Economic rents Taxes are a cost, and, therefore, changes in tax rates can affect consumer prices, project lives, and the value of existing firms. The following problem illustrates this. It also illustrates that tax changes that appear to be “good for business” do not always increase the value of existing firms. Indeed, unless new investment incentives increase consumer demand, they can work only by rendering existing equipment obsolete.
The manufacture of bucolic acid is a competitive business. Demand is steadily expanding, and new plants are constantly being opened. Expected cash flows from an investment in a new plant are as follows:
Assumptions:
- 1. Tax depreciation is straight-line over three years.
- 2. Pretax salvage value is 25 in year 3 and 50 if the asset is scrapped in year 2.
- 3. Tax on salvage value is 40% of the difference between salvage value and
depreciated investment. - 4. The cost of capital is 20%.
- a. What is the value of a one-year-old plant? Of a two-year-old plant?
- b. Suppose that the government now changes tax depreciation to allow a 100% writeoff in year 1. How does this affect the value of existing one- and two-year-old plants? Existing plants must continue using the original tax depreciation schedule.
- c. Would it now make sense to scrap existing plants when they are two rather than three years old?
- d. How would your answers change if the corporate income tax were abolished entirely?
a)
To determine: values of one year old plant and two year old plant.
Explanation of Solution
Here, value in the sense, present value.
Calculation of present value of one-year old plant:
Hence, the present value of one-year old plant is $76.62.
Calculation of present value of two-year old plant:
Hence, the present value of two-year old plant is $48.61.
b)
To determine: Effect of government on taxes on one and two year old plant and existing plants should continue using the schedule of original tax depreciation.
Explanation of Solution
Given the industry is competitive, the investments in new plant producing the product must yields zero NPV.
Calculation of Revenues (R) at which the NPV of new plant is zero:
Hence,
By solving this, the value of R= $95.88.
By using the value of R we can calculate the present values of existing one and two years old plants.
Calculation of present value of one and two-year old plants:
Hence, the present value of one-year old plant is $72.84.
Hence, the present value of two-year old plant is $46.55
c)
To determine: Net salvage value of two year old plant.
Explanation of Solution
Calculation of salvage value:
The salvage value is $43.33.
d)
To determine: Values the corporate tax rates are abolished entirely.
Explanation of Solution
Solving for zero NPV:
By using the revenues of $90.60
Calculation of present value of one-year old plant:
Hence, the present value of one-year old plant is $79.40.
Calculation of present value of two-year old plant:
Hence, the present value of two-year old plant is $54.67
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 11 Solutions
Principles of Corporate Finance (Mcgraw-hill/Irwin Series in Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate)
- A paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, in terms of both generating revenues and reducing costs. The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows: Economic profit = Operating profit − Capital charge Assume the following information for a hotel chain that wishes to adopt the new method. The firm has $100 million in operating profit, has $1 billion in investment, and uses a cost of capital rate of 5%, so the capital charge is $50 million and the economic profit is $50 million. Relevant calculations are contained in Part 1 of the following schedule: Part 1: Economic Profit (in thousands, except cost of capital rate) Revenue $…arrow_forwardA paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, both in terms of generating revenues and reducing costs. The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows: Economic profit = Operating profit − Capital charge Assume the following information for a hotel chain that wishes to adopt the new method. The firm has $100 million in operating profit, has $1 billion in investment, and uses a cost of capital rate of 5%, so the capital charge is $50 million and the economic profit is $50 million. Relevant calculations are contained in Part 1 of the following schedule: Part 1: Economic Profit (in thousands, except cost of capital rate)…arrow_forwardA paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, both in terms of generating revenues and reducing costs. The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows: Economic profit = Operating profit − Capital charge Assume the following information for a hotel chain that wishes to adopt the new method. The firm has $100 million in operating profit, has $1 billion in investment, and uses a cost of capital rate of 5%, so the capital charge is $50 million and the economic profit is $50 million. Relevant calculations are contained in Part 1 of the following schedule: Part 1: Economic Profit (in thousands, except cost of capital rate)…arrow_forward
- 1) Which of the following statements describes the force that drives the distribution of resources (goods and services, labor, and money) in a free-enterprise economy? A) Businesses are willing to supply more of a good or service at higher prices because the potential for profits is higher. B) Supply and demand curves intersect at the point where supply and demand are not equal. C) Changing the price of a product does not alter the supply curve. D) The price at which the number of products that businesses are willing to supply is inversely proportional to the amount of products that consumers are willing to buy at a specific point in time. E) Prices for goods and services vary according to the changes in supply and demand. 1)arrow_forwardCompanies have found that offering discounts to customers in return for early payment can be counterproductive in terms of the resulting adverse effect on profitability. This is when the reduction in profitability outweighs any marginal improvements gained from the benefit of a reduction in the working capital requirement. Required: Given the above critically discuss the alternative measures to offering discounts to customers that could prove more effective in reducing the working capital requirement for a company with only minimal potential reductions in profitability.arrow_forwardAssume the government introduces a lump-sum tax on each firm within a perfectly competitive industry. Which of the following will be true after the introduction of this tax? a. Consumer prices will increase b. There will be no change in any firm’s level of profits c. A deadweight efficiency loss will occur d. There will be no change in the market quantity of outputarrow_forward
- Lowering price does not always increase revenue with increased demand. Besides reducing price, what else can a firm do to stimulate demand for its product?arrow_forwardThe market for capital Firms require capital to invest in productive opportunities. The best firms with the most profitable opportunities can attract capital away from inefficient firms with less profitable opportunities. Investors supply firms with capital at a cost called the interest rate. The interest rate that investors require is determined by several factors, including the availability of production opportunities, the time preference for current consumption, risk, and inflation. Suppose the Federal Reserve (the Fed) decides to tighten credit by contracting the money supply. Use the following graph by moving the black X to show what happens to the equilibrium level of borrowing and the new equilibrium interest rate. Q1. Which tend to be more volatile, short- or long-term interest rates? Long-term interest rates 2. Short-term interest rates Q2. If the inflation rate was 3.20% and the nominal interest rate was 4.20% over the last year, what was the real rate of interest over…arrow_forwardMany businesses finance their investment activities internally. Should internal financing affect the efficiency with which the interest rate performs its functions? No, investment is profitable if the expected rate of return is greater than the rate of interest regardless of the source of funds. Yes, investment is profitable if the expected rate of return is greater than the rate of interest regardless of the source of funds. O No, because internal financing relies on a different profit calculation. Yes, because firms are usually more anxious about what happens to money that they do not have to pay back.arrow_forward
- Which of the followings is NOT an advantage of financial institutions in consumption smoothing? A. They help to solve moral hazard and adverse selection issues. B. They help to share risks. C. They help to reduce transaction costs. D. They help to create more jobs.arrow_forwardIf the firm is in a very competitive, mature industry, what effect will the competitive conditions have on residual income for the firm and others in the industry? Now suppose the firm holds a competitive advantage in its industry, but the advantage is not likely to be sustainable for more than a few years. As the firm’s competitive advantage diminishes, what effect will that have on that firm’s residual income? and If a firm’s residual income for a particular year is positive, does that mean the firm was profitable? Explain. If a firm’s residual income for a particular year is negative, does that mean the firm necessarily reported a loss on the income statement? Explain. What does it mean when a firm’s residual income is zero?arrow_forwardVideo Tech Ltd manufactures video game machines. Market saturation and technological innovations have caused pricing pressures that have resulted in declining profits. To stem the slide in profits until new products can be introduced, top management has started to focus on achieving cost savings in manufacturing and increases in sales volume. Sales can be increased only if production volume increases. Therefore, an incentive program has been developed to reward those production managers who contribute to an increase in the number of units produced and achieve cost reductions. In addition, a just-in-time purchasing program has been implemented, and raw materials are purchased on an as-needed basis.The production managers have responded to the pressure to improve manufacturing performance and this has resulted in an increase in the number of completed units over normal production levels. The video game machines are put together by the assembly group, which requires parts from both the…arrow_forward
- Essentials Of InvestmentsFinanceISBN:9781260013924Author:Bodie, Zvi, Kane, Alex, MARCUS, Alan J.Publisher:Mcgraw-hill Education,
- Foundations Of FinanceFinanceISBN:9780134897264Author:KEOWN, Arthur J., Martin, John D., PETTY, J. WilliamPublisher:Pearson,Fundamentals of Financial Management (MindTap Cou...FinanceISBN:9781337395250Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Joel F. HoustonPublisher:Cengage LearningCorporate Finance (The Mcgraw-hill/Irwin Series i...FinanceISBN:9780077861759Author:Stephen A. Ross Franco Modigliani Professor of Financial Economics Professor, Randolph W Westerfield Robert R. Dockson Deans Chair in Bus. Admin., Jeffrey Jaffe, Bradford D Jordan ProfessorPublisher:McGraw-Hill Education