Suppose that you were interested in investigating the effect of a drug that is to be used in the treatment of patients who have glaucoma in both eyes. A comparison between the mean reduction in eye pressure for this drug and for a standard treatment is desired. Both treatments are applied directly to the eye. (a) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would result in paired samples. O Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated). Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. (b) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would not result in paired samples. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. OGather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated). Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. (c) Would an experiment without paired samples be as informative as a paired experiment? Comment. The unpaired experiment would be just as informative as a paired experiment because a set of eyes belonging to one person are likely to vary as much as two eyes belonging to different people. The unpaired experiment would be more informative since a set of eyes are likely to be very similar, while the individual patients may have very different eyes. The unpaired experiment would be less informative since the the individual patients may have very different eyes, while a set of eyes are likely to be very similar.

MATLAB: An Introduction with Applications
6th Edition
ISBN:9781119256830
Author:Amos Gilat
Publisher:Amos Gilat
Chapter1: Starting With Matlab
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1P
icon
Related questions
Question

11.2.1

Suppose that you were interested in investigating the effect of a drug that is to be used in the treatment of patients who have glaucoma in both eyes. A comparison between the mean
reduction in eye pressure for this drug and for a standard treatment is desired. Both treatments are applied directly to the eye.
(a) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would result in paired samples.
Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each
experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all
the eyes,
and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received
the standard treatment.
Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each
experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated).
Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that
have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment.
(b) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would not result in paired samples.
Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each
experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all
the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received
the standard treatment.
Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each
experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated).
Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that
have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment.
(c) Would an experiment without paired samples be as informative as a paired experiment? Comment.
The unpaired experiment would be just as informative as a paired experiment because a set of eyes belonging to one person are likely to vary as much as two eyes belonging
to different people.
The unpaired experiment would be more informative since a set of eyes are likely to be very similar, while the individual patients may have very different eyes.
The unpaired experiment would be less informative since the the individual patients may have very different eyes, while a set of eyes are likely to be very similar.
Transcribed Image Text:Suppose that you were interested in investigating the effect of a drug that is to be used in the treatment of patients who have glaucoma in both eyes. A comparison between the mean reduction in eye pressure for this drug and for a standard treatment is desired. Both treatments are applied directly to the eye. (a) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would result in paired samples. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated). Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. (b) Describe a reasonable method of collecting data that would not result in paired samples. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to each participant. Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. Gather a number of volunteers who suffer from glaucoma in both eyes. Measure the pressure in each eye of each participant before the treatments begin. For each experimental subject, randomly assign the treatments to the eyes (so that one eye receives the standard treatment and the other receives the drug that is being evaluated). Once the patients have applied the treatments for a fixed time, measure again the pressures in all the eyes, and compare the mean reduction in pressure for the eyes that have received the new treatment with the mean reduction in pressure for those that have received the standard treatment. (c) Would an experiment without paired samples be as informative as a paired experiment? Comment. The unpaired experiment would be just as informative as a paired experiment because a set of eyes belonging to one person are likely to vary as much as two eyes belonging to different people. The unpaired experiment would be more informative since a set of eyes are likely to be very similar, while the individual patients may have very different eyes. The unpaired experiment would be less informative since the the individual patients may have very different eyes, while a set of eyes are likely to be very similar.
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 3 steps

Blurred answer
Recommended textbooks for you
MATLAB: An Introduction with Applications
MATLAB: An Introduction with Applications
Statistics
ISBN:
9781119256830
Author:
Amos Gilat
Publisher:
John Wiley & Sons Inc
Probability and Statistics for Engineering and th…
Probability and Statistics for Engineering and th…
Statistics
ISBN:
9781305251809
Author:
Jay L. Devore
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Statistics for The Behavioral Sciences (MindTap C…
Statistics for The Behavioral Sciences (MindTap C…
Statistics
ISBN:
9781305504912
Author:
Frederick J Gravetter, Larry B. Wallnau
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Elementary Statistics: Picturing the World (7th E…
Elementary Statistics: Picturing the World (7th E…
Statistics
ISBN:
9780134683416
Author:
Ron Larson, Betsy Farber
Publisher:
PEARSON
The Basic Practice of Statistics
The Basic Practice of Statistics
Statistics
ISBN:
9781319042578
Author:
David S. Moore, William I. Notz, Michael A. Fligner
Publisher:
W. H. Freeman
Introduction to the Practice of Statistics
Introduction to the Practice of Statistics
Statistics
ISBN:
9781319013387
Author:
David S. Moore, George P. McCabe, Bruce A. Craig
Publisher:
W. H. Freeman