The state of Alabama enacted a statute that imposed a tax on premiums earned by insurance companies. The statute imposed a 1 percent tax on domestic insurance companies (i.e., insurance companies that were incorporated in Alabama and had their principal office in the state). The statute imposed a 4 percent tax on the premiums earned by out-of-state insurance companies that sold insurance in Alabama. Out-of-state insurance companies could reduce the premium tax by 1 percent by investing at least 10 percent of their assets in Alabama. Domestic insurance companies did not have to invest any of their assets in Alabama. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, an out-of-state insurance company, sued the state of Alabama, alleging that the Alabama statute violated the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Who wins and why? Explain your answer.

The state of Alabama enacted a statute that imposed a tax on premiums earned by insurance companies. The statute imposed a 1 percent tax on domestic insurance companies (i.e., insurance companies that were incorporated in Alabama and had their principal office in the state). The statute imposed a 4 percent tax on the premiums earned by out-of-state insurance companies that sold insurance in Alabama. Out-of-state insurance companies could reduce the premium tax by 1 percent by investing at least 10 percent of their assets in Alabama. Domestic insurance companies did not have to invest any of their assets in Alabama. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, an out-of-state insurance company, sued the state of Alabama, alleging that the Alabama statute violated the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Who wins and why? Explain your answer.

Similar questions

Explain how the income of corporations is double taxed and what a corporation can do to minimize their tax burden?
Discuss the legal responsibilities and liabilities of directors and officers in a corporation. What fiduciary duties do they owe to the company and its shareholders? What are the potential legal consequences for breaching these duties?
Wiener Haus #82 has been underperforming for a few years. The franchisee (owner of Haus #82) is frustrated and files a claim against the franchisor for breach. The franchisee claims that the agreement he signed contained a statement at the start of the agreement detailing that the business model the franchisor developed was "proven effective and profitable." On these facts, does the franchisee have a winning breach of contract claim against the franchisor? O No, the contract formed was a voidable contract. Thus, the franchisor is void of responsibility if the business model does not produce profit for the franchisee. O Yes, the franchisee relied on these statements when deciding to contract and thus the franchisor should be responsible when the business model fails to work for the franchisee. O No, courts have generally held that the type of language relied upon by the franchisee is "prefatory" and does not create a duty on the part of the franchisor. O Yes, the money paid to the…
Suture Express was a new upstart specializing in the medical supply network by selling only sutures. Owens & Minor was a medical supply distributor that carried all types of medical supplies, including sutures. Owens & Minor began bundling provisions that required its customers to pay a premium for all medical products unless the customer agreed to purchase its sutures. Suture Express brought suit alleging a loss to Owens & Minor through anticompetitive practices. Is this a tying situation that violates federal antitrust laws? Why or why not?
An apartment building in Ithaca, New York with 72 units was financed with a $7.2 million non-recourse first mortgage loan at a 3.6% annual interest rate and an additional $3.6 million fully recourse second mortgage loan at a 7.2% annual interest rate. The owner later borrowed another $720,000 with a fully recourse third mortgage loan at a 10.8% annual interest rate. The borrower ultimately found itself in financial distress and unable to make the monthly mortgage payments on the three outstanding mortgage loans and the property went into foreclosure. What happens to the claims of the second and third mortgage lenders if the foreclosure lawsuit by the first mortgage lender includes all junior mortgage lenders and the property is sold to an unrelated third party for a net price of $6.6 million at the foreclosure sale? a. The mortgage liens of the junior claimants and the loan amounts owed to them are unaffected by the foreclosure sale b. The mortgage liens of the junior claimants are…
What are the criminal penalties incorporated by the Congress for violating the Securities Exchange Act of 1934?
The McDonald Investment Company was a corporation organized and incorporated in the state of Minnesota. The principal and only place of business from which the company conducted operations was Rush City, Minnesota. More than 80 percent of the company’s assets were located in Minnesota, and more than 80 percent of its income was derived from Minnesota. McDonald sold securities to Minnesota residents only. The proceeds from the sale were used entirely to make loans and other investments in real estate and other assets located outside the state of Minnesota. The company did not file a registration statement with the SEC. Does this offering qualify for an intrastate offering exemption from registration? Explain your answer.
Do corporate shareholders have an obligation to make certain that their business corporation acts in an ethical and proper manner in conducting business
Choose the individual who would be eligible for membership in the Florida Real Estate Commission. member of the general public who had a real estate license 15 years ago broker who held an active license for ten ears and has been retired (inactive license) for the past two years active sales associate who got her license one year ago broker who has had an active license for the past five years and is over the age of 65
Hyde is a broker involved in a conflicting demands settlement procedure that has already begun. The escrow funds are held in an attorney's escrow account. Hyde seeks an EDO from the FREC. How will the FREC likely respond? The FREC will not issue an EDO because the funds are in an attorney's escrow account. The FREC will issue an EDO within ten business days. The FREC will issue an EDO if the other three settlement procedures don't work. The FREC will not issue an EDO because the dispute must be settled
Discuss the role of securities law in regulating the issuance and trading of stocks and bonds, as well as the legal obligations of companies in providing accurate and timely financial information to investors.
“I think I’m in trouble,” Elvira confided to her husband, Curtis. “I had a customer in today who complained that one of my clerks had discriminated against her and that she was going to sue. I discovered that this same clerk had designed an elaborate scheme to embezzle from me and I intend to press criminal charges. Also, my landlord has stating that the remodeling I did voids my rental agreement and he wants me to vacate in 2 months. I looked at the contract and I’m 99% sure he’s wrong, but I’m no lawyer. I need some legal help!”