Concept explainers
Solving Tough
There are many scheduling problems in the healthcare arena, from scheduling nurses and OR rooms, to scheduling doctor’s appointments with no-shows, to triaging patients and doling out vaccinations: but one of the most critical scheduling problems involves organ transplants. A husband and wife team of surgeon (Segev) and mathematician (Gentry) have studied both kidney and liver transplant allocation and have made some groundbreaking recommendations.
For kidney transplants, finding an appropriate match is sometimes difficult. Waiting for a kidney from someone who is deceased can take too long. Unfortunately, even though a person can function with only one kidney, donating the other kidney to a loved one may not be possible if the blood type and other antibodies do not match. One solution is to pair two such incompatible couples so that the donors’ kidneys do not help their loved one directly but do allow them to receive a transplant more quickly. This is known as the Kidney Paired Donation (KPD) program, and before Gentry and Segev completed their research, perhaps 60 such exchanges took place each year. After applying a new matching algorithm to a nationwide set of donors/recipients, more than 600 exchange transplants were occurring each year, saving lives and over $750 million annually in healthcare costs.
Livers come from deceased donors and have a short shelf life of less than four hours, eliminating the possibility of lengthy transit times between donor and transplant center. In the United States, a recipient waiting list used to be divided into 11 geographic districts, and available livers were allocated within the same district (perhaps because of the limited transit time). This led to a disparity in service, with some districts having more need and less availability than others. Desperate patients were known to move into a more receptive district to await transplant. Gentry and Sedev sought to redraw the district boundaries to minimize disparity in access to livers.
Redistricting is a class of problems that uses integer programming (similar to linear programming) to design geographic boundaries between units, and is usually applied to school districts or voting districts. The integer programming model proposed by Gentry and Segev is designed specifically for liver transplant redistricting and is more transparent to the user than previous models. As is common with practical models, the liver committee had some design constraints in mind that reduced the size of the problem. The districts should be adjoining, the number of districts should be at least four and no more than eight, the maximum transport time should be three hours, and each district should have a minimum of six transplant centers. Gentry and Segev added the ranking of patients by need, called the MELD index, to the analysis. MELD prioritizes candidates based on the risk of death while awaiting liver transplantation.
A simulation model was built to test out the proposed 4-district, 6-district, and 8-district models over a five year time frame. The recommended 4-district plan would save 554 lives, cost $25,000 less than other plans, and eliminate the disparity between districts in receiving organs. The Liver Committee that manages allocation policies unanimously approved the 4-district plan (even when transplant centers in their own district would see a reduction in allocations).
For more details about Gentry and Segev’s transplant models, search YouTube for the video. “The Right Match: A Short Documentary.” Comment on the process of discovery and the cross-functional interaction of the two researchers.
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 17 Solutions
Operations and Supply Chain Management, 9th Edition WileyPLUS Registration Card + Loose-leaf Print Companion
Additional Business Textbook Solutions
Business in Action
Principles of Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management (10th Edition)
Operations Management, Binder Ready Version: An Integrated Approach
Business in Action (8th Edition)
Operations Management: Processes and Supply Chains (12th Edition) (What's New in Operations Management)
Operations Management: Processes and Supply Chains (11th Edition)
- Scenario The KOREAN factory of Hi-Tech Metal, Inc. primarily manufactures plumbing system parts for gas pipes, drainage pipes, water supply pipes and hoses etc. A mainframe computer was used for scheduling, but it took a lot of time and unnecessarily put heavy workload on scheduling managers and on-site workers. Following are the associated problems to meet customers’ needs Lengthy 3 to 4 days schedule drafting time, caused by mainframe computer’s long processing time. Inflexibility of mainframe computer to sudden order changes, leading to tedious manual calculation and direct on-site adjustment Extra workload for on-site workers One-month base scheduling that cannot meet customers’ need, Task 4 Considering above scenario justify improvements and alternatives to design and manufacturing of plumbing system. [Improvements, alternative systems, explain the IoT systems and Industry4.0 impacts]arrow_forwardScenario The KOREAN factory of Hi-Tech Metal, Inc. primarily manufactures plumbing system parts for gas pipes, drainage pipes, water supply pipes and hoses etc. A mainframe computer was used for scheduling, but it took a lot of time and unnecessarily put heavy workload on scheduling managers and on-site workers. Following are the associated problems to meet customers’ needs Lengthy 3 to 4 days schedule drafting time, caused by mainframe computer’s long processing time. Inflexibility of mainframe computer to sudden order changes, leading to tedious manual calculation and direct on-site adjustment Extra workload for on-site workers One-month base scheduling that cannot meet customers’ need, Task 1 Considering above scenario Summarize the design process for the finished component [Identify components, explain the utilities and design process (5/7/10 step) for components]arrow_forwardData concerning three of the activity cost pools of Salcido LLC, a legal firm, have been provided below: Activity Cost Pool Researching legal issues Meeting with clients Preparing documents Total Cost Total Activity $ 20,780 $ 1,174,173 $ 92,140 660 research hours 7,293 meeting hours 5,760 documents The activity rate for the "meeting with clients" activity cost pool is closest to: Multiple Choice $90 per meeting hour $71 per meeting hour $161 per meeting hour $1,174,173 per meeting hourarrow_forward
- Give three examples of unethical scheduling activity and discuss which ethical standard each scenario violates?arrow_forwardPlease help me answer this question, for it is hard for me to understand the topic. This is from operations management (scheduling).arrow_forwardHow is the scheduling of patients in a doctor’s clinic similar to and different from the scheduling of jobs in a factory?arrow_forward
- William Beebe owns a small shoe store. He has 10 pairs of shoes that requireresoling and polishing. He has a machine that can resole one pair of shoes at atime, and the time required for the operation varies with the type and condition of theshoe and the type of sole that is used. Shoes are polished on a machine dedi-cated tothis purpose as well, and polishing is always done after resoling. His assistant generally does the polishing while Mr. Beebe does the resoling. The resoling and polishingtimes (in minutes) are Shoes Resoling Time Polishing Time1 14 32 28 13 12 24 6 55 10 106 14 67 4 128 25 89 15 510 10 5In what order should the shoes be repaired in order to minimize the total makespanfor these 10 jobs?arrow_forwardDescribe scheduling needs in job shops.arrow_forwardGive three examples of unethical scheduling activity and explain which ethical standard each scenario violates?arrow_forward
- Discuss 3 examples of unethical scheduling activity and describe which ethical standard each scenario violates?arrow_forwardplease answer in 30 minutes. answer only if you are 100% sure of solution, else negative rating.arrow_forwardStatement of the ProblemKuala Lumpur Hospital, as we all know, is one of Malaysia's busiest hospitals. This is due to the fact that it admits a diverse range of patients suffering from a diverse range of disorders. These patients have arrived as a result of the health sector that operates in this facility. In other words, the departments within it are quite diverse. As a result, the hospital must deal with a high volume of both existing and new patients. Employees are required to gather patient personal information such as name, address, and so on for all of these admissions. It intends to capture and save their data for further use. Employee admissions, such as physicians and nurses, should also be recorded by the hospital. Furthermore, the hospital must manually record the many departments, rooms, and physicians in hospitals. It is also required to keep frequent records of patients, patients admitted to the hospital, doctor exams on patients, patients who have had surgery, and…arrow_forward
- Practical Management ScienceOperations ManagementISBN:9781337406659Author:WINSTON, Wayne L.Publisher:Cengage,