9. There is a negative correlation between the sleep patterns of owls and humans: owls are more likely to be awake when humans are asleep, and owls are more likely to be asleep when humans are awake. Hence, owls waking up probably causes humans to fall asleep. Two Things Being Correlated (in the premises): How They’re Purportedly Correlated: Conclusion Argued For (in the conclusion): Any Plausible Alternate Explanations? (yes or no): If so, what? (spurious coincidence, common cause, reversed): Explain this Alternate Explanation: Overall Quality of Argument (good or bad):
9. There is a negative correlation between the sleep patterns of owls and humans: owls are more likely to be awake when humans are asleep, and owls are more likely to be asleep when humans are awake. Hence, owls waking up probably causes humans to fall asleep.
Two Things Being Correlated (in the premises):
How They’re Purportedly Correlated:
Conclusion Argued For (in the conclusion):
Any Plausible Alternate Explanations? (yes or no):
If so, what? (spurious coincidence, common cause, reversed):
Explain this Alternate Explanation:
Overall Quality of Argument (good or bad):
10. When I wear my lucky Phillies hat while watching a Phillies baseball game on TV, the Phillies almost always seem to win. So my hat truly is a lucky hat: wearing it causes the Phillies to play better.
Two Things Being Correlated (in the premises):
How They’re Purportedly Correlated:
Conclusion Argued For (in the conclusion):
Any Plausible Alternate Explanations? (yes or no):
If so, what? (spurious coincidence, common cause, reversed):
Explain this Alternate Explanation:
Overall Quality of Argument (good or bad):
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 3 steps
