OPPOSING VIEWPOINTS Two Views of the Huns The first selection is a description of the Huns by on foot, and remain glued to their horses, hardy but Ammianus Marcellinus (ca. 330-ca. 393), who has been ugly beasts.... Buying or selling, eating or drinking, are called the "last great Roman historian." Ammianus wrote a history of Rome from 96 C.E. to his own day. Only the chapters that deal with the period from 354 to 378 have survived. Historians believe that his account of the Huns is largely based on stereotypes. The second selection is taken from an account by Priscus, an envoy from the Eastern Roman Empire to all done by day or night on horseback... They sometimes fight by challenging their foes to single combat, but when they join battle they advance in packs, uttering their various war cries. Being lightly equipped and very sudden in their movements they can deliberately scatter and gallop about at random, inflicting tremendous slaughter; their extreme nimble- the court of Attila (AT-uh-luh or uh-TIL-uh), king of the ness enables them to force a rampart or pillage an Huns from 434 to 453. His description of the Huns in 448 is quite different from that of Ammianus Marcellinus. enemy's camp before one catches sight of them.... They have no fixed abode, no home or law or settled manner of life, but wander like refugees with the wag- ons in which they live. In these their wives weave their filthy clothing, mate with their husbands, and give birth to their children, and rear them to the age Ammianus Marcellinus, The Later Roman Empire The Huns ... are quite abnormally savage. From the moment of their birth they make deep gashes in their children's cheeks, so that when in due course hair appears its growth is checked by the wrinkled scars.... [We were invited to a banquet with Attila.] When the They have squat bodies, strong limbs, and thick necks, hour arrived we went to Attila's palace... and stood and are so prodigiously ugly and bent that they might be two-legged animals.... Still, their shape, however disagreeable, is human; but their way of life is so rough national custom, that we might pray before we sat that they have no use for fire or seasoned food, but live down. Having tasted the cup, we proceeded to take on the roots of wild plants and the half-raw flesh of any sort of animal, which they warm a little by placing of the room on either side. Attila sat in the middle on it between their thighs and the backs of their horses. They have no buildings to shelter them, but avoid any- it steps led up to his bed, which was covered with thing of the kind; ... not so much as a hut thatched with reeds is to be found among them.... They wear garments of linen or of the skins of field-mice stitched together, and there is no difference between their dothing whether they are at home or abroad. Once they have put their necks in some dingy shirt they never take it off or change it till it rots and falls to pieces from incessant wear. They have round caps of fur on their heads, and protect their hairy legs with goatskins. Their shapeless shoes... make it hard to walk easily. In consequence they are ill-fitted to fight of puberty. Priscus, An Account of the Court of Attila the Hun on the threshold of the hall in the presence of Attila. The cupbearers gave us a cup, according to the our seats, all the chairs being ranged along the walls a couch; a second couch was set behind him, and from linen sheets and coverlets.... (First the king and his guests pledged one another with the wine.) When this ceremony was over the cup- bearers retired and tables, large enough for three or four, or even more, to sit at, were placed next the ta- ble of Attila, so that each could take of the food on the dishes without leaving his seat. The attendant of Attila first entered with a dish full of meat, and behind him came the other attendants with bread and other dishes, which they laid on the tables. A luxuri- ous meal, served on silver plate, had been made ready (continued)

icon
Related questions
Question
  • What is your first impression after reading this?
  • How reliable do you think these descriptions of the Huns are? Why?
OPPOSING VIEWPOINTS
Two Views of the Huns
The first selection is a description of the Huns by
on foot, and remain glued to their horses, hardy but
Ammianus Marcellinus (ca. 330-ca. 393), who has been ugly beasts.... Buying or selling, eating or drinking, are
called the "last great Roman historian." Ammianus
wrote a history of Rome from 96 c.E. to his own day.
Only the chapters that deal with the period from 354
to 378 have survived. Historians believe that his
account of the Huns is largely based on stereotypes.
The second selection is taken from an account by
Priscus, an envoy from the Eastern Roman Empire to
all done by day or night on horseback...
They sometimes fight by challenging their foes to
single combat, but when they join battle they advance
in packs, uttering their various war cries. Being lightly
equipped and very sudden in their movements they
can deliberately scatter and gallop about at random,
inflicting tremendous slaughter; their extreme nimble-
the court of Attila (AT-uh-luh or uh-TIL-uh), king of the ness enables them to force a rampart or pillage an
Huns from 434 to 453. His description of the Huns in
448 is quite different from that of Ammianus
Marcellinus.
enemy's camp before one catches sight of them....
They have no fixed abode, no home or law or settled
manner of life, but wander like refugees with the wag-
ons in which they live. In these their wives weave
their filthy clothing, mate with their husbands, and
give birth to their children, and rear them to the age
Ammianus Marcellinus, The Later Roman
Empire
The Huns ... are quite abnormally savage. From the
moment of their birth they make deep gashes in their
children's cheeks, so that when in due course hair
appears its growth is checked by the wrinkled scars.... [We were invited to a banquet with Attila.] When the
They have squat bodies, strong limbs, and thick necks, hour arrived we went to Attila's palace ... and stood
and are so prodigiously ugly and bent that they might
be two-legged animals.... Still, their shape, however
disagreeable, is human; but their way of life is so rough national custom, that we might pray before we sat
that they have no use for fire or seasoned food, but live down. Having tasted the cup, we proceeded to take
on the roots of wild plants and the half-raw flesh of
any sort of animal, which they warm a little by placing of the room on either side. Attila sat in the middle on
it between their thighs and the backs of their horses.
They have no buildings to shelter them, but avoid any- it steps led up to his bed, which was covered with
thing of the kind; ... not so much as a hut thatched
with reeds is to be found among them.... They wear
garments of linen or of the skins of field-mice stitched with the wine.) When this ceremony was over the cup-
together, and there is no difference between their
dothing whether they are at home or abroad. Once
they have put their necks in some dingy shirt they
never take it off or change it till it rots and falls to
pieces from incessant wear. They have round caps of
fur on their heads, and protect their hairy legs with
goatskins. Their shapeless shoes... make it hard to
walk easily. In consequence they are ill-fitted to fight
of puberty.
Priscus, An Account of the Court of Attila
the Hun
on the threshold of the hall in the presence of Attila.
The cupbearers gave us a cup, according to the
our seats, all the chairs being ranged along the walls
a couch; a second couch was set behind him, and from
linen sheets and coverlets....
(First the king and his guests pledged one another
bearers retired and tables, large enough for three or
four, or even more, to sit at, were placed next the ta-
ble of Attila, so that each could take of the food on
the dishes without leaving his seat. The attendant of
Attila first entered with a dish full of meat, and
behind him came the other attendants with bread and
other dishes, which they laid on the tables. A luxuri-
ous meal, served on silver plate, had been made ready
(continued)
The Late Roman Empire 151
Scanned with CamScanner
Transcribed Image Text:OPPOSING VIEWPOINTS Two Views of the Huns The first selection is a description of the Huns by on foot, and remain glued to their horses, hardy but Ammianus Marcellinus (ca. 330-ca. 393), who has been ugly beasts.... Buying or selling, eating or drinking, are called the "last great Roman historian." Ammianus wrote a history of Rome from 96 c.E. to his own day. Only the chapters that deal with the period from 354 to 378 have survived. Historians believe that his account of the Huns is largely based on stereotypes. The second selection is taken from an account by Priscus, an envoy from the Eastern Roman Empire to all done by day or night on horseback... They sometimes fight by challenging their foes to single combat, but when they join battle they advance in packs, uttering their various war cries. Being lightly equipped and very sudden in their movements they can deliberately scatter and gallop about at random, inflicting tremendous slaughter; their extreme nimble- the court of Attila (AT-uh-luh or uh-TIL-uh), king of the ness enables them to force a rampart or pillage an Huns from 434 to 453. His description of the Huns in 448 is quite different from that of Ammianus Marcellinus. enemy's camp before one catches sight of them.... They have no fixed abode, no home or law or settled manner of life, but wander like