What do you think is the most significant problem regarding (1)
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Grand Canyon University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
106
Subject
English
Date
Jan 9, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by SuperChinchillaPerson985
●
What do you think is the most significant problem regarding the sale of organs?
●
One of the most significant issues is the exploitation of vulnerable individuals who may be coerced or forced into selling their organs due to economic desperation. This can lead to a
situation where individuals are not fully informed or compensated fairly for their organs, resulting in inequities and potential harm.
●
Why do you think it is a problem?
The sale of organs can create a black market that encourages illegal activities, including organ trafficking and exploitation of organ donors and recipients. The lack of a regulated and transparent system for organ donation and transplantation further complicates the issue.
●
Who has the power to solve this problem?
The responsibility to fix this problem lies with a combination of individuals, organizations, and governments Some key stakeholders include the International Organizations, medical professionals and organizations, non-governmental Organizations, and society. By collaborating and taking collective action, these stakeholders can work towards combatting organ trafficking, promoting ethical organ donation, and ensuring that organs are obtained and allocated fairly and transparently.
●
Why has it not been solved up to this point?
The issue of organ trafficking involves multiple countries and regions, each with its own laws, regulations, and challenges. Coordinating efforts and establishing a unified approach across borders is a complex task. Crafting effective legislation and regulations to address organ trafficking while respecting individual rights and autonomy is a delicate balance. Establishing comprehensive legal frameworks that are enforceable and adaptable tp evolving practices can be challenging. The lack of law enforcement also causes a problem. The demand for organs far exceeds the supply, creating a lucrative black market. Economic disparities and poverty can make individuals vulnerable to exploitation. It demands sustained efforts and collaboration among governments, organizations, and society to effectively combat organ trafficking and promote ethical organ donation practices.
●
How can the problem be solved?
Addressing the problem of selling organs requires a multifaceted approach that combines legal, regulatory, enforcement, education, and socio-economic measures.
●
What are the benefits and costs related to your solution?
Organ Shortage: Shifting towards a system based soley on altruistic organ donation may lead to a
decrease in the available organ supply, as it relies on individual willingness to donate. This could
potentially result in longer waiting times and limited access to organ transplantation for those in need. Some argue that introducing financial incentatives for organ donation, even within a regulated system, may raise ethical concerns. Establishing and maintaining a regulated organ donation system requires significant administrative infrastructure, including monitoring, evaluation, and oversight. This can incur additional costs and logistical challenges.
Counter-arguments: Introduction:
a. Begin by acknowledging the skepticism and the importance of considering different perspectives.
b. State the problem concisely: The unethical sale of organs and the associated issues of exploitation, criminal activity, and inequities.
Establish the need for action: a. Present compelling statistics and facts about the prevalence and consequences of organ trafficking and the detrimental impact on vulnerable individuals and healthcare systems.
b. Emphasize the urgency of addressing the problem by highlighting the ethical implications and the need to protect human rights.
Address Ethical Concerns:
a. Acknowledge the ethical concerns related to commodification of human body and potential exploitation of vulnerable individuals.
b. Argue that implementing a regulated system can mitigate these concerns by ensuring transparency, fairness, and informed consent.
c. Highlight the importance of protecting the dignity and autonomy of both donors and recipients through an ethical organ procurement process.
Highlight Benefits:
a. Emphasize the benefits of a regulated organ donation system, such as increased availability of organs, reduced waiting times, reduced waiting times, and improved patient outcomes.
b. Address Organ Shortage Concerns
c. Discuss Regulatory Measures
Conclusion:
a. Summarize the main points presented in the proposal, emphasizing the ethical imperative, the benefits of a regulated system, and the potential to save lives and the potential to save and protect vulnerable individuals.
ENG_106 Grand Canyon University
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help