A new drug is tested in two peer-reviewed studies, A and B. Both studies provide evidence that the new drug is an improvement (The null hypothesis, that the new drug does not help, is rejected). But the researchers who conducted study A report a p-value of 8.2%, the team from study B obtained a p-value of only 2.3%. Which study provides the stronger evidence in favor of the new drug? Choose the most appropriate answer. a. Study B, because follow-up studies usually provide stronger evidence. b. Study A, because their p-value is bigger. c. Study A, because it was done by real researchers, and B only by a 'team'. d. Study B, because their p-value is smaller. e. The evidence from both studies is too weak.

A new drug is tested in two peer-reviewed studies, A and B. Both studies provide evidence that the new drug is an improvement (The null hypothesis, that the new drug does not help, is rejected). But the researchers who conducted study A report a p-value of 8.2%, the team from study B obtained a p-value of only 2.3%. Which study provides the stronger evidence in favor of the new drug? Choose the most appropriate answer. a. Study B, because follow-up studies usually provide stronger evidence. b. Study A, because their p-value is bigger. c. Study A, because it was done by real researchers, and B only by a 'team'. d. Study B, because their p-value is smaller. e. The evidence from both studies is too weak.

A First Course in Probability (10th Edition)

10th Edition

ISBN:9780134753119

Author:Sheldon Ross

Publisher:Sheldon Ross

Chapter1: Combinatorial Analysis

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 1.1P: a. How many different 7-place license plates are possible if the first 2 places are for letters and...

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

Coach Elyson claims that 90% of her volleyball serves are good serves. The captain of the team thinks Coach Elyson has a lower rate of good serves. To test this, 50 of the coach’s serves are randomly selected and 41 of them are good. To determine if these data provide convincing evidence that the proportion of Coach Elyson’s serves that are good is less than 90%, 100 trials of a simulation are conducted. The team captain’s hypotheses are: H0: p = 90% and Ha: p < 90%, where p = the true proportion of Coach Elyson’s serves that are good. Based on the results of the simulation, what is an estimate of the P-value of the test? A) 0% B) 2% C) 4% D) 98%
According to a Pew Research Center study, in May 2011, 33% of all American adults had a smart phone (one which the user can use to read email and surf the Internet). A communications professor at a university believes this percentage is lower among community college students. She selects 352 community college students at random and finds that 122 of them have a smart phone. In testing the hypotheses: Ho: p= 0.33 versus Ha: p < 0.33 Do the hypothesis test. Use a level of significance of a = 0.05; Use the unrounded values in Excel to find the answers for #3 and #4. 4. Find the p-value.-- 5. The communication professor should the null hypothesis.
Please help me better understand how to properly solve. A randomized controlled experiment in Charlotte, North Carolina, studied three police responses to spousal abuse: advise and possibly separate the couple, issue a citation to the offender, and arrest the offender. The effectiveness of the three responses was determined by re-arrest rates. The photo shows the rates. Research wishes to test null hypothesis that that the proportions of subsequent arrests are the same regardless of the treatment assigned. Under the null hypothesis, determine the expected number of times no subsequent arrest would occur for the treatment “Advise/separate”?
When results are not statistically significant, why do you conclude that it is plausible that the two variables are independent rather than concluding that the variables are different independent?
According to a Pew Research Center study, in May 2011, 33% of all American adults had a smart phone (one which the user can use to read email and surf the Internet). A communications professor at a university believes this percentage is higher among community college students. She selects 320 community college students at random and finds that 135 of them have a smart phone. In testing the hypotheses: Ho: p = 0.33 versus Ha: p > 0.33 Do the hypothesis test. Use a level of significance of a = 0.05; Use the unrounded values in Excel to find the answers for #3 and #4. 1. This is an example of a hypothesis test. 2. Find the standard error. 3. Find the z value. 4. Find the p-value. 5. The communication professor should the null hypothesis.
A large clinical trial of the effect of diet on breast cancer assigned women at random to either a normal diet or a low-fat diet. To check that the random assignment did produce comparable groups, we can compare the two groups at the start of the study. Asked if there is a family history of breast cancer: 1276 of the 5964 women in the low-fat group and 1507 of the 7726 women in the control group said "Yes." If the random assignment worked well, there should not be a significant difference in the proportions with a family history of breast cancer. How significant is the observed difference? State: Is there evidence of a difference in the proportion of women with a family history of breast cancer between the treatment and control groups? Plan: Let pi be the proportion for the treatment group, and Pz the proportion for the control group. State the hypotheses for your test. Ha:Pi + P2 Solve: Give the value of the test statistic. Use the calculator. Select an answer ♥ Ho:pi = p2 What is the…
A recent study of 1000 high school juniors and seniors asked whether or not they felt smartphones are a valuable learning tool. Additional data were gathered on their smartphone plan (unlimited data, additional texting, or standard voice plan) and which class they were in (junior vs. senior). Which of the following is a correct pair of hypotheses the researchers could test? (A) Ho: The proportion of juniors and seniors who feel smartphones are a valuable learning tool is the same for students that have each type of plan. Ha: The proportion of juniors and seniors who feel smartphones are a valuable learning tool is not the same for students that have each type of plan (B) Ho: The proportion of students who feel smartphones are a valuable learning tool is the same for students that have each type of plan. Ha: The proportion of students who feel smartphones are a valuable learning tool is not the same for students that have each type of plan. (C) Ho: There is an association between class…
When three groups were compared using the one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA), the result turned out to be significant, that is, the null hypothesis was rejected. What will be the appropriate interpretation of this result?A. All three groups significantly differ in means.B. Exactly two of the three groups significantly differ.C. At least two of the three groups significantly differ in means.D. All three groups have the same effect on the dependent variable.
In a clinical trial of a drug intended to help people stop smoking, 125 subjects were treated with the drug for 12 weeks, and 14 subjects experienced abdominal pain. If someone claims that more than 8% of the drug's users experience abdominal pain, that claim is supported with a hypothesis test conducted with a 0.05 significance level. Using 0.17 as an alternative value of p, the power of the test is 0.95. Interpret this value of the power of the test. The power of 0.95 shows that there is a % chance of rejecting the hypothesis of p = when the true proportion is actually That is, if the proportion of users who experience abdominal pain is actually then there is a % chance of supporting the claim that the proportion of than 0.08. users who experience abdominal pain is (Type integers or decimals. Do not round.)
A manufacturer of laptop computers claims that only 1% of their computers are defective. In a sample of 600 computers, it was found that 3% were defective. If the proportion of defectives were really only 1%, there would be than 1 chance in 1000 of getting such a large proportion of defective laptops in the sample. Is there statistically significant evidence against the manufacturer's claim? Why or Why not?
A researcher is interested in the impact of joining a weight loss program in the past 12 months on the individual's weight loss. The analysis was restricted to people aged 16 and older who answered yes to the question “During the past 12 months, have you tried to lose weight?” About 5% of the sample had joined a weight loss program in the past year. (i) Why do we restrict our analysis to those who answered yes to this question?
Results on seat belt usage from the 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey were published in a USA Snapshot on January 13, 2005. The following table outlines the results from the high school students who were surveyed in the state of Nebraska. They were asked whether or not they rarely or never wear seat belts when riding in someone else's car. Using ? = .05, does this sample present sufficient evidence to reject the hypothesis that gender is independent of seat belt usage? Female Male Rarely or never use seat belt 206 323 Uses seat belt 1220 1157 (a) Find the test statistic. (Give your answer correct to two decimal places.)(ii) Find the p-value. (Give your answer bounds exactly.) ______< p < ________