Homework Help is Here – Start Your Trial Now!
Social Science
History
From a Radicals point of view, please make debate points about the NEW DEAL. Attached below is a PDF to help you.    Please make issues, and then points for it.

From a Radicals point of view, please make debate points about the NEW DEAL. Attached below is a PDF to help you.    Please make issues, and then points for it.

icon
Related questions
Question

From a Radicals point of view, please make debate points about the NEW DEAL. Attached below is a PDF to help you. 

 

Please make issues, and then points for it. 

THE RADICAL VIEW OF THE NEW DEAL FLAMM U.S. HISTORY The following is a description of the attitude of radicals toward President Roosevelt and the New Deal. As you shall see, it is an interesting mix of the liberal and conservative positions. We radicals agree with the conservatives when they claim that Roosevelt and his New Deal have failed to lift the U.S. out of the Great Depression. Millions are still jobless, millions are still homeless, and millions are still hungry. However, we disagree with the conservatives when they blame the current situation on the socialist aspects of the New Deal. On the contrary, the real problem lies in the fact that the New Deal has not gone far enough. Instead of trying to introduce socialism through permanent and structural changes (like public control of the banking system) it has sought to prop up capitalism through temporary and superficial reforms (like the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation). We radicals also agree with the liberals when they say that the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA), the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), and the Works Progress Administration (WPA) are steps in the right direction. However, we disagree with the liberals when they claim that the New Deal has the nation on the road to recovery. On the contrary, these programs are like band-aids - they cover up the wound without treating it. Thus the AAA leads to the eviction of poor black sharecroppers (since it pays farmers not to grow certain crops or plow additional fields), while the WPA creates temporary jobs and fosters dependency among those it employs. Above all, we feel that FDR has missed a golden opportunity. With his personal popularity and the desperate shape of the country, he could have shifted the U.S. away from capitalism (where the gap between the rich and poor grows ever larger) and toward socialism (where the gap between rich and poor is controlled by the government). Instead, he has enacted a limited program of reform in order to save capitalism - the very economic system that brought us the Great Depression in the first place. In the long-run, that approach will only lead to more economic chaos and more suffering among the people. Now is the time to recognize that capitalism is a failure, and that the New Deal is nothing more than a shallow attempt to disguise that fact.
Transcribed Image Text:THE RADICAL VIEW OF THE NEW DEAL FLAMM U.S. HISTORY The following is a description of the attitude of radicals toward President Roosevelt and the New Deal. As you shall see, it is an interesting mix of the liberal and conservative positions. We radicals agree with the conservatives when they claim that Roosevelt and his New Deal have failed to lift the U.S. out of the Great Depression. Millions are still jobless, millions are still homeless, and millions are still hungry. However, we disagree with the conservatives when they blame the current situation on the socialist aspects of the New Deal. On the contrary, the real problem lies in the fact that the New Deal has not gone far enough. Instead of trying to introduce socialism through permanent and structural changes (like public control of the banking system) it has sought to prop up capitalism through temporary and superficial reforms (like the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation). We radicals also agree with the liberals when they say that the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA), the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC), and the Works Progress Administration (WPA) are steps in the right direction. However, we disagree with the liberals when they claim that the New Deal has the nation on the road to recovery. On the contrary, these programs are like band-aids - they cover up the wound without treating it. Thus the AAA leads to the eviction of poor black sharecroppers (since it pays farmers not to grow certain crops or plow additional fields), while the WPA creates temporary jobs and fosters dependency among those it employs. Above all, we feel that FDR has missed a golden opportunity. With his personal popularity and the desperate shape of the country, he could have shifted the U.S. away from capitalism (where the gap between the rich and poor grows ever larger) and toward socialism (where the gap between rich and poor is controlled by the government). Instead, he has enacted a limited program of reform in order to save capitalism - the very economic system that brought us the Great Depression in the first place. In the long-run, that approach will only lead to more economic chaos and more suffering among the people. Now is the time to recognize that capitalism is a failure, and that the New Deal is nothing more than a shallow attempt to disguise that fact.
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

SEE SOLUTIONCheck out a sample Q&A here
Blurred answer