Let us consider an economic sector characterized by the following data. The (inverse) demand function is p = 20 -2q with q the quantities produced by the firms in the sector and p the price. The total cost of production for any firm in the sector is: CT(q) = q* - 4q + 5 a) Firm 1 seeks to deter the entry of another firm, firm 2, into its market througha sustainable monopoly strategy. Calculate the equilibrium price, quantity and profit of firm 1 given this strategy Answer: Price set will be equal to marginal cost. P = MC MG = 29- 4 Putting this into demand function we get: 2q-4 = 20 - 2q q* = 6 (Quantity produced to deter competition) Putting this into demand function: p* = 8 (Price charged to deter competition) Firm 1 has failed to deter entry into its market. So, we now have a situation of non-cooperative oligopoly, with firm 2 having the same total cost as firm 1. The market quantity is such that q = q1 + q2 I) It is assumed that both firms 1 and 2 compete on quantity by making their decisions simultaneously. Identify the duopoly situation. Calculate the quantities offered by each firm, the equilibrium price, and their individual profits Answer: For firm 1: Optimal Condition: MR1 = MC1 TR1 = p°q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q1 MR1 = 20 - 4q1 - q2 MC1 = 2q1 - 4 Putting in optimal condition: 20 - 4q1 - q2 = 2q1 - 4 (24 - q2)/6 = q1• -) (Reaction function of firm1 for a given level of firm 2 output) For Firm 2: Optimal Condition: MR2 = MC2 TR1 = p*q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q2 MR1 = 20 - q1 - 4q2 MC1 = 2q2 - 4 q2* = (24 - q1)/6 -(ii) (Reaction function of firm2 for a given level of firm 1 output) Now we take value of q2* and put it into equation (i): 6q1 = 24 - (24 - q1)/6 36q1 = 120 + q1 q1* = 3.43 approx. Putting in equation (ii) we get: q2* = 3.43 Putting in demand function: P= 20 - 2*6.86 = 6.28 Profit of firm 1: => p*q1-q12 + 4q1 -5 Putting in optimal condition: q1 + q2 = q* = 6.86 = 23.52 - 11.76 + 13.72 -5 = 30.46 Similarly, Profit of firm 2 = 30.46 QUESTION (to answer): I) Represent the duopoly situation of question I) as a normal form game (matrix), with firm 1 in the row and firm 2 in the column. In addition to the equilibrium quantity strategies, you will choose as non-equilibrium quantity strategies q = 2 for both firm 1 and firm 2. By carefully explaining your reasoning, show that the equilibrium solution found in question I) is indeed a Nash equilibrium (For this question, please detail your profit calculations for out of equilibrium)

ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
14th Edition
ISBN:9780190931919
Author:NEWNAN
Publisher:NEWNAN
Chapter1: Making Economics Decisions
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1QTC
icon
Related questions
Question
Let us consider an economic sector characterized by the following data.
The (inverse) demand function is p = 20 -2q with q the quantities produced by the firms in the sector
and p the price.
The total cost of production for any firm in the sector is:
CT(q) = q* - 4g + 5
a) Firm 1 seeks to deter the entry of another firm, firm 2, into its market through a
sustainable monopoly strategy.
Calculate the equilibrium price, quantity and profit of firm 1 given this strategy
Answer:
Price set will be equal to marginal cost. P = MC MG = 29- 4
Putting this into demand function we get: 2q-4 = 20 - 29
q* = 6 (Quantity produced to deter competition)
Putting this into demand function: p* = 8 (Price charged to deter competition)
Firm 1 has failed to deter entry into its market.
So, we now have a situation of non-cooperative oligopoly, with firm 2 having the same total cost as
firm 1. The market quantity is such that q = q1 + q2
I)
It is assumed that both firms 1 and 2 compete on quantity by making their decisions
simultaneously. Identify the duopoly situation.
Calculate the quantities offered by each firm, the equilibrium price, and their individual
profits
Answer: For firm 1: Optimal Condition: MR1 = MC1
TR1 = p*q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q1 MR1 = 20 - 4q1 - q2
MC1 = 2q1 - 4
Putting in optimal condition: 20 - 4q1 - q2 = 2q1 - 4
(24 - q2)/6 = q1 * --) (Reaction function of firm1 for a given level of firm 2 output)
For Firm 2: Optimal Condition: MR2 = MC2
TR1 = p*q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q2
MC1 = 2q2 - 4
q2* = (24 - q1)/6 -(ii) (Reaction function of firm2 for a given level of firm 1 output)
Now we take value of q2* and put it into equation (i): 6q1 = 24 - (24 - q1)/6
36q1 = 120 + q1 q1* = 3.43 approx.
