Which of the alternatives is preferable.
Answer to Problem 100P
The option to be selected is Solar Collector Field, since it results in a higher overall
Explanation of Solution
Given information:
Installation Cost:
Flat Solar Panels$87 Million
Mechanized Solar Panels $101 Million
Solar Collector Field $91 Million
Annual Operation and Maintenance costs (year 1):
Flat Solar Panels $2 Million
Mechanized Solar Panels $2.3 Million
Solar Collector Field $3 Million
Increase in Annual Operation and Maintenance costs (year 2 onwards):
Flat Solar Panels $250,000
Mechanized Solar Panels $300,000
Solar Collector Field $350,000
Annual Revenues in the form of Electricity
Flat Solar Panels $6.9 Million
Mechanized Solar Panels $8.8 Million
Solar Collector Field $9.7 Million
Annual Increase in Revenues:
Flat Solar Panels8%
Mechanized Solar Panels 8%
Solar Collector Field 8%
Useful Life: 20 Years
Rate of Interest for calculation: 10%.
Based on the above information, the following tables outlines the
Flat Solar Panels:
Year | Cash Flows | Cash Inflows | Cash Flows | Net Cash Flows | P.V. @10% | Amount | |
0 | Electricity Benefits | $ - | Initial Cost | $ 87,000,000.00 | $ (87,000,000.00) | 1 | $ (87,000,000.00) |
1 | Electricity Benefits | $6,900,000.00 | Operating Costs | $ 2,000,000.00 | $ 4,900,000.00 | 0.9091 | $ 4,454,590.00 |
2 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $7,452,000.00 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 2,250,000.00 | $ 5,202,000.00 | 0.8264 | $ 4,298,932.80 |
3 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $8,048,160.00 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 2,500,000.00 | $ 5,548,160.00 | 0.7513 | $ 4,168,332.61 |
4 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $8,692,012.80 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 2,750,000.00 | $ 5,942,012.80 | 0.683 | $ 4,058,394.74 |
5 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $9,387,373.82 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,000,000.00 | $ 6,387,373.82 | 0.6209 | $ 3,965,920.41 |
6 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 10,138,363.73 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,250,000.00 | $ 6,888,363.73 | 0.5645 | $ 3,888,481.33 |
7 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 10,949,432.83 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,500,000.00 | $ 7,449,432.83 | 0.5132 | $ 3,823,048.93 |
8 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 11,825,387.45 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,750,000.00 | $ 8,075,387.45 | 0.4665 | $ 3,767,168.25 |
9 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 12,771,418.45 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,000,000.00 | $ 8,771,418.45 | 0.4241 | $ 3,719,958.57 |
10 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 13,793,131.93 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,250,000.00 | $ 9,543,131.93 | 0.3855 | $ 3,678,877.36 |
11 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 14,896,582.48 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,500,000.00 | $ 10,396,582.48 | 0.3505 | $ 3,644,002.16 |
12 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 16,088,309.08 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,750,000.00 | $ 11,338,309.08 | 0.3186 | $ 3,612,385.27 |
13 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 17,375,373.81 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,000,000.00 | $ 12,375,373.81 | 0.2897 | $ 3,585,145.79 |
14 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 18,765,403.71 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,250,000.00 | $ 13,515,403.71 | 0.2633 | $ 3,558,605.80 |
15 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 20,266,636.01 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,500,000.00 | $ 14,766,636.01 | 0.2394 | $ 3,535,132.66 |
16 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 21,887,966.89 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,750,000.00 | $ 16,137,966.89 | 0.2176 | $ 3,511,621.59 |
17 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 23,639,004.24 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,000,000.00 | $ 17,639,004.24 | 0.1978 | $ 3,488,995.04 |
18 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 25,530,124.58 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,250,000.00 | $ 19,280,124.58 | 0.1799 | $ 3,468,494.41 |
19 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 27,572,534.54 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,500,000.00 | $ 21,072,534.54 | 0.1635 | $ 3,445,359.40 |
20 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 29,778,337.31 | Operating Costs($250,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,750,000.00 | $ 23,028,337.31 | 0.1486 | $ 3,422,010.92 |
Net Present Value | $ (11,904,541.97) |
Mechanized Solar Panels:
Year | Cash Flows | Cash Inflows | Cash Flows | Cash Outflows | Net Cash Flows | P.V. @10% | Amount |
0 | Electricity Benefits | $ - | Initial Cost | $ 101,000,000.00 | $ (101,000,000.00) | 1 | $ (101,000,000.00) |
1 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 8,800,000.00 | Operating Costs | $ 2,300,000.00 | $ 6,500,000.00 | 0.9091 | $ 5,909,150.00 |
2 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 9,504,000.00 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 2,600,000.00 | $ 6,904,000.00 | 0.8264 | $ 5,705,465.60 |
3 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 10,264,320.00 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 2,900,000.00 | $ 7,364,320.00 | 0.7513 | $ 5,532,813.62 |
4 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 11,085,465.60 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,200,000.00 | $ 7,885,465.60 | 0.683 | $ 5,385,773.00 |
5 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 11,972,302.85 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,500,000.00 | $ 8,472,302.85 | 0.6209 | $ 5,260,452.84 |
6 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 12,930,087.08 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,800,000.00 | $ 9,130,087.08 | 0.5645 | $ 5,153,934.15 |
7 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 13,964,494.04 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,100,000.00 | $ 9,864,494.04 | 0.5132 | $ 5,062,458.34 |
8 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 15,081,653.57 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,400,000.00 | $ 10,681,653.57 | 0.4665 | $ 4,982,991.39 |
9 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 16,288,185.85 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,700,000.00 | $ 11,588,185.85 | 0.4241 | $ 4,914,549.62 |
10 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 17,591,240.72 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,000,000.00 | $ 12,591,240.72 | 0.3855 | $ 4,853,923.30 |
11 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 18,998,539.98 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,300,000.00 | $ 13,698,539.98 | 0.3505 | $ 4,801,338.26 |
12 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 20,518,423.17 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,600,000.00 | $ 14,918,423.17 | 0.3186 | $ 4,753,009.62 |
13 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 22,159,897.03 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,900,000.00 | $ 16,259,897.03 | 0.2897 | $ 4,710,492.17 |
14 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 23,932,688.79 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,200,000.00 | $ 17,732,688.79 | 0.2633 | $ 4,669,016.96 |
15 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 25,847,303.89 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,500,000.00 | $ 19,347,303.89 | 0.2394 | $ 4,631,744.55 |
16 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 27,915,088.20 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,800,000.00 | $ 21,115,088.20 | 0.2176 | $ 4,594,643.19 |
17 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 30,148,295.26 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,100,000.00 | $ 23,048,295.26 | 0.1978 | $ 4,558,952.80 |
18 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 32,560,158.88 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,400,000.00 | $ 25,160,158.88 | 0.1799 | $ 4,526,312.58 |
19 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 35,164,971.59 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,700,000.00 | $ 27,464,971.59 | 0.1635 | $ 4,490,522.86 |
20 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 37,978,169.32 | Operating Costs($300,000 higher than previous year) | $ 8,000,000.00 | $ 29,978,169.32 | 0.1486 | $ 4,454,755.96 |
Net Present Value | $ (2,047,699.18) |
Solar Collector Field:
Year | Cash Flows | Cash Inflows | Cash Flows | Cash Outflows | Net Cash Flows | P.V. @10% | Amount |
0 | Electricity Benefits | $ - | Initial Cost | $ 91,000,000.00 | $ (91,000,000.00) | 1 | $ (91,000,000.00) |
1 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 9,700,000.00 | Operating Costs | $ 3,000,000.00 | $ 6,700,000.00 | 0.9091 | $ 6,090,970.00 |
2 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 10,476,000.00 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,350,000.00 | $ 7,126,000.00 | 0.8264 | $ 5,888,926.40 |
3 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 11,314,080.00 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 3,700,000.00 | $ 7,614,080.00 | 0.7513 | $ 5,720,458.30 |
