6007258 (HLS), final

docx

School

Stanford University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

474

Subject

Information Systems

Date

Oct 30, 2023

Type

docx

Pages

Uploaded by LieutenantGoldfish2766

1 Collection Disciplines / INTS Student’s Name Institution Due Date

2 Introduction In this paper we'll talk about how combining several methods of information gathering may increase accuracy, trustworthiness, and the capacity to make sound decisions. We'll also look at situations when it isn't feasible or desirable to combine approaches, based on criteria including limited resources, ethical issues, and study aims. We may better appreciate the importance of a well-rounded and comprehensive approach to intelligence collection if we know the strengths and limits of each intelligence field and the benefit of all-source information. Response 1 Several subfields within the larger subject of intelligence gathering are known as INTS (Intelligence disciplines), each of which emphasizes a unique set of techniques and resources. Each field of study has pros and cons, which is why it's common practice to combine them. Some of the most common types of collections are: Human Intelligence (HUMINT): HUMINT refers to gathering data from people (agents, informants, etc.) rather than machines. Relationship-building and covert activities are common components. The Advantage is that human sources may explain unclear data and gather knowledge that is not easily accessible via other methods (Gentry, 2018); therefore, thus enabling data accessibility. However, the weakness is that human sources may be inaccurate or biased; thus, relying on them is dangerous. HUMINT activities can need a lot of time and energy. Second, the Signals Intelligence (SIGINT) involves gathering information through monitoring and analyzing electronic conversations and transmissions (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). Electronic communications like radio, telephone, and the internet will be monitored. The benefits include the ability to give real-time information, cover a wide range of communications and

3 electronic data, and show the intents and capabilities of enemies (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). However, the Weaknesses is the possible lack of complete context and the use of complex encryption techniques are weaknesses. Legal and ethical reasons may also constrain SIGINT activities. Also, the Imagery Intelligence (IMINT) is responsible for Collecting and analyzing visual images from satellites, aerial reconnaissance, or other surveillance platforms is known as "Imagery Intelligence" (IMINT) (Tanabe et al., 2023). Among its advantages is that it provides detailed and visual information about locations, activities, and facilities, helping to understand changes over time. However, the limitation is in acquiring high-resolution imagery may be costly, and data availability may be restricted due to inclement weather or cloudy locations. According to US Naval War College (2015), intelligence gleaned via the systematic collection and analysis of distinctive signatures released by different targets, such as radar signals or chemical, biological, or radioactive emissions, is known as Measurement and Signature Intelligence (MASINT). Benefits include the ability to reveal previously concealed or disguised items, precisely measure and evaluate target qualities, and give invaluable technical knowledge. Nevertheless, the limitations is that it can only be used on certain objects or contexts, calling for specialist equipment and knowledge. "Open Source Intelligence" (OSINT) refers to gathering and analyzing data from freely available resources such as newspapers, websites, social media, etc US Naval War College (2015). Benefits include being inexpensive and providing access to a wide variety of information, often in real-time. The weakness is that it might be difficult to verify the accuracy of the information, and important data isn't always readily accessible to the public. Geospatial Intelligence (GEOINT):

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

4 GEOINT, or Geospatial Intelligence, uses maps, satellite images, and other georeferenced data to decipher and depict intelligence (Tanabe et al., 2023). Benefits include facilitating mission planning and raising awareness by highlighting patterns, trends, and linkages in geographical data (Gentry, 2018). The shortcoming is that it depends on current and reliable geographic data, which may not be readily accessible in all areas. Cyber intelligence (abbreviated as "CYBINT") refers to the practice of gathering and analyzing data about online dangers such as hacks and flaws (Gentry, 2018). The benefits include a better understanding of potential cyber risks and how to protect against them. The weaknesses is the ever-changing nature of the cyber threat environment makes it difficult to effectively prepare for new attacks. It's crucial to understand that these various methods of gathering info may and do complement one another (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). When numerous methods are used to evaluate a person's intellect, the strengths of one might make up for the limitations of the others. For intelligence reports to be useful and actionable, analysts must carefully combine data from several sources and assess each source's credibility. Response 2 Why Using Multiple Collection Disciplines is Preferred When compared to depending on a single source of INT, various collecting disciplines or all-source intelligence is preferred. Strengthened Precision and Dependability which involves the ability to cross-reference and validate data is greatly enhanced when collected through various methods and sources. As a result, there is less of a chance of making decisions based on information from just one source,

