How will the Lincoln School District's lawyers use the constitutional concept of substantial disruption? NAME Isaich B.SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT CASE SUMMARY: Hayes v. Lincoln School DistrictSherniece Hayes, a junior at Lincoln High School, created a Facebook group on herparent's computer at her house which she called "SAUG." On the Facebook group page, Hayeswrote that SAUG stood for "Students Against Ugly Girls." Another student, however, later told theprincipal that Sherniece was lying, because Sherniece had told her that the page really stood for"Students Against Ugly Gina." According to this student, this was a reference to another LincolnHigh School student, Gina McDonald. Sherniece invited 100 students from Lincoln High Schooland some other schools in the area to join the group, and 24 people from both Lincoln and otherhigh schools joined.Students posted comments and images to the group making fun of Gina. There weredozens of very mean comments. Many of the studentscalled her ugly, made fun of her acne, and said shedressed poorly, Some even used profanity directedtowards Gina; for example, one student posted a pictureof Gina's head on a pig's body, with the caption "Proof thatGina's mom f----d a pig that's why Gina looks like that."Another student posted a picture of Gina and wrote thatshe is "the ugliest girl at Lincoln." A third student wrote, "We need to clean up the mess atLincoln let's take out the trash (that's you GINA)!"Some Lincoln students accessed the page from school computers and left commentsthat were very cruel towards Gina. Students also started talking about the Facebook group atschool. One day in the cafeteria, some students, including Sherniece Hayes, started chanting"Take out the trash! Take out the trash!" while looking in Gina's direction and laughing.Gina started pretending to be sick so she could miss school. Hergrades started to drop and her parents became concerned. Finally, Gina toldher parents about the page. Gina and her parents complained about theFacebook group to the school's principal. After an investigation, schoolofficials determined that Sherniece created a "hate website" that violated theschool's policy against bullying. Sherniece was suspended for 5 days andreceived a "social suspension" for 90 days, which prohibited her fromparticipating in school social events. The suspension also went on herrecord which would be reported to any college to which she applied.Sherniece Hayes sued the school, claiming that the suspension violated her free speechrights under the First Amendment. The case eventually arrived in the Supreme Court.PGroupsShure, char, and emall with small groups of friends.Ovcs GreenCut as a groupTanlineFeeT s4ENT = 9EEIByCovenalKT=413CHECAControl wheses wDATEstandato the grFATnerd& uglyweakwanna-beasy bimboSTUPIDNO LIFEfreak

Substantial disruption refers to a significant and material interference with the normal functioning…

Students posted comments and images to the group making fun of Gina. There were dozens of very mean comments. Many of the students called her ugly, made fun of her acne, and said she dressed poorly, Some even used profanity directed towards Gina; for example, one student posted a picture of Gina's head on a pig's body, with the caption "Proof that Gina's mom f----d a pig that's why Gina looks like that." Another student posted a picture of Gina and wrote that she is "the ugliest girl at Lincoln." A third student wrote, "We need to clean up the mess at Lincoln let's take out the trash (that's you GINA)!" SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT CASE SUMMARY: Hayes v. Lincoln School District Sherniece Hayes, a junior at Lincoln High School, created a Facebook group on her parent's computer at her house which she called "SAUG." On the Facebook group page, Hayes wrote that SAUG stood for "Students Against Ugly Girls." Another student, however, later told the principal that Sherniece was lying, because Sherniece had told her that the page really stood for "Students Against Ugly Gina." According to this student, this was a reference to another Lincoln High School student, Gina McDonald. Sherniece invited 100 students from Lincoln High School and some other schools in the area to join the group, and 24 people from both Lincoln and other high schools joined. 09 Ch as a gro Tama P www. Groups Shure, char, and email with small groups of friends. C Chile Cher Se Furet Lime Nery ? 8 p = O V st 4 * 19 K U A T " 21 + Coves emal Sanda 4 -8 34 CHEC and are Control whee p standaa friends to the group Some Lincoln students accessed the page from school computers and left comments that were very cruel towards Gina. Students also started talking about the Facebook group at school. One day in the cafeteria, some students, including Sherniece Hayes, started chanting "Take out the trash! Take out the trash!" while looking in Gina's direction and laughing. Gina started pretending to be sick so she could miss school. Her grades started to drop and her parents became concerned. Finally, Gina told her parents about the page. Gina and her parents complained about the Facebook group to the school's principal. After an investigation, school officials determined that Sherniece created a "hate website" that violated the school's policy against bullying. Sherniece was suspended for 5 days and received a "social suspension" for 90 days, which prohibited her from participating in school social events. The suspension also went on her record which would be reported to any college to which she applied. Sherniece Hayes sued the school, claiming that the suspension violated her free speech ights under the First Amendment. The case eventually arrived in the Supreme Court. FAT & vrgly nerd weak wanna-be ha ST

Students posted comments and images to the group making fun of Gina. There were dozens of very mean comments. Many of the students called her ugly, made fun of her acne, and said she dressed poorly, Some even used profanity directed towards Gina; for example, one student posted a picture of Gina's head on a pig's body, with the caption "Proof that Gina's mom f----d a pig that's why Gina looks like that." Another student posted a picture of Gina and wrote that she is "the ugliest girl at Lincoln." A third student wrote, "We need to clean up the mess at Lincoln let's take out the trash (that's you GINA)!" SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT CASE SUMMARY: Hayes v. Lincoln School District Sherniece Hayes, a junior at Lincoln High School, created a Facebook group on her parent's computer at her house which she called "SAUG." On the Facebook group page, Hayes wrote that SAUG stood for "Students Against Ugly Girls." Another student, however, later told the principal that Sherniece was lying, because Sherniece had told her that the page really stood for "Students Against Ugly Gina." According to this student, this was a reference to another Lincoln High School student, Gina McDonald. Sherniece invited 100 students from Lincoln High School and some other schools in the area to join the group, and 24 people from both Lincoln and other high schools joined. 09 Ch as a gro Tama P www. Groups Shure, char, and email with small groups of friends. C Chile Cher Se Furet Lime Nery ? 8 p = O V st 4 * 19 K U A T " 21 + Coves emal Sanda 4 -8 34 CHEC and are Control whee p standaa friends to the group Some Lincoln students accessed the page from school computers and left comments that were very cruel towards Gina. Students also started talking about the Facebook group at school. One day in the cafeteria, some students, including Sherniece Hayes, started chanting "Take out the trash! Take out the trash!" while looking in Gina's direction and laughing. Gina started pretending to be sick so she could miss school. Her grades started to drop and her parents became concerned. Finally, Gina told her parents about the page. Gina and her parents complained about the Facebook group to the school's principal. After an investigation, school officials determined that Sherniece created a "hate website" that violated the school's policy against bullying. Sherniece was suspended for 5 days and received a "social suspension" for 90 days, which prohibited her from participating in school social events. The suspension also went on her record which would be reported to any college to which she applied. Sherniece Hayes sued the school, claiming that the suspension violated her free speech ights under the First Amendment. The case eventually arrived in the Supreme Court. FAT & vrgly nerd weak wanna-be ha ST