place, such students actually reported "higher levels of [academic] engagement and more frequent use of deep learning activities." Jillian Kinzie, a researcher involved with that project, confessed that when she saw those results, her first reaction was, "This can't be right. We have to go back and look at this again." But the benefits did indeed prove impressive. As the survey's director, George Kuh, told a reporter, "Compared with their counterparts, children of helicopter parents were more satisfied with every aspect of their college experience, gained more in such areas as writing peers about and critical thinking, and were more likely to talk with faculty and substantive topics." Meanwhile, in the 2012 study of grown children, "frequent parental involvement, including a wide range of support, was associated with better well-being for young adults." Support (not limited to money) from one's parents may be helpful, not critical, when students graduate with uncertain employment prospects and, perhaps, a crushing load of debt. A fair-minded appraisal of the subject suggests that denunciations of HP are based less on evidence than on a disparaging attitude about young people or on the value judgment that kids ought to become independent as soon as possible. That judgment may seem like common sense, but maturity isn't the same as self-sufficiency. Most developmental psychologists have concluded that the quality of parent-child relationships continues to matter even past childhood. Good parenting is less about pushing one's offspring to be independent at a certain age than being responsive to what a particular child needs. But doesn't research show that HP can be psychologically damaging at least to some young people? A handful of small studies have shown that extreme versions of HP sometimes go hand-in-hand with anxiety or a diminished sense of well-being. In each of these studies, however, questionnaires were given to students only at a single college, and the strength of the results weren't particularly impressive. Look closer, in fact, and you'll find two caveats to all of this research that are even more damning. First, the findings offer no support for the conclusion that HP caused the problems with which it was associated. One set of researchers admitted that "when parents perceive their child as depressed, they may be more likely to 'hover."" Those in another study acknowledged that unhappy students "may view their parents as more intrusive." Here, in other words, we have two alternative, perfectly plausible explanations for the (weak) correlation. One: if the parents are hovering, it's because the kids already have issues. Two: students who are struggling may be more likely than their peers to interpret whatever their parents are doing as excessive involvement. Either way, the evidence doesn't prove that HP makes kids unhappy. The second major caveat is truly intriguing; its implications extend to the heart of what's meant by "overparenting" of children of all ages. When you read the research closely, it turns out that what's classified as over-, intrusive, or helicopter parenting might more accurately be described as excessive control of children. This offers a very different lens through which to view all those warnings that parents do too much for

Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
5th Edition
ISBN:9780134477961
Author:Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Publisher:Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Chapter1: The Science Of Psychology
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1TY
icon
Related questions
Question

Write a summary about this article please.

Reading
Read the passage carefully. Then complete the exercises that follow.
CD 1
TR 2
5
10
15
20
25
30
"Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as
widespread as we think?
by Alfie Kohn, alfiekohn.org
Parents who are overly involved in the lives of their college-age children are
the folks we love to scorn. A steady stream of articles and blog posts bristle with
indignation over dads who phone the dean about a trivial problem or moms who
know more than we think they should about junior's love life. But it may be a good
time to ask just how common such incidents really are—and whether "helicopter
parenting” (HP), when it does occur, is as damaging as we've been led to believe.
When you track down hard data, the results contrast sharply with the conventional
wisdom. Yes, most parents are in touch with their college-age kids on a regular basis.
But communicating isn't the same thing as intervening on a child's behalf, and the
latter seems to be fairly rare. The National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE),
which reached out to more than 9,000 students at 24 colleges and universities, found
that only 13 percent of college freshmen and 8 percent of seniors said a parent had
frequently intervened to help them solve problems.
As one university administrator told the Chronicle of Higher Education, "The
popular image of modern parents as high-strung nuisances who torment college
administrators doesn't match reality." In any case, the students themselves certainly
don't seem to be tormented by their parents. An overwhelming majority of the
10,000-plus University of California students contacted in a separate survey said their
parents weren't involved in their choice of courses or their major.
Alarming media reports have also claimed that parents hover once their
young-adult children enter the workplace, but there's little basis for that claim either.