4 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 12,219,206.40 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,050,000.00 | $ 8,169,206.40 | 0.683 | $ 5,579,567.97 |
5 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 13,196,742.91 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,400,000.00 | $ 8,796,742.91 | 0.6209 | $ 5,461,897.67 |
6 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 14,252,482.34 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 4,750,000.00 | $ 9,502,482.34 | 0.5645 | $ 5,364,151.28 |
7 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 15,392,680.93 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,100,000.00 | $ 10,292,680.93 | 0.5132 | $ 5,282,203.85 |
8 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 16,624,095.41 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,450,000.00 | $ 11,174,095.41 | 0.4665 | $ 5,212,715.51 |
9 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 17,954,023.04 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 5,800,000.00 | $ 12,154,023.04 | 0.4241 | $ 5,154,521.17 |
10 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 19,390,344.88 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,150,000.00 | $ 13,240,344.88 | 0.3855 | $ 5,104,152.95 |
11 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 20,941,572.47 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,500,000.00 | $ 14,441,572.47 | 0.3505 | $ 5,061,771.15 |
12 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 22,616,898.27 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 6,850,000.00 | $ 15,766,898.27 | 0.3186 | $ 5,023,333.79 |
13 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 24,426,250.13 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,200,000.00 | $ 17,226,250.13 | 0.2897 | $ 4,990,444.66 |
14 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 26,380,350.14 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,550,000.00 | $ 18,830,350.14 | 0.2633 | $ 4,958,031.19 |
15 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 28,490,778.16 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 7,900,000.00 | $ 20,590,778.16 | 0.2394 | $ 4,929,432.29 |
16 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 30,770,040.41 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 8,250,000.00 | $ 22,520,040.41 | 0.2176 | $ 4,900,360.79 |
17 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 33,231,643.64 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 8,600,000.00 | $ 24,631,643.64 | 0.1978 | $ 4,872,139.11 |
18 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 35,890,175.13 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 8,950,000.00 | $ 26,940,175.13 | 0.1799 | $ 4,846,537.51 |
19 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 38,761,389.14 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 9,300,000.00 | $ 29,461,389.14 | 0.1635 | $ 4,816,937.12 |
20 | Electricity Benefits (8% higher than last year) | $ 41,862,300.27 | Operating Costs($350,000 higher than previous year) | $ 9,650,000.00 | $ 32,212,300.27 | 0.1486 | $ 4,786,747.82 |
Net Present Value | $ 13,045,300.56 |
Net present value is the difference of Sum of Present values of cash inflows and Sum of Present values of cash outflows. If the value is positive then the project may be accepted. While evaluation of two or more alternatives takes place, then the proposal with the higher net present value may be selected since it results in a greater cash inflow over the duration of the project.
In the given scenario, Present values are calculated by calculating the present values of cash inflows in the form of revenues in the form of electricity and cash outflows such as installation cost and operating cost.
Installation Costs in case of Flat Solar Panels are $87 Million, Mechanized Solar Panels + $101 Million and Solar Collector Field + $91 Million.
Annual Operation and Maintenance costs for year 1, in case of Flat Solar Panels+ $2 Million, Mechanized Solar Panels + $2.3 Million and Solar Collector Field + $3 Million.
Increase Annual Operation and Maintenance costs year 2 onwardsin case ofFlat Solar Panels+ $250,000, Mechanized Solar Panels + $300,000 and Solar Collector Field + $350,000.
Annual Revenues in the form of Electricity in case of Flat Solar Panels + $6.9Million, Mechanized Solar Panels + $8.8 Million and Solar Collector Field + $9.7 Million
Annual Increase in Revenues is 8% in case of all alternatives and the Useful Life is 20 Years. Rate of Interest for calculation is considered as 10%
Present value factor is calculated as 1/1.10 ^ N where N is the year of operation.