MR1 = 20 - q1 - 4q2
Putting in optimal condition:
Putting in equation (ii) we get: q2• = 3.43
q1 + q2 = q* = 6.86
Putting in demand function: P= 20 - 2*6.86 = 6.28
Profit of firm 1: => p*q1 - q12 + 4q1 -5
= 23.52 - 11.76 + 13.72 -5
= 30.46
Similarly,
Profit of firm 2 = 30.46
QUESTION (to answer):
II)
Represent the duopoly situation of question I) as a normal form game (matrix), with firm
1 in the row and firm 2 in the column. In addition to the equilibrium quantity strategies,
you will choose as non-equilibrium quantity strategies q = 2 for both firm 1 and firm 2.
By carefully explaining your reasoning, show that the equilibrium solution found in
question I) is indeed a Nash equilibrium
(For this question, please detail your profit calculations for out of equilibrium)
Transcribed Image Text:Let us consider an economic sector characterized by the following data. The (inverse) demand function is p = 20 -2q with q the quantities produced by the firms in the sector and p the price. The total cost of production for any firm in the sector is: CT(q) = q* - 4g + 5 a) Firm 1 seeks to deter the entry of another firm, firm 2, into its market through a sustainable monopoly strategy. Calculate the equilibrium price, quantity and profit of firm 1 given this strategy Answer: Price set will be equal to marginal cost. P = MC MG = 29- 4 Putting this into demand function we get: 2q-4 = 20 - 29 q* = 6 (Quantity produced to deter competition) Putting this into demand function: p* = 8 (Price charged to deter competition) Firm 1 has failed to deter entry into its market. So, we now have a situation of non-cooperative oligopoly, with firm 2 having the same total cost as firm 1. The market quantity is such that q = q1 + q2 I) It is assumed that both firms 1 and 2 compete on quantity by making their decisions simultaneously. Identify the duopoly situation. Calculate the quantities offered by each firm, the equilibrium price, and their individual profits Answer: For firm 1: Optimal Condition: MR1 = MC1 TR1 = p*q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q1 MR1 = 20 - 4q1 - q2 MC1 = 2q1 - 4 Putting in optimal condition: 20 - 4q1 - q2 = 2q1 - 4 (24 - q2)/6 = q1 * --) (Reaction function of firm1 for a given level of firm 2 output) For Firm 2: Optimal Condition: MR2 = MC2 TR1 = p*q1 = [20 - 2(q1 +q2)] *q2 MC1 = 2q2 - 4 q2* = (24 - q1)/6 -(ii) (Reaction function of firm2 for a given level of firm 1 output) Now we take value of q2* and put it into equation (i): 6q1 = 24 - (24 - q1)/6 36q1 = 120 + q1 q1* = 3.43 approx. MR1 = 20 - q1 - 4q2 Putting in optimal condition: Putting in equation (ii) we get: q2• = 3.43 q1 + q2 = q* = 6.86 Putting in demand function: P= 20 - 2*6.86 = 6.28 Profit of firm 1: => p*q1 - q12 + 4q1 -5 = 23.52 - 11.76 + 13.72 -5 = 30.46 Similarly, Profit of firm 2 = 30.46 QUESTION (to answer): II) Represent the duopoly situation of question I) as a normal form game (matrix), with firm 1 in the row and firm 2 in the column. In addition to the equilibrium quantity strategies, you will choose as non-equilibrium quantity strategies q = 2 for both firm 1 and firm 2. By carefully explaining your reasoning, show that the equilibrium solution found in question I) is indeed a Nash equilibrium (For this question, please detail your profit calculations for out of equilibrium)
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Monopoly
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, economics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
Recommended textbooks for you
ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
Economics
ISBN:
9780190931919
Author:
NEWNAN
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
Principles of Economics (12th Edition)
Principles of Economics (12th Edition)
Economics
ISBN:
9780134078779
Author:
Karl E. Case, Ray C. Fair, Sharon E. Oster
Publisher:
PEARSON
Engineering Economy (17th Edition)
Engineering Economy (17th Edition)
Economics
ISBN:
9780134870069
Author:
William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, C. Patrick Koelling
Publisher:
PEARSON
Principles of Economics (MindTap Course List)
Principles of Economics (MindTap Course List)
Economics
ISBN:
9781305585126
Author:
N. Gregory Mankiw
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Managerial Economics: A Problem Solving Approach
Managerial Economics: A Problem Solving Approach
Economics
ISBN:
9781337106665
Author:
Luke M. Froeb, Brian T. McCann, Michael R. Ward, Mike Shor
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Managerial Economics & Business Strategy (Mcgraw-…
Managerial Economics & Business Strategy (Mcgraw-…
Economics
ISBN:
9781259290619
Author:
Michael Baye, Jeff Prince
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education