **Incremental B/C Ratio**: - The incremental B/C ratio is ___ (Round to two decimal places). - Therefore, based on the B/C ratio method, Design ___ is more economical.d. **Discounted Payback Period**: - The discounted payback period of Design Y is ___ years (Round to one decimal place). - The discounted payback period of Design Z is ___ years (Round to one decimal place). - Therefore, based on the payback period method, Design ___ would be preferred.### Additional Insight:e. **Why might the recommendations based on the payback period method differ from the other two methods?**- **A.** Because the payback period method ignores the cash flows after the payback period.- **B.** Because the payback period gives more weight to the cash flows after the payback period.

Disclaimer- “Since you have asked multiple questions, we will solve the first three questions for…

Two mutually exclusive design alternatives are being considered. The estimated cash flows for each alternative are given below. The MARR is 10% per year. The decision-maker can select one of these alternatives or decide to select none of them. Make a recommendation based on the following methods. Design Y Investment cost Annual revenue Annual cost Useful life Salvage value Net PW is more economical. a. Based on PW method, Design b. The modified B/C ratio of Design Y is The modified B/C ration of Design Z is $140,000 $43,705 $7,881 15 years $14,700 $135,999 Design Z $275,000 $86,582 $27,683 15 years $33,000 $180,890 (Round to two decimal places) (Round to two decimal places) c. The incremental B/C ratio is (Round to two decimal places) Therefore, based on the B/C ratio method, Design is more economical

Two mutually exclusive design alternatives are being considered. The estimated cash flows for each alternative are given below. The MARR is 10% per year. The decision-maker can select one of these alternatives or decide to select none of them. Make a recommendation based on the following methods. Design Y Investment cost Annual revenue Annual cost Useful life Salvage value Net PW is more economical. a. Based on PW method, Design b. The modified B/C ratio of Design Y is The modified B/C ration of Design Z is $140,000 $43,705 $7,881 15 years $14,700 $135,999 Design Z $275,000 $86,582 $27,683 15 years $33,000 $180,890 (Round to two decimal places) (Round to two decimal places) c. The incremental B/C ratio is (Round to two decimal places) Therefore, based on the B/C ratio method, Design is more economical

ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS

14th Edition

ISBN:9780190931919

Author:NEWNAN

Publisher:NEWNAN

Chapter1: Making Economics Decisions

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 1QTC

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

The MARR is 7% per year, capital investment is $118,864, annual expense is $30,127, annual revenue is $89,754, salvage value is $18,093, The study period is 10 years. What is the AW?
Q4 (i) State the salient features of the Pakistan Environmental Protection Act (PEPA) 1997.
You have been requested to compare four mutually exclusive alternatives using the B/C method and the results are shown. Which alternative, if any, do you recommend? Alternative X Z Q Equivalent Total Cost, $ Million 20 30 50 90 Direct B/C Ratio 0.75 1.07 1.20 1.11 AB/C Ratio When Compared with Alternative 1.70 1.50 1.21 1.40 1.13 Z 1.00
Two mutually exclusive design alternatives are being considered. The estimated cash flows for each alternative are given below. The MARR is 12% per year. The decision-maker can select one of these alternatives or decide to select none of them. Make a recommendation based on the following methods. Design Y a. Based on PW method, Design is more economical. b. The modified B/C ratio of Design Y is The modified B/C ration of Design Z is c. The incremental B/C ratio is (Round to two decimal places) Therefore, based on the B/C ratio method, Design Investment cost Annual revenue Annual cost Useful life Salvage value (Round to two decimal places) (Round to two decimal places) d. The discounted payback period of Design Y is The discounted payback period of Design Z is Net PW is is more economical years (Round to one decimal place) years (Round to one decimal place) $140,000 $51,725 $9,672 15 years $14,700 $149,103 Design Z $275,000 $84,946 $18,059 15 years $33,000 $186,587 Therefore, based on…
Define the term Net Present Worth in the present worth analysis?
MARR is 10% per year. Compare the two plans using the Capitalized Cost Method. The first plan calls for an initial investment of $500,000, with expenses of $20,000 per year for the first 20 years and $30,000 per year thereafter. It also requires an expenditure of $200,000 20 years after the initial investment, and this will repeat every 20 years thereafter. The second plan has an initial investment of $700,000 followed by a single (one time) investment of $300,000 30 years later. It will incur annual expenses of $10,000 forever. Based on the Capitalized Cost measure.Which plan would you recommend?
select projects options are 3, 2, 1&3, 2&3, or 1&2
The cost of the extending a certain road at Yellowstone National Park is $1.7 million. Resurfacing and other maintenance are expected to cost $350,000 every 3 years with an interest rate of 6% per year. a) What is the Annual Worth based capitalized cost of the road? b) How will the answer (a) change if its Salvage is expected to be $3 million at the end of its useful Life?
Examine in details Four (04) different sourcing approaches that could be used by procurement experts
A proposal to reduce traffic congestion on Jounieh Highway has a B/C ratio of 1.4. The annual worth of benefits minus disbenefits is $560,000. What is the first cost of the project if the interest rate is 5% per year and the project is expected to be perpetual?* 4,000,000 4,588,208 8,000,000 6,666,667
The following estimates (in $1000 units) have been developed for a new cybersecurity system at Chicago's O'Hare Airport. Calculate the conventional B/C ratio at a discount rate of 10% per year. First cost, $ AW of benefits, $ per year FW (in year 20) of disbenefits, $ M&O costs, $ per year Expected life, years O 1.21 <1.15 1.52 O 1.91 DOCUMENT.pdf 13,000 3,800 6,750 400 20
Five mutually exclusive alternatives are being considered for providing a sewage- treatment facility. The annual equivalent costs and estimated benefits of the alternatives are as follows: Alternative E Annual Equivalent (in thousands) Cost $1,050 Benefits $1,110 900 $1,810 1,230 $1,390 1,350 $1,500 990 $1,140 Which plan, if any, should be adopted if the Sewage Authority wishes to invest if, and only if, the B-C ratio is at least 1.0.?