Untitled document.edited (49)
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
201
Subject
Political Science
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
3
Uploaded by jobt481
Question 1
I'm afraid I have to disagree with Senator Tuberville's remarks on the Senate floor earlier this week. I accept and understand his personal views on abortion, but I don't think it's right for him to use his Senate position to obstruct military promotions. His actions are driven more by his convictions than by what is best for the military and its members.
Senator Tuberville contends that the Department of Defense's policy prohibiting military personnel from obtaining abortions is unlawful and unconstitutional. Nonetheless, the policy complies with current Supreme Court rulings in Dobbs v. Jackson's Health Organization and federal law. The approach merely makes legally available healthcare services accessible; it does not compel anyone to get an abortion. The Constitution guarantees the freedom to seek and receive medical care, and this policy ensures that military members and their families can also exercise that right.
Furthermore, Senator Tuberville's assertion that a large portion of Americans oppose the use of tax monies to pay for abortions for active military personnel is not valid. Although some people undoubtedly feel this way, not all Americans share this viewpoint. A Pew Research Center poll from 2019 found that 58% of Americans thought abortion should be allowed in all or most situations, indicating that a sizable segment of the American people do not agree with Senator Tuberville's viewpoint, so it might not be proper for him to use his convictions to obstruct military promotions.
Furthermore, the military will suffer grave consequences due to Senator Tuberville's conduct. His
blocking of promotions is severely disrupting the command structure, and senior officers are being burdened with having to do the duties of many officers, which might make the armed forces less prepared and morale-boosting, which could endanger our national security. Senator Graham said this might eventually hurt our military if it becomes the norm.
Furthermore, it is risky to establish a precedent with Senator Tuberville's claim that the Senate can obstruct military promotions to hold the Department of Defense responsible. It contradicts the idea of civilian command over the armed forces. The Constitution authorizes Congress to organize and maintain armies but stipulates that these forces must abide by federal law. Senator Tuberville is abusing his power by using his Senate position to obstruct promotions and disregarding the professional advice of top military experts who have determined that these individuals are eligible for advancement.
Question 2
I support the Senate Democrats' attempts to remove obstacles to military promotions. The military has suffered due to Senator Tuberville's suspension of advertisements, and this matter needs to be resolved quickly and effectively. Due to Senator Tuberville's block on promotions, there have been significant disruptions to the command structure and a decline in military readiness and morale. At this crucial juncture, the military is under threat in many parts of the globe, and delayed promotions could undermine the forces' capacity. The Senate's Democratic leadership is addressing this issue and ensuring the military's readiness by working toward a resolution to clear the way for the promotions of 367 generals and admirals.
Furthermore, both Republicans and Democrats are concerned about Senator Tuberville's conduct.
Numerous senators have asked him to remove his hold on the military, voicing concerns about its
detrimental repercussions. However, Senator Tuberville has yet to indicate that she would back down, and the Senate needs to act to address this problem.
Moreover, the efforts of the Democrats in the Senate to remove barriers to promotions are compliant with federal legislation and department policy. Military members and their families are entitled to legally available healthcare services, including abortion services, according to the Department of Defense. Senator Tuberville is violating these people's rights and the idea of civilian command over the armed forces by obstructing promotions. To guarantee that the military obeys federal laws and protects the rights of its soldiers, the Senate must approve these promotions.
It may be contended that the Senate Democrats' endeavors to enact a provisional compromise to circumvent Senator Tuberville's influence are merely calculated political maneuvers. Nonetheless, the Senate must move quickly to ratify these promotions through a single piece of legislation, considering the gravity of the situation and the possible repercussions for the armed forces. It's also important to note that a few Republican colleagues of Senator Tuberville have voiced worries regarding his hold on promotions, which emphasizes how urgently this issue needs to be resolved.
In conclusion, there are severe issues and repercussions for the military following Senator Tuberville's decision to halt military promotions due to the Department of Defense's abortion policy. Republicans and Democrats have expressed interest in this matter, and to maintain the rule of law and guarantee military preparedness, the Senate must act and accept these promotions. The Senate must act quickly to rectify Senator Tuberville's actions, which run against the idea of civilian command over the armed forces. The Senate Democrats' attempts to temporarily circumvent the Senate norms to facilitate these promotions demonstrate their commitment to finding a solution and protecting the rights of military members. The Senate's top
priorities should ultimately be the military and its personnel's best interests, not individual senators' or politicians' political objectives.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help