5 which may be wrong or prejudiced. While each source has its caveats, analysts may reduce the likelihood of making mistakes and increase confidence in their analysis by integrating data from many sources (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). Also, comprehensive Picture is also a factor since the many fields of study represented in a collection might provide new light on an issue. For instance, signals intelligence (SIGINT) may disclose communication patterns, while human intelligence (HUMINT) can lighten people's objectives and motives (Tanabe et al., 2023). Analysts fill in the blanks in their grasp of the topic by mixing information from many sources. Moreover, The synergy of information occurs when data from several sources are combined to shed light on previously hidden correlations and patterns (US Naval War College, 2015). Valuable insights may be noticed with a comprehensive analysis of the data. Sources and methods vary widely; not all methods used in one collecting field may be directly transferred to another (Gentry, 2018). Intelligence experts better react to new situations and overcome the limits of specific sources if they use various gathering techniques. Additionally, enhanced Decision-Making is also a factor since intelligence helps decision-makers make better, more well-informed decisions. They can make informed choices because they have access to information from various sources, decreasing the likelihood that they will rely on either unreliable or biased material (US Naval War College, 2015). Regarding risk management, it is important to note that depending on a single source may be dangerous, particularly if it is unreliable or inaccurate. The potential for being deceived or influenced is less when one uses several sources to get information. Also, the urgency of information might vary depending on the source. Intelligence analysts can obtain a timelier and

6 more up-to-date picture of the situation using multiple collection disciplines (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). Credibility and Legitimacy is also a contributing factor since all-source intelligence gives additional weight to the output since it draws from a wider variety of trustworthy and genuine sources. This may strengthen the analysis's credibility and persuasiveness when presented to decision-makers. Therefore, the intelligence analysis improves quality, depth, and dependability when using several collecting disciplines and all-source intelligence (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). It lessens the dangers associated with depending on a single source or intelligence type and allows intelligence professionals to understand the topic more in-depth. Response 3 Data and knowledge may be gathered using various methods or "collection disciplines." Surveys, interviews, experiments, observations, etc., are all examples of qualitative and quantitative methods that fall under these umbrellas. Some examples of when it could not be useful to combine methods of data collecting are as follows: Using various collecting disciplines may not always be feasible owing to time or resource restrictions, especially when the scope of the study or project is small. The current resources may accomplish the goals using a single, suitable collecting discipline (Izzat Alsmadi, 2023). Also, depending on the topic, it may be difficult to gather all relevant data, or it may only exist in a single format. There may be no need to use additional data-gathering methods if the necessary information can be obtained using a single method (Gentry, 2018). A certain method of data collecting may be more suitable for this investigation than another. Interviews and focus groups, for instance, may be preferable to surveys if the aim is to

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

7 learn about people's thoughts and emotions (Tanabe et al., 2023). Additionally, using various collecting disciplines may result in needless invasions of privacy, especially if the study issue concerns sensitive or private information. Researchers may choose a streamlined approach to data collecting if doing so would reduce the likelihood of ethical violations (Tanabe et al., 2023). When data is obtained from several sources or using multiple techniques, some may be duplicated. Sometimes it's easier to just stick to one field of study if it can give you the whole picture. Moreover, research and data analysis might become more convoluted when numerous collecting disciplines are included. Bringing in other disciplines may not be essential and may muddy the findings if the research topic is simple and can be solved by a single strategy (Tanabe et al., 2023). Tanabe et al. (2023) emphasize that it is worth noting that factors like available resources, ethical concerns, and the desired outcomes of the study all play a role in deciding whether or not to use a mixed-methods approach to data gathering. To guarantee the validity and dependability of their results, researchers must carefully evaluate these characteristics and choose the most suitable collecting field or combination of disciplines. Conclusion In conclusion, there are several benefits to integrating different collection methods within the intelligence-gathering process. Analysts may obtain a more full and accurate picture of the situation by integrating data from many sources. They may then be able to reduce risks and make more informed choices. On the other hand, there are circumstances when combining data collection methods would not be possible or desired. One approach may be preferable to another

8 when resources are few; the study issue is straightforward, or both. The intelligence-collecting operation's demands will determine whether or not various collection disciplines will be used.

9 References Gentry, J. A. (2018). Favorite INTs: how they develop, why they matter. Intelligence and National Security , 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1080/02684527.2018.1449371 Izzat Alsmadi. (2023). Collection Operations . 347–351. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031- 21651-0_14 Tanabe, R., Robson, Filho, S., Alves-da-Silva, D., & Joao. (2023). OSINT Methods in the Intelligence Cycle . 42–54. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-30592-4_4 US Naval War College. (2015). LibGuides: Intelligence Studies: Types of Intelligence Collection . Libguides.com. https://usnwc.libguides.com/c.php?g=494120&p=3381426

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version