comparitive

docx

School

Australian College of Business and Technology, Colombo *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

202

Subject

Arts Humanities

Date

Nov 24, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

Uploaded by onlysahar64

COMAPRITIVE ANALYSIS OF “A Village After Dark" AND "The Lottery," Introduction: In the realm of short fiction, the nuances and intricacies of the human experience are often explored through the lens of distinct narratives and unique storytelling techniques. In this comparative essay, we delve into the worlds crafted by two renowned authors—Kazuo Ishiguro and Shirley Jackson—through their short stories, "A Village After Dark" and "The Lottery," respectively. These tales, while distinct in their themes and narrative approaches, share a common thread: the revelation of concealed darkness within ostensibly ordinary settings. As we embark on this exploration, we will analyze the structural elements, thematic underpinnings, and the profound use of language and symbolism in each story. Ishiguro, celebrated for his exploration of memory and perception, guides us through the labyrinth of personal recollections in "A Village After Dark," while Jackson, a master of societal critique, confronts us with the chilling ritual of "The Lottery." Through a detailed examination of their narrative styles, use of symbolism, and the poignant quotes that punctuate their works, we aim to unravel the layers of meaning embedded in these captivating tales. These stories, each a masterpiece, offer not only a glimpse into the shadows that linger within their fictional worlds but also an opportunity for readers to reflect on the broader dimensions of darkness—be it personal or societal. As we navigate the labyrinth of these narratives, we invite you to join us on a literary journey that transcends the boundaries of ordinary storytelling, pushing the boundaries of perception and challenging the very fabric of tradition and memory. Structural Elements and Narrative Styles:

In "A Village After Dark," Ishiguro constructs a compelling narrative through a first-person perspective, immersing readers in the subjective experience of the protagonist. The dilapidated house, a central element, becomes a symbolic repository of memories, shrouded in an enigmatic darkness. Ishiguro's prose, with phrases like "Memories can be distorted. They're just an interpretation, not a record," delves into the fragile nature of recollection, prompting readers to question the reliability of memory. This structural choice, coupled with Ishiguro's evocative language, creates an atmosphere where the line between reality and perception blurs. On the other hand, Jackson adopts a detached third-person point of view in "The Lottery," employing a matter-of-fact tone that amplifies the shock value of the story's climax. The seemingly ordinary nature of the town and its routine events, described alongside the lottery, underscores the insidious normalcy of the ritual. Jackson's structural decisions serve to heighten the impact of societal critique, as the reader is positioned as an observer, gradually realizing the grim reality concealed beneath the façade of tradition. Use of Symbols: Ishiguro employs symbolism with finesse in "A Village After Dark," notably through the dilapidated house and the surrounding darkness. The house, embodying the protagonist's memories, becomes a haunting symbol of the past's persistence. The elusive shadows within the house symbolize the hidden, perhaps unsettling, aspects of personal history. Ishiguro subtly intertwines these symbols with the protagonist's introspections, guiding readers to question the reliability of their own memories. In "The Lottery," Shirley Jackson employs the lottery itself as a powerful symbol. Initially presented as a communal event, it gradually unravels as a ritualistic act of violence. The symbolism of the lottery challenges the blind adherence to tradition and the

dangers of unquestioning conformity. The black box, a physical representation of tradition, holds an ominous significance, serving as a reminder of the arbitrary cruelty woven into societal norms. Common Themes: Dark Realities in Seemingly Normal Settings: Both stories explore the theme of hidden darkness within seemingly ordinary communities. In "A Village After Dark," Ishiguro subtly reveals the unsettling undercurrents in a village setting, while Jackson, in "The Lottery," presents a shocking ritual in an otherwise conventional town. Quotes and Analysis: From "A Village After Dark": "The house seemed to hold onto the dark. It hid things in the corners of its shadows, and when I turned to look, they vanished." Ishiguro's use of language creates a mysterious atmosphere, emphasizing the hidden secrets within the village. "Memories can be distorted. They're just an interpretation, not a record." This quote reflects the theme of unreliable memories and the malleability of perception, adding a layer of complexity to the narrative. From "The Lottery": "It isn't fair, it isn't right."This quote captures the essence of the protagonist's realization about the injustice of the lottery, prompting readers to question societal norms. "The lottery was conducted—as were the square dances, the teenage club, the Halloween program—by Mr. Summers."The casual tone in describing the lottery

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

alongside other seemingly normal events underscores the story's theme of blind adherence to tradition. Comparative Analysis: Narrative Perspective: Ishiguro's choice of a first-person perspective in "A Village After Dark" creates an intimate connection with the protagonist, allowing readers to delve into the complexities of memory and perception. In contrast, Jackson's third-person perspective in "The Lottery" maintains a degree of emotional distance, emphasizing the societal critique. Symbolism and Themes: While both stories use symbols to convey deeper meanings, Ishiguro's focus on personal memories and the unreliability of perception contrasts with Jackson's societal critique of blind tradition. "A Village After Dark" delves into the internal, whereas "The Lottery" explores external social structures. In conclusion, "A Village After Dark" and "The Lottery" share common ground in exposing the darkness beneath seemingly normal exteriors. However, their divergent narrative styles and thematic emphases contribute to unique reading experiences, inviting readers to reflect on both personal and societal dimensions of darkness. These stories, though divergent in their narrative styles and thematic emphases, converge in their ability to reveal the concealed darkness within their respective settings. Ishiguro and Jackson, masters of their craft, beckon readers to contemplate the intricate interplay between personal recollections and societal norms, challenging preconceived notions and prompting a profound exploration of the shadows that linger within the pages of their captivating tales.

WORK CITED Ishiguro, Kazuo. "A Village After Dark." Nocturnes: Five Stories of Music and Nightfall , Faber and Faber, 2009, pp. 23-46. Jackson, Shirley. "The Lottery." The Lottery and Other Stories , Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2005, pp. 291-299.

comparitive

Related Documents