Reading Response 1
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
San Jacinto Community College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1301-363
Subject
History
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by ProfTurkey4162
Inary Reyes
HIST 1302-329
Reading Response 1
January 21, 2024
Andrew Carnegie held pretty progressive beliefs about wealth. How compelling are
Carnegie's ideas more than a century later? Which ideas do you see as dated or old?
While some of Carnegie's ideas remain compelling, such as the encouragement of
philanthropy and social responsibility, others appear outdated considering changing societal
values, notably on topics such as paternalism, meritocracy, and the role of government.
Andrew Carnegie's argument for philanthropy and the wise use of riches remains
persuasive today. Carnegie stated that people who have large fortunes should see their riches as a
vehicle for social progress. This viewpoint has lasted to this day, as seen by the behavior of many
modern billionaires who donate a significant amount of their fortune to philanthropic
organizations. The concept of philanthropy as a moral obligation is consistent with the belief that
people with significant means are responsible for addressing societal concerns. Carnegie's
emphasis on social responsibility has affected current discussions about corporate ethics and the
role of firms in promoting community welfare.
Despite the ongoing attraction of some components of Carnegie's worldview, others
appear to be outdated such as Carnegie's paternalistic approach as it raises questions regarding
power relations and the premise that the wealthy should decide how to use their resources best.
Furthermore, Carnegie's meritocratic ideas, which hold that money is acquired through hard
effort and talent, may contrast with current discussions about income disparity and systematic
hurdles to equal opportunity. Furthermore, Carnegie's preference for private philanthropy over
government involvement may be questioned in today's setting, where discussions regarding the
appropriate role of government in tackling societal concerns continue.
Inary Reyes
HIST 1302-329
Reading Response 1
January 21, 2024
Andrew Carnegie's ideas about wealth, while enduring in some respects, require careful
adaptation in the 21st century. The enduring emphasis on philanthropy and social responsibility
reflects a shared belief in the potential for wealth to positively impact society. However, as
cultural norms shift, components of Carnegie's worldview, including paternalism, meritocracy,
and skepticism of government interference, appear to be less in line with current viewpoints.
Navigating Carnegie's legacy entails acknowledging the timeless value of some of his concepts
while evaluating and modifying others to fit the difficulties of the present world.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help