Conclusion:
Hence the option to be selected is Flat Solar Panels since it results in higher overall cash flow for a period of 20 years.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 5 Solutions
ENGR.ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
- Which of the following is true about the concept of concentration? Group of answer choices The lower the degree of rivalry amongst the firms, the higher the concentration. The lower the number of firms in a market, the lower the concentration. All of the answers are correct. The higher the degree of rivalry amongst the firms, the lower the concentrationarrow_forward↑ Quiz x Chat × | Use ☑ Micr ☑ Price × b Ans × b Suco × b Anst ✓ Pow × 1.6: ✓ ECO ☑ #26 ☑ #27 ✓ #28 ✓ -0 -0 setonhall.instructure.com/courses/30968/quizzes/52774/take/questions/1035198 Question 15 2 pts Use the information contained in the graph below describing a firm operating in a competitive environment to answer the following question. If the graph described a firm that decides to produce, what would be the value of its profit, its deficit, or would it break even? $7 385 $8 $4 4 120 150 30 50 50 None of the answers are correct. #29 × N. price × | + ☆ ☑ B Relaunch to update :arrow_forward↑ Quiz: F X . ChatG × G Use th × b Answe × b Answe ☑ Micros ☑ Power × 1.6: A ☑ ECON ✓ #26 - X #27 - X #28 - X #29 - × G is mr c ×+ -o -0 setonhall.instructure.com/courses/30968/quizzes/52774/take/questions/1035213 Q ☆ B Relaunch to update : Question 9 2 pts Use the information contained in the three graphs below to answer the following question. Which of the three curves represent the MR? (A) (B) $800 $800 $800 $700 $700 $700 $600 $600 $600 $500 $500 $500 67 S S $400 $400 $400 $300 $300 $300 $200 $200 $200 $100 $100 $100 50 50 30 01 01 2 34 01 A None of the curves could be the answer. C B (C)arrow_forward
- Profits will be_________? Group of answer choices High, regardless of the degree of rivalry between competitors. Low, when the degree of rivalry between competitors is low. High, when the degree of rivalry between competitors is high. Low, when the degree of rivalry between competitors is high.arrow_forwardeconomics/epidemologyarrow_forwardnot use ai pleasearrow_forward
- If a firm exits, we must have that P < AVC None of the answers are correct. Two answers are correct. P > AVC P < ATCarrow_forwardNot use ai pleasearrow_forwardQuestion 8 Which of the following is true about the concept of concentration? O All of the answers are correct. O O The lower the number of firms in a market, the lower the concentration. The higher the degree of rivalry amongst the firms, the lower the concentration. The lower the degree of rivalry amongst the firms, the higher the concentration. Previous 2 pts Next ->arrow_forward
- Question 15 Price discrimination is usually defined as selling a product to different customers at The same price as costs of service are the same. Different prices even though costs of service are the same. The same price even though costs of service are different. Different prices as costs of service are different. ? 2 pts ◄ Previous Next -arrow_forwardQuestion 22 2 pts Use the information contained in the three graphs below to answer the following question. Which of the three curves could display an efficiency scale? (A) 5800 $700 5600 $500 (B) $800 $700 (C) ccc $400 $300 $200 $300 $200 $100 $100 $400 $300 $300 $100 1 $800 $700 S $600 A None of the curves could be the answer. B C ◄ Previous Next ->arrow_forwardUse the information contained in the graph below to answer the following question. Which of the curves could represent marginal costs? O A C B O None of the curves could be the answer. B ◄ Previous Next ▸arrow_forward
- Principles of Economics (12th Edition)EconomicsISBN:9780134078779Author:Karl E. Case, Ray C. Fair, Sharon E. OsterPublisher:PEARSONEngineering Economy (17th Edition)EconomicsISBN:9780134870069Author:William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, C. Patrick KoellingPublisher:PEARSON
- Principles of Economics (MindTap Course List)EconomicsISBN:9781305585126Author:N. Gregory MankiwPublisher:Cengage LearningManagerial Economics: A Problem Solving ApproachEconomicsISBN:9781337106665Author:Luke M. Froeb, Brian T. McCann, Michael R. Ward, Mike ShorPublisher:Cengage LearningManagerial Economics & Business Strategy (Mcgraw-...EconomicsISBN:9781259290619Author:Michael Baye, Jeff PrincePublisher:McGraw-Hill Education