AF-6466.edited
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
IoBM *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1015
Subject
Communications
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
12
Uploaded by DeanWorldSandpiper26
Topic: Participatory Culture in the Digital Age: An Analysis of Social Media
Student name Date
Participatory Culture in the Digital Age: An Analysis of Social Media
Introduction
The increase of social media platforms and the rise of the internet have fundamentally altered the
relationship between the news media and the general public. This revolutionary change has
sparked a lively discussion among academics, which has led to the investigation of a new
theoretical framework known as "participatory culture." According to Jenkin's (2011) definition,
"participatory culture" occurs when consumers actively participate in creating and shaping media
rather than simply consuming it. This change has far-reaching effects on how popular culture is
made, consumed, and experienced.
Jenkins (2009) defines culture as "participatory" when there are few constraints on people
expressing themselves creatively or getting involved in their communities, when people are
encouraged to share what they make, and when there is a degree of informal mentoring. The
proliferation of user-generated content on sites like YouTube, Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok has
helped this culture. These shifts have sparked discussions about the media's changing function,
its impact on cultural norms, and the opportunities and threats it poses to different communities
and individuals.
This investigation aims to examine how the changing dynamics of social media have affected
popular culture by delving into the academic discourse surrounding participatory culture in this
setting. The article will cite numerous scholarly works that provide critical insights into the topic,
illumining how the media's relationship with pop culture has evolved in the digital era (Jenkins,
2011). The following critical summaries provide comprehensive coverage of this dynamic and
cutting-edge area of study, which provides in-depth analyses of these perspectives.
Media Education in a Participatory Culture: Navigating the Digital Landscape
Jenkins, H., 2009. Confronting the challenges of participatory culture: Media education for
the 21st century (p. 145). The MIT Press.
This article reviews Henry Jenkins's seminal work "Confronting the Challenges of Participatory
Culture: Media Education for the 21st Century," in which he explores the dynamic landscape of
today's media landscape (Jenkins, 2009). Jenkins notes the development of a 'participatory
culture,' a social phenomenon made possible by the widespread use of digital and social media in
which viewers and listeners are no longer merely observers but rather active contributors and
participants in creating and disseminating content. Jenkins emphasises how this shift has
significantly impacted classroom instruction of media literacy. As the digital realm develops into
a more interactive one, the ability to read, write, use, understand, and create meaning from digital
media is becoming increasingly important. As a result, it is important to develop talents like
multitasking, media literacy, relationship building, and negotiation (Jenkins, 2007). A shift from
a focus on the teacher to one on the learner will be required as media literacy grows in
importance.
Moving toward a more participatory culture has many advantages, such as increased access to
information and more chances for creative collaboration, but also presents new challenges, as
Jenkins (2007) argues. Examples of such issues include the digital divide, the participation gap,
the transparency problem, and the ethics challenge. The digital divide describes the gaps in
people's access to digital technology, while the participation gap describes the gaps in people's
knowledge of and experience with the digital world. The ethics dilemma stresses the importance
of informing users of the moral weight of their online actions. The transparency issue, on the
other hand, draws attention to the fact that users have a hard time gauging how their actions
might be affected.
Jenkins proposes rethinking media education to accommodate these problems. He promotes an
approach that does more than teach people how to use technology; it also teaches them how to
think critically about the media they consume, what impact their actions might have on society,
and how to engage positively with the digital world (Storey et al., 2016). Jenkins argues that
media literacy classes should help students recognise the two-way street between the media and
their minds and identities. In addition, Jenkins believes that media education must change to
reflect the dynamic nature of the media industry (Manca, 2018). For young people to fully
participate in the new media landscape, we must help them develop a deeper appreciation for the
new cultural competencies and social skills they will need. Increasing media literacy calls for a
concerted effort by educational institutions, families, and neighbourhoods.
Overall, Jenkins's research contributes importantly to the conversation about media literacy
education in the context of participatory culture (Jenkins, 2009). It provides a nuanced, critical,
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
and future-focused perspective on media education in light of the opportunities and challenges of
the digital age. For educators, policymakers, and anyone else trying to make sense of the
complexities of 21st-century education, Jenkins's insights are indispensable.
Understanding Youth Engagement with New Media
Ito, M., 2013. Hanging out, messing around, and geeking out: Kids living and learning with
new media (p. 440). The MIT Press.
Mizuko Ito's extensive study, "Hanging Out, Messing Around, and Geeking Out: Kids Living
and Learning with New Media," delves deeply into the ways that young people engage with
digital media and how this interaction affects their education (Ito, 2013). In his research, Ito
explores the nuances of online participation, providing a nuanced understanding of how young
people's digital practices intersect with their learning experiences inside and outside the
classroom.
