Study Questions Worksheet - week 10
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Durham College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1441
Subject
Philosophy
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
Pages
3
Uploaded by DoctorWaspMaster886
Below is an area for you to capture your thoughts as you work through this lesson.
Your notes on this
worksheet will be used to answer the following discussion questions at the end of the lesson:
Do you believe that there is a moral difference between a beloved family pet and a
livestock animal?
Do you believe that these animals should be treated differently,
some being granted with rights and others not?
A Critique on Regan’s Animal Rights Theory
- Worksheet
1.
What is the main criticism in this lesson of the
arguments for animal rights within our previous
lesson?
2. What is the basis for granting human beings moral
rights that we do not grant animals?
Do you agree?
The main criticism of arguments for animal rights
often revolves around the practical implications and
the perceived lack of balance between ethical
considerations and real-world application. In
essence, while the concept of animal rights
advocates for ethical treatment and respect for all
living beings, criticisms often revolve around the
practical implications of implementing such rights,
the hierarchical nature of rights among animals,
and the balancing act required between human and
animal interests. Achieving a consensus on these
complex issues remains a significant challenge
within discussions on animal rights.
The basis for granting human beings moral rights that
differ from those granted to animals often stems from
various philosophical perspectives, predominantly
emphasizing qualities such as cognitive abilities, self-
awareness, rationality, and moral agency. This
viewpoint argues that these attributes give humans a
unique moral status, justifying the allocation of rights
that are not extended to animals.
As for my agreement,
I see the rationale behind granting different moral
rights based on cognitive abilities and moral agency,
but I also believe in the importance of ethical treatment
for all sentient beings. While humans may have unique
attributes, acknowledging the capacity of animals to
experience suffering and their inherent value as living
beings is crucial in determining how we treat and
interact with them. Striking a balance between
recognizing human exceptionalism and respecting the
inherent worth of animals is a complex but essential
aspect of ethical considerations.
3.
Do you believe it is moral to consume an animal that
has suffered for most of its life?
4.
Explain how your relationship differs between a
family pet, and a random livestock animal.
Are there
different emotions involved?
The morality of consuming an animal suffering for most
of its life is a complex issue influenced by factors such as
suffering, ethical treatment, personal values, and
cultural and societal norms. Ethical concerns arise from
the treatment of animals, personal values, and dietary
choices, and can be influenced by differences in animal
welfare and consumption practices across different
culture.
The emotional connection between a family pet and a
random livestock animal is influenced by shared
experiences, shared experiences, and understanding of
each other's behaviors and needs. A family pet fosters a
deep emotional bond, providing companionship, love,
and emotional support. On the other hand, a random
livestock animal is often seen as utilitarian, providing
resources rather than emotional companionship. The
emotional connection between these two relationships
is characterized by love, attachment, and empathy,
while the relationship with a livestock animal is
transactional.
Planning Post Secondary Instruction by Georgian College - Centre of Teaching and Learning is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-
NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
–
VERSION 2019
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help