The preference of one alternative out of the three based on economic criteria by using the present worth, equivalent annual cost, benefit-cost ratio and rate of return methods.

Question

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Answer 1

Question

100%

Chapter 13, Problem 14P

To determine

The preference of one alternative out of the three based on economic criteria by using the present worth, equivalent annual cost, benefit-cost ratio and rate of return methods.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 14P

Alternative 3- Intersection widening

Explanation of Solution

Given:

Analysis period = 20 years

Annual interest rate = 15 percent

Traffic And Highway Engineering, Chapter 13, Problem 14P

Calculation:

Determine the present worth of alternative 1 (Traffic signals):

PW1=−340,000−(10,000+450,000)(P/A−15−20)+25,000(P/F−15−20)(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26(P/F−15−20)=1 ( 1+i )n=1 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=0.0611PW1=−340,000−(10,000+450,000)(6.26)+25,000(0.0611) =$−3218072.50

Determine the present worth of alternative 2 (Intersection widening):

PW2=−850,000−(5,000+300,000)(P/A−15−20)+12,000(P/F−15−20)(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26(P/F−15−20)=1 ( 1+i )n=1 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=0.0611PW2=−850,000−(5,000+300,000)(6.26)+12,000(0.0611) =$−2758566.80

Determine the present worth of alternative 3 (Grade separation):

PW3=−2,120,000−(5,000+225,000)(P/A−15−20)(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26PW3=−2,120,000−(5,000+225,000)(6.26) =$−3559800

The project with the highest present worth is alternative 2.

Determine the equivalent annual cost of alternative 1 (Traffic signals):

EUAW=NPW[i ( 1+i ) n ( 1+i ) n−1]EUAW1=−3218072.50 [0.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20 ( 1+0.15 ) 20−1]EUAW1=$−514891.60

Determine the equivalent annual cost of alternative 2 (Intersection widening):

EUAW=NPW[i ( 1+i ) n ( 1+i ) n−1]EUAW2=−2758566.80 [0.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20 ( 1+0.15 ) 20−1]EUAW2=$−441370.688

Determine the equivalent annual cost of alternative 3 (Grade separation):

EUAW=NPW[i ( 1+i ) n ( 1+i ) n−1]EUAW3=−3559800 [0.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20 ( 1+0.15 ) 20−1]EUAW3=$−569568

The project with the highest equivalent annual costis alternative 2.

Determine the benefit-cost ratioof alternative 1 (Traffic signals):

BCR1=−( 10,000+450,000)( P/A−15−20)+25,000( P/F−15−20)−340,000(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26(P/F−15−20)=1 ( 1+i )n=1 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=0.0611BCR1=−2878072.5−340,000=8.465

Determine the benefit-cost ratio of alternative 2 (Intersection widening):

BCR2=−( 5,000+300,000)( P/A−15−20)+12,000( P/F−15−20)−850,000(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26(P/F−15−20)=1 ( 1+i )n=1 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=0.0611BCR2=−1908566.8−850,000=2.245>1

Since BCR >1, we would select Alternative 2.

Determine the benefit-cost ratio of alternative 3 (Grade separation):

BCR3=−( 5,000+225,000)( P/A−15−20)−2,120,000(P/A−15−20)= ( 1+i )n−1i ( 1+i )n= ( 1+0.15 ) 20−10.15 ( 1+0.15 ) 20=6.26BCR3=−1439800−2,120,000=0.68<1

Since BCR is less than 1, we would not select Alternative 3

Determine the benefit-cost ratio of alternative 2 with respect to 1:

BCR2−1=1,908,566.8−2,878,072.5850,000−340,000 =1.9

We reachthe same conclusion as previously, which is to select Alternative 2

Determine the rate of return (ROR)of alternative 1versus 2:

NPW=0=(850,000−340,000)−(5,000+150,000)(P/A−i−20)+(25,000−12,000)(P/F−i−20)

It is very difficult to solve this explicitly for i. By trial and error, we can easily find the i that makes the right side of the equation equal to the left side.

510,000=−155,000(P/A−i−20)+13,000(P/F−i−20)

Try i=30 %,

−155,000(P/A−30−20)+13,000(P/F−30−20)=513911.62

For i=31 %

−155,000(P/A−31−20)+13,000(P/F−31−20)=497684.2512

Then, we can try i=30.5 % and by interpolation 30.237 % is the rate of return to make the left side to equal to the right side.

Since ROR is greater than 15 percent, we select Alternative 2

Determine the rate of return (ROR) of alternative 3 versus 1:

NPW=0=(2,120,000−340,000)−(5,000+225,000)(P/A−i−20)+(25,000−0)(P/F−i−20)

By trial and error, we can easily find the i that makes the right side of the equation equal to the left side.

1,780,000=−230,000(P/A−i−20)+25,000(P/F−i−20)

Try i=11 %,

−230,000(P/A−11−20)+25,000(P/F−11−20)=1828464.62

For i=12 %

−230,000(P/A−12−20)+25,000(P/F−12−20)=1715277.50

By interpolation 11.428 % is the rate of return to make the left side to equal to the right side.

Since the ROR is lower than 15 percent, we discard Alternative 3.

Conclusion:

The second alternative i.e. Intersection widening is selected by using the three economic methods.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

Students have asked these similar questions

Please explain step by step and include any formula used

Please explain step by step and include any formular used

please Explain step by step and include any formular used

Answer 2