The three ways Ito classifies the ways in which young people interact with digital media
—"hanging out," "messing around," and "geeking out"—provide the inspiration for the title of
her book. To "hang out" online is to socialise with friends and acquaintances, to "mess around"
with new technologies is to experiment with them, and to "geek out" is to immerse oneself in the
study of a niche interest thanks to the wealth of information available online (Lange, 2016).
It argues that these forms of youth engagement with online media facilitate "interest-driven"
learning, in which students can follow their passions and find like-minded peers. Young people
can participate in these events to build confidence, learn new skills, and broaden their horizons
(Harlan et al., 2014). This style of education often outperforms more traditional classroom
settings, which may not adequately address students' unique needs or encourage group projects.
The potential for this type of digital learning to diverge from the norms of more conventional
educational systems is something that Ito highlights as well. She argues that traditional
education's standardised, curriculum-based, and individual-oriented framework frequently
conflicts with the non-formal, peer-based, and interest-driven learning made possible by digital
media. As a result of this tension, the educational value of digital media may need to be noticed
or understood.
Moreover, Ito's work emphasises the importance of adults, mentors, and peers in shaping young
people's experiences with digital media. Ito notes that caring adults can be pivotal in directing
and enhancing young people's interactions with technology (Knobel and Lankshear, 2015). They
have the power to make sure that time spent online is productive and beneficial rather than
harmful or distracting.
Ito's research stresses the value of realising and capitalising on the educational potential of time
spent with digital media. Her findings call for rethinking established educational models and
including computer and Internet literacy and competence in school curricula (Ito, 2013). Ito's
study is a must-read for anyone concerned about the future of education because of the
importance of his argument in the modern digital age. Her research raises important concerns
about how we can create classroom settings that adapt to and thrive in today’s rapidly changing
digital landscape.
In "Hanging Out, Messing Around, and Geeking Out," Ito explains how young people use digital
media to connect with their education. Her research offers crucial insights for educators, parents,
policymakers, and anyone interested in shaping the future of learning in the digital age by
providing a balanced perspective on the opportunities and challenges youth engagement with
digital media presents.
The Evolution and Impact of Social Media: Tracing the Culture of Connectivity
Van Dijck, J., 2013. The culture of connectivity: A critical history of social media. Oxford
University Press.
Author José van Dijck provides a deep historical overview of the development and impact of
social media platforms in her book; The Culture of Connectivity: A Critical History of Social
Media, focusing on how these tools have fostered a new "culture of connectivity (Van Dijck,
2013). The social and cultural implications of the participatory culture fostered by social media
are explored in depth by van Dijck's work. Van Dijck explores how social media giants like
Facebook, Twitter, Flickr, YouTube, and LinkedIn have developed over time and how this
change has affected communication, self-expression, and knowledge sharing. According to her,
the widespread adoption of such media has had far-reaching effects on every aspect of society,
from personal interactions to government and the arts.
She created the term "platformed sociality" to describe the new order of interpersonal
relationships that have emerged due to the proliferation of online social networking sites.
According to Van Dijck (2013)., these mediums do double duty as social behaviour facilitators
and regulators (Pachucki and Breiger, 2010). They create a framework of rules that direct and
limit user interaction while simultaneously providing unprecedented opportunities for user
connectivity and participation.
The conflict between openness and commercialization is central to van Dijck's oeuvre. She
claims that the original ideals of social media—democratic sharing and open communication—
have given way to the monetization of the platforms. The economic motivations behind these
platforms have far-reaching effects, including privacy, data security, and the potential
manipulation of user behaviour. In particular, van Dijck focuses on the problem of data privacy
(Helmond and van der Vlist, 2019). She argues that users do not give much thought to how the
platform owners use their data while they are chatting with their friends. She expresses concern
over the rise of surveillance capitalism,' in which personal information is routinely sold off to
corporations.
Van Dijck also delves into how social media platforms' internal power structures work. Although
it may seem like anyone can create and share content online, she notes that control of the most
popular sites still rests with a small number of tech giants (Lizardo, 2006). There is a pressing
need for effective regulation of social media in light of this concentration of power, which has
prompted legitimate concerns about the impact these companies have on public discourse. "The
Culture of Connectivity" offers an in-depth and critical examination of the evolution of social
media and its effects on society. By shedding light on issues like data privacy,
commercialization, and power dynamics, Van Dijck's work helps to illuminate the complexities
of the social media landscape. Her research provides important new perspectives for academics,
policymakers, and social media users on the participatory culture of the digital age.
Networked Teens: Unraveling the Complexities of Digital Social Lives
Boyd, D., 2014. It is not very easy: The social lives of networked teens. Yale University
Press
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
In her book "It is Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens," danah Boyd sets out on
an interesting journey into the world of teenagers and their use of technology. According to Boyd
(2014), the work is a significant contribution because it synthesizes a large body of research
based on in-depth interviews with teenagers across the United States and provides a foundation
for understanding youth engagement with digital media.
Boyd argues that adolescents' online behaviour continues and reflects their real-world social
lives. She argues that teens' digital practices are intrinsically entwined with their everyday life
experiences, relationships, and identities, and she challenges the widely held belief that digital
media is reprogramming teenagers (Merchant, 2012). The complexity of adolescents' online lives
is reflected in how Boyd organizes his work around central themes. Some topics covered are
identity, privacy, addiction, risk, bullying, inequality, and literacy. Boyd adds complexity to these
discussions, which too often paint an oversimplified picture of young people's use of digital
media.
'Networked publics' is a central idea in Boyd's research. She argues that young people can find
new public spaces for communication and self-expression on social media websites. However,
the dynamics of these networked publics present new challenges for privacy and identity
management because they are both more visible and more persistent than conventional public
spaces. Although more people have access to technology than ever before, significant gaps still
need to be in people's ability to effectively utilize that access (Robards and Lincoln, 2016). This
phenomenon is known as the "digital divide," which Boyd specifically addresses. She stresses
the significance of incorporating critical thinking and ethical interaction with digital media into
digital literacy programs.
She helps us remember that the online world is just an extension of the real-world social
environment teenagers have always had to master. The digital age introduces different kinds of
social spaces, each with advantages and disadvantages (Boyd, 2014). Therefore, teachers,
parents, and policymakers must comprehend these dynamics to cultivate a secure and beneficial
online setting. Her ideas spark a debate about our responsibilities as a society in the age of
constant online access.
Boyd also critically analyses the conversation surrounding cyberbullying and online predators.
She acknowledges the validity of these worries but says they are frequently misplaced and
overstated. She urges taking into account not only the dangers but also the benefits of online
participation. "It is Complicated" is an interesting read because it provides a sympathetic and
perceptive analysis of teens' use of digital media. Boyd successfully debunks many myths about
today's adolescents' digital lives, arguing for a more nuanced understanding that considers the
complexities of these teens' lives. Educators, parents, policymakers, and anyone interested in
understanding youth engagement in the digital age should read her work because it emphasizes
the need to engage with teenagers' digital practices in a supportive, respectful, and informed
manner.
YouTube and Its Role in Shaping Participatory Culture
Burgess, J. and Green, J., 2018. YouTube: Online video and participatory culture. John
Wiley & Sons.
Jean Burgess and Joshua Green delve into the phenomenon of YouTube in their book "YouTube:
Online Video and Participatory Culture," where they analyze the site's central role in spreading
participatory digital culture (Burgess and Green, 2018). YouTube has had a revolutionary effect
on the media landscape, and Burgess and Green explain how the platform works from the
perspectives of community building, content creation, and consumption. The authors investigate
YouTube's role as a venue for user-created content and a for-profit media outlet. They emphasize
how YouTube has helped to democratize content creation by giving regular people the tools they
need to make their videos (Briciu and Briciu, 2020). They also note that the site is a for-profit
media outlet with editorial and advertising content. This conflict between amateur and expert
content creators is central to Burgess and Green's canon.
The idea of "viral videos" is a primary lens through which they view the phenomenon. The
authors analyze the dynamics of virality, probing the factors that lead to a video going viral.
Although they acknowledge that virality can help bring attention to unprofessional work, they
argue that it is often manipulated for commercial or political gain. Burgess and Green also
discuss YouTube's function as a social media hub (Androutsopoulos, 2013). They investigate
how YouTube encourages users to bond over shared passions, content creation, and discussion.
However, they also talk about how the platform's design, which prioritises content sharing over
conversation, prevents it from fostering in-depth social interactions. The authors also look at how
YouTube has affected established forms of media. They claim that YouTube has changed the
broadcasting industry by providing a new platform where specialised programming can reach an
audience. They also discuss how the platform has affected other parts of pop culture, like
comedy and fashion.
As Burgess and Green point out, YouTube is more than just a technological platform; it is also a
cultural phenomenon. By highlighting the transformative potential and challenges of such
platforms, their analysis of YouTube significantly contributes to the discourse surrounding digital
participatory culture (Burgess and Green, 2018). The significance of using these digital platforms
in our increasingly interconnected societies begs serious consideration.
Burgess and Green examine the moral and ethical challenges YouTube presents, including
copyright infringement and personal data security issues. They talk about how difficult it is for
YouTube to balance user autonomy, adherence to the law, and the safeguarding of intellectual
property. This debate highlights the difficulties of regulating a medium that features both user-
and professionally-created content (Burgess and Green, 2018). YouTube is a cultural
phenomenon, and "YouTube: Online Video and Participatory Culture" analyses it in depth.
YouTube's dual role as a platform for user-generated content and commercial media, its influence
on popular culture, and the challenges it presents in terms of legal and ethical issues are all shed
light on in Burgess and Green's work. Scholars and anyone curious about the state of digital
participatory culture should read their analysis because of the valuable insights it provides into
the dynamics of online video consumption and production.
Conclusion After considering the wide variety of perspectives on participatory culture in the digital age, it is
clear that this phenomenon is multi-faceted and complex, marked by a nuanced interplay
between the social, cultural, and technological spheres. All of these works provide a deep
understanding of the ways digital media are shaping our individual and collective experiences,
from Jenkins' examination of the difficulties and possibilities of participatory culture to Ito's
nuanced understanding of youth digital practices to Boyd's investigation of the complexities of
teenagers' digital social lives. The power dynamics, commercial interests, and data privacy
concerns that underpin social media platforms are made more transparent by Van Dijck's critical
examination of the culture of connectivity. Online video-sharing platforms like YouTube have
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
disrupted established media in a similar way to how Burgess and Green disentangle the conflicts
between user-generated and commercial content.
However, there is a consistent theme throughout the sources, and that is the critical challenges
and enormous transformative potential of digital media. It has been analysed digital media and
urged us to engage with it critically, question our interactions with it, and consider taking
advantage of its benefits while minimising its risks. These findings do not give us final answers
but a conceptual framework to inquire about and find our way around the digital world.
Remember that your participation in the digital space shapes the participatory culture you
inhabit, shaping people to continue to learn, connect, and create within it. It is a conversation that
is open, evolving, and full of possibilities. Its complexity is also what makes it so attractive. It
encourages us to actively shape the future of the digital age by thinking critically and creatively
about it now.
Bibliography Androutsopoulos, J. 2013. Participatory Culture And Metalinguistic Discourse: Performing And
Negotiating German Dialects On Youtube. Discourse,
2
,
47-71.
Boyd, D. 2014. It Is Difficult: The Social Lives Of Networked Teens
, Yale University Press.
Briciu, A. & Briciu, V.-A. Participatory Culture And Tourist Experience: Promoting Destinations
Through Youtube. Strategic Innovative Marketing And Tourism: 8th Icsimat, Northern
Aegean, Greece, 2019, 2020. Springer, 425-433.
Burgess, J. & Green, J. 2018. Youtube: Online Video And Participatory Culture
, John Wiley &
Sons.
Harlan, M. A., Bruce, C. & Lupton, M. 2014. Creating And Sharing: Teens' Information
Practices In Digital Communities. Information Research,
19.
Helmond, A. & Van Der Vlist, F. N. 2019. Social Media And Platform Historiography:
Challenges And Opportunities. Tmg–Journal For Media History,
22.
Ito, M. 2013. Hanging Out, Messing Around, And Geeking Out: Kids Living And Learning With
New Media
, The Mit Press.
Jenkins, H. 2007. Confronting The Challenges Of Participatory Culture: Media Education For
The 21st Century (Part One). Nordic Journal Of Digital Literacy,
2
,
23-33.
Jenkins, H. 2009. Confronting The Challenges Of Participatory Culture: Media Education For
The 21st Century
, The Mit Press.
Jenkins, H. 2011. Convergence Culture. Where Old And New Media Collide. Revista Austral De
Ciencias Sociales,
20
,
129-133.
Knobel, M. & Lankshear, C. 2015. Digital Media And Literacy Development. The Routledge
Handbook Of Language And Digital Communication.
Routledge.
Lange, P. G. 2016. Kids On Youtube: Technical Identities And Digital Literacies
, Routledge.
Lizardo, O. 2006. How Cultural Tastes Shape Personal Networks. American Sociological
Review,
71
,
778-807.
Manca, S. 2018. Social Network Sites In Formal And Informal Learning: Potentials And
Challenges For Participatory Culture. Rime. Rivista Dell'istituto Di Storia Dell'europa
Mediterranea (Issn 2035-794x)
,
77‐88-77‐88.
Merchant, G. 2012. Unravelling The Social Network: Theory And Research. Learning, Media
And Technology,
37
,
4-19.
Pachucki, M. A. & Breiger, R. L. 2010. Cultural Holes: Beyond Relationality In Social Networks
And Culture. Annual Review Of Sociology,
36
,
205-224.
Robards, B. & Lincoln, S. 2016. Making It “Facebook Official”: Reflecting On Romantic
Relationships Through Sustained Facebook Use.
Social Media+ Society,
2
,
2056305116672890.
Storey, M.-A., Zagalsky, A., Figueira Filho, F., Singer, L. & German, D. M. 2016. How Social
And Communication Channels Shape And Challenge A Participatory Culture In Software
Development. Ieee Transactions On Software Engineering,
43
,
185-204.
Van Dijk, J. 2013. The Culture Of Connectivity: A Critical History Of Social Media
, Oxford
University Press.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help