refugees with the wag- ons in which they live. In these their wives weave their filthy clothing, mate with their husbands, and give birth to their children, and rear them to the age Ammianus Marcellinus, The Later Roman Empire The Huns ... are quite abnormally savage. From the moment of their birth they make deep gashes in their children's cheeks, so that when in due course hair appears its growth is checked by the wrinkled scars.... [We were invited to a banquet with Attila.] When the They have squat bodies, strong limbs, and thick necks, hour arrived we went to Attila's palace ... and stood and are so prodigiously ugly and bent that they might be two-legged animals.... Still, their shape, however disagreeable, is human; but their way of life is so rough national custom, that we might pray before we sat that they have no use for fire or seasoned food, but live down. Having tasted the cup, we proceeded to take on the roots of wild plants and the half-raw flesh of any sort of animal, which they warm a little by placing of the room on either side. Attila sat in the middle on it between their thighs and the backs of their horses. They have no buildings to shelter them, but avoid any- it steps led up to his bed, which was covered with thing of the kind; ... not so much as a hut thatched with reeds is to be found among them.... They wear garments of linen or of the skins of field-mice stitched with the wine.) When this ceremony was over the cup- together, and there is no difference between their dothing whether they are at home or abroad. Once they have put their necks in some dingy shirt they never take it off or change it till it rots and falls to pieces from incessant wear. They have round caps of fur on their heads, and protect their hairy legs with goatskins. Their shapeless shoes... make it hard to walk easily. In consequence they are ill-fitted to fight of puberty. Priscus, An Account of the Court of Attila the Hun on the threshold of the hall in the presence of Attila. The cupbearers gave us a cup, according to the our seats, all the chairs being ranged along the walls a couch; a second couch was set behind him, and from linen sheets and coverlets.... (First the king and his guests pledged one another bearers retired and tables, large enough for three or four, or even more, to sit at, were placed next the ta- ble of Attila, so that each could take of the food on the dishes without leaving his seat. The attendant of Attila first entered with a dish full of meat, and behind him came the other attendants with bread and other dishes, which they laid on the tables. A luxuri- ous meal, served on silver plate, had been made ready (continued) The Late Roman Empire 151 Scanned with CamScanner
(Opposing Viewpoints continued)
for us and the other guests, but Attila ate nothing but
meat on a wooden platter. In everything else, too, he
showed himself temperate; his cup was of wood, while
to the guests were given goblets of gold and silver.
His dress, too, was quite simple, affecting only to be
clean.
Q What motives may have prompted Ammianus
Marcellinus to describe the Huns so harshly? How
does the account of Priscus differ, and what
strategies of the Huns do you detect here to
impress and overawe foreigners? How reliable d
you think these descriptions of the Huns are? W
Sources: Ammianus Marcellinus, The Later Roman Empire. From The Later Roman Empire by Ammianus Marcellinus, selected and translated by Walter Hamilton (Penguin Classics, 1986). Trand
copyright © Walter Hamilton, 1986. Reproduced by permission of Penguin Books Ltd. Priscus, An Account of the Court of Amila the Hun, from Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum, trans. J. B.E
Transcribed Image Text:(Opposing Viewpoints continued) for us and the other guests, but Attila ate nothing but meat on a wooden platter. In everything else, too, he showed himself temperate; his cup was of wood, while to the guests were given goblets of gold and silver. His dress, too, was quite simple, affecting only to be clean. Q What motives may have prompted Ammianus Marcellinus to describe the Huns so harshly? How does the account of Priscus differ, and what strategies of the Huns do you detect here to impress and overawe foreigners? How reliable d you think these descriptions of the Huns are? W Sources: Ammianus Marcellinus, The Later Roman Empire. From The Later Roman Empire by Ammianus Marcellinus, selected and translated by Walter Hamilton (Penguin Classics, 1986). Trand copyright © Walter Hamilton, 1986. Reproduced by permission of Penguin Books Ltd. Priscus, An Account of the Court of Amila the Hun, from Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum, trans. J. B.E
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer