Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Childhood: Key Insights from Montgomery

This assignment is based on Module 3 and focuses exclusively on your textbook by Montgomery - An Introduction to Childhood: Anthropological Perspectives on Children’s Lives . Reference/use only the readings from the course. 1. Based on Chapters 1 and 2 in Montgomery, why is it difficult to apply the Western notion of “childhood” cross-culturally? (10 marks) The inherent cultural heterogeneity in the understanding of childhood poses issues when applying the Western concept of childhood across cultures. In the West, childhood is usually seen as a separate stage of life characterized by innocence, dependence, and education. However, this idea is difficult to apply in different cultural contexts. For instance, the economic and family arrangements of many non-Western civilizations mandate that children participate in productive activities from a young age and provide material support for their families. The Western ideal of children as consumers rather than producers starkly contrasts this. It is also difficult to define childhood universally because the age at which children are deemed independent and responsible differs greatly throughout cultures. As an example, in the textbook, they talk about the Western notion, but they mention that in “Western Europe the notion of childhood as a distinct human condition started to emerge only around the end of the 15 th century, and that before this people had little conception of childhood as a phase in the life-course.” (Montgomery, pg 51, 2009) I believe that this is a good example because it

gives us an insight into the Western notion in Europe and how they look at children and childhood. 2. Using Montgomery’s book, illustrate by way of cross- cultural examples how children, from an early age onwards, contribute productively to their family and are viewed as producers and not consumers as in Western cultures. (10 marks) The Western view of children’s duties and contributions within the family is very different from the non-Western view, which views children as resource consumers rather than as contributors to the family’s well-being. An example is indigenous civilizations. Children in these societies are taught survival techniques from an early age. They pick up skills in building shelters, fishing, hunting, and navigating the treacherous Arctic landscape. These abilities immediately improve the family’s way of living and are essential to the child’s survival. Children who actively participate in these activities not only help their families gain food and resources, but also contribute to the preservation of their educational institutions and cultural traditions. The notion that youngsters might help in the household highlights the generational transfer of duties and talents. Children actively participate in cultural and spiritual traditions in certain Native American communities. They engage in storytelling, ceremonies, and rituals to pass on and protect their cultural legacy. Children's participation in maintaining

their traditions is valued, indicating that their community views them as active participants in their cultural identity rather than only as knowledge consumers. Conversely, formal schooling is highly valued in Western countries, where childhood is seen as a time when children are dependent on adults for necessities like food, shelter, and medical care. Although there is some truth to this viewpoint, it usually ignores the initiative and skills of young people. 3. Using ethnographic examples in Montgomery, explain why the disciplining of children appears to be harsher in some societies than others. (5 marks) Communities differ greatly in how they discipline their children, and ethnographic research can shed light on why certain communities seem to discipline their children more harshly than others. To demonstrate this argument, let’s look at an ethnographic case from Montgomery, Alabama. Discipline policies can differ greatly in Montgomery, as they can in many other American cities, based on historical, social, and cultural considerations. In the textbook Montgomery says, “By using ethnographic evidence from non-Western societies, she argued that children outside Europe and North America had to undergo much less dramatic discontinuities in their cultural conditioning, and that through institutions such as age-sets and initiation into secret knowledge, people could pass from role to role without the stress and strain of Western adolescent.” (Montgomery, 2009, pg24)

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

The reason for this example is to give more of an insight on the topic of ethnography. 4. Is the term “adolescent” basically a Western concept which does not apply cross-culturally? Discuss based on your overview of Montgomery. (5 marks) Since the idea of adolescence is based on Western conceptions of development and age, its application in cross-cultural contexts is up for debate. Montgomery’s work probably examines the cultural variations on this idea. There might not be a distinct “adolescents’ phase as defined by Western culture in many non-Western cultures in many non-Western countries. Rather, cultures frequently celebrate the passage from childhood to maturity with their customs, including ceremonies, rituals, or other cultural behaviours. In some cultural contexts, the Western idea of adolescence is less relevant due to the significant variations in social duties and obligations that occur during the adolescent years. It is crucial to understand that the label “adolescent” is not always applicable and may not adequately describe the experiences of youth in various cultural contexts. (Montgomery, 2009) References

Montgomery, H. (2009). What is a Child? In An introduction to childhood: Anthropological perspectives on children’s lives (pp. 50–51). essay, Wiley- Blackwell. Montgomery, H. (2009). Childhood within Anthropology. In An introduction to childhood: Anthropological perspectives on children’s lives (pp. 23–24). essay, Wiley-Blackwell.

ANTR Assignment 2

Related Documents