Michigan State University researchers discovered that 77 percent of the 725 employers
they surveyed "hardly ever witnessed a parent while hiring a college senior." As for
grown children outside of college and the workplace, the only study on the topic I
could find, published in 2012, reported that just one in five or six parents seemed to be
intensely involved in their children's lives.
But what about the effects of such parenting on individual young people when
it does occur? Here, too, a look at empirical findings yields surprising conclusions.
For starters, some research has actually made a case in favor of parents' being very
actively connected-and, yes, even involved with their young-adult children. That
NSSE survey, for example, didn't find a lot of HP going on, but where it was taking
CHAPTER 1 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think?
5
Transcribed Image Text:Reading Read the passage carefully. Then complete the exercises that follow. CD 1 TR 2 5 10 15 20 25 30 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think? by Alfie Kohn, alfiekohn.org Parents who are overly involved in the lives of their college-age children are the folks we love to scorn. A steady stream of articles and blog posts bristle with indignation over dads who phone the dean about a trivial problem or moms who know more than we think they should about junior's love life. But it may be a good time to ask just how common such incidents really are—and whether "helicopter parenting” (HP), when it does occur, is as damaging as we've been led to believe. When you track down hard data, the results contrast sharply with the conventional wisdom. Yes, most parents are in touch with their college-age kids on a regular basis. But communicating isn't the same thing as intervening on a child's behalf, and the latter seems to be fairly rare. The National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE), which reached out to more than 9,000 students at 24 colleges and universities, found that only 13 percent of college freshmen and 8 percent of seniors said a parent had frequently intervened to help them solve problems. As one university administrator told the Chronicle of Higher Education, "The popular image of modern parents as high-strung nuisances who torment college administrators doesn't match reality." In any case, the students themselves certainly don't seem to be tormented by their parents. An overwhelming majority of the 10,000-plus University of California students contacted in a separate survey said their parents weren't involved in their choice of courses or their major. Alarming media reports have also claimed that parents hover once their young-adult children enter the workplace, but there's little basis for that claim either. Michigan State University researchers discovered that 77 percent of the 725 employers they surveyed "hardly ever witnessed a parent while hiring a college senior." As for grown children outside of college and the workplace, the only study on the topic I could find, published in 2012, reported that just one in five or six parents seemed to be intensely involved in their children's lives. But what about the effects of such parenting on individual young people when it does occur? Here, too, a look at empirical findings yields surprising conclusions. For starters, some research has actually made a case in favor of parents' being very actively connected-and, yes, even involved with their young-adult children. That NSSE survey, for example, didn't find a lot of HP going on, but where it was taking CHAPTER 1 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think? 5
Reading
Read the passage carefully. Then complete the exercises that follow.
CD 1
TR 2
5
10
15
20
25
30
"Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as
widespread as we think?
by Alfie Kohn, alfiekohn.org
Parents who are overly involved in the lives of their college-age children are
the folks we love to scorn. A steady stream of articles and blog posts bristle with
indignation over dads who phone the dean about a trivial problem or moms who
know more than we think they should about junior's love life. But it may be a good
time to ask just how common such incidents really are—and whether "helicopter
parenting” (HP), when it does occur, is as damaging as we've been led to believe.
When you track down hard data, the results contrast sharply with the conventional
wisdom. Yes, most parents are in touch with their college-age kids on a regular basis.
But communicating isn't the same thing as intervening on a child's behalf, and the
latter seems to be fairly rare. The National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE),
which reached out to more than 9,000 students at 24 colleges and universities, found
that only 13 percent of college freshmen and 8 percent of seniors said a parent had
frequently intervened to help them solve problems.
As one university administrator told the Chronicle of Higher Education, "The
popular image of modern parents as high-strung nuisances who torment college
administrators doesn't match reality." In any case, the students themselves certainly
don't seem to be tormented by their parents. An overwhelming majority of the
10,000-plus University of California students contacted in a separate survey said their
parents weren't involved in their choice of courses or their major.
Alarming media reports have also claimed that parents hover once their
young-adult children enter the workplace, but there's little basis for that claim either.
Michigan State University researchers discovered that 77 percent of the 725 employers
they surveyed "hardly ever witnessed a parent while hiring a college senior." As for
grown children outside of college and the workplace, the only study on the topic I
could find, published in 2012, reported that just one in five or six parents seemed to be
intensely involved in their children's lives.
But what about the effects of such parenting on individual young people when
it does occur? Here, too, a look at empirical findings yields surprising conclusions.
For starters, some research has actually made a case in favor of parents' being very
actively connected-and, yes, even involved with their young-adult children. That
NSSE survey, for example, didn't find a lot of HP going on, but where it was taking
CHAPTER 1 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think?
5
Transcribed Image Text:Reading Read the passage carefully. Then complete the exercises that follow. CD 1 TR 2 5 10 15 20 25 30 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think? by Alfie Kohn, alfiekohn.org Parents who are overly involved in the lives of their college-age children are the folks we love to scorn. A steady stream of articles and blog posts bristle with indignation over dads who phone the dean about a trivial problem or moms who know more than we think they should about junior's love life. But it may be a good time to ask just how common such incidents really are—and whether "helicopter parenting” (HP), when it does occur, is as damaging as we've been led to believe. When you track down hard data, the results contrast sharply with the conventional wisdom. Yes, most parents are in touch with their college-age kids on a regular basis. But communicating isn't the same thing as intervening on a child's behalf, and the latter seems to be fairly rare. The National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE), which reached out to more than 9,000 students at 24 colleges and universities, found that only 13 percent of college freshmen and 8 percent of seniors said a parent had frequently intervened to help them solve problems. As one university administrator told the Chronicle of Higher Education, "The popular image of modern parents as high-strung nuisances who torment college administrators doesn't match reality." In any case, the students themselves certainly don't seem to be tormented by their parents. An overwhelming majority of the 10,000-plus University of California students contacted in a separate survey said their parents weren't involved in their choice of courses or their major. Alarming media reports have also claimed that parents hover once their young-adult children enter the workplace, but there's little basis for that claim either. Michigan State University researchers discovered that 77 percent of the 725 employers they surveyed "hardly ever witnessed a parent while hiring a college senior." As for grown children outside of college and the workplace, the only study on the topic I could find, published in 2012, reported that just one in five or six parents seemed to be intensely involved in their children's lives. But what about the effects of such parenting on individual young people when it does occur? Here, too, a look at empirical findings yields surprising conclusions. For starters, some research has actually made a case in favor of parents' being very actively connected-and, yes, even involved with their young-adult children. That NSSE survey, for example, didn't find a lot of HP going on, but where it was taking CHAPTER 1 "Helicopter Parenting" Hysteria: Is it as widespread as we think? 5
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 3 steps

Blurred answer
Recommended textbooks for you
Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
Ciccarelli: Psychology_5 (5th Edition)
Psychology
ISBN:
9780134477961
Author:
Saundra K. Ciccarelli, J. Noland White
Publisher:
PEARSON
Cognitive Psychology
Cognitive Psychology
Psychology
ISBN:
9781337408271
Author:
Goldstein, E. Bruce.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning,
Introduction to Psychology: Gateways to Mind and …
Introduction to Psychology: Gateways to Mind and …
Psychology
ISBN:
9781337565691
Author:
Dennis Coon, John O. Mitterer, Tanya S. Martini
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Psychology in Your Life (Second Edition)
Psychology in Your Life (Second Edition)
Psychology
ISBN:
9780393265156
Author:
Sarah Grison, Michael Gazzaniga
Publisher:
W. W. Norton & Company
Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research a…
Cognitive Psychology: Connecting Mind, Research a…
Psychology
ISBN:
9781285763880
Author:
E. Bruce Goldstein
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Theories of Personality (MindTap Course List)
Theories of Personality (MindTap Course List)
Psychology
ISBN:
9781305652958
Author:
Duane P. Schultz, Sydney Ellen Schultz
Publisher:
Cengage Learning