Which of the following objections do Gilmore, Costa, and Calosi mention in their discussion of pointism? a. just as one can be sure of one's own existence merely by noting that one is currently conscious, one can be sure that reality has at least some temporal duration, merely by noting that one's current conscious experience has some temporal duration (it's not instantaneous). b. It has an even worse truthmaker problem than ordinary presentism. c. it cannot make use of reference frames to relativize tense operators, since frames of reference would not exist if only a single spacetime point existed. d. Given the link that connects presentness with absolute availability, pointism entails that if your current experience is absolutely available to you, then no experience that is occurring elsewhere is absolutely available to its owner.
Which of the following objections do Gilmore, Costa, and Calosi mention in their discussion of pointism? a. just as one can be sure of one's own existence merely by noting that one is currently conscious, one can be sure that reality has at least some temporal duration, merely by noting that one's current conscious experience has some temporal duration (it's not instantaneous). b. It has an even worse truthmaker problem than ordinary presentism. c. it cannot make use of reference frames to relativize tense operators, since frames of reference would not exist if only a single spacetime point existed. d. Given the link that connects presentness with absolute availability, pointism entails that if your current experience is absolutely available to you, then no experience that is occurring elsewhere is absolutely available to its owner.
Related questions
Question
Transcribed Image Text:Which of the following objections do Gilmore, Costa, and Calosi mention in their discussion of
pointism?
a. just as one can be sure of one's own existence merely by noting that one is currently conscious, one
can be sure that reality has at least some temporal duration, merely by noting that one's current
conscious experience has some temporal duration (it's not instantaneous).
b. It has an even worse truthmaker problem than ordinary presentism.
c. it cannot make use of reference frames to relativize tense operators, since frames of reference would
not exist if only a single spacetime point existed.
d. Given the link that connects presentness with absolute availability, pointism entails that if your
current experience is absolutely available to you, then no experience that is occurring elsewhere is
absolutely available to its owner.
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps
