On page 20, Loewen points out how only 4 textbooks mention Wilson's racial policies, and follows with a block quote from the textbook Land of Promise from 1983. He then points out how textbooks now treat it. "Omitting or absolving Wilson's racism goes beyond concealing a character blemish. It is overtly racist. No Black person could ever consider Woodrow Wilson a hero. Textbooks that present him as a hero are written from a white perspective. The cover-up denies all students the chance to learn something important about the interrelationship between the leader and the led" (20-1). How effective is Lowen's argument here? Why? Explain fully.
On page 20, Loewen points out how only 4 textbooks mention Wilson's racial policies, and follows with a block quote from the textbook Land of Promise from 1983. He then points out how textbooks now treat it. "Omitting or absolving Wilson's racism goes beyond concealing a character blemish. It is overtly racist. No Black person could ever consider Woodrow Wilson a hero. Textbooks that present him as a hero are written from a white perspective. The cover-up denies all students the chance to learn something important about the interrelationship between the leader and the led" (20-1). How effective is Lowen's argument here? Why? Explain fully.
Related questions
Question
![### Analysis of Textbook Representations of Wilson's Racial Policies
In his discussion on page 20, Loewen highlights a critical gap in historical education: the omission of President Woodrow Wilson's racial policies in most textbooks. Loewen notes that only four textbooks address this aspect of Wilson's presidency. He supports his argument with a block quote from the textbook **Land of Promise** published in 1983, which serves as an example.
**Loewen's Quotation:**
> "Omitting or absolving Wilson's racism goes beyond concealing a character blemish. It is overtly racist. No Black person could ever consider Woodrow Wilson a hero. Textbooks that present him as a hero are written from a white perspective. The cover-up denies all students the chance to learn something important about the interrelationship between the leader and the led" (20-1).
**Analysis Questions:**
1. **How effective is Loewen's argument here?**
2. **Why? Explain fully.**
Loewen's argument is compelling due to several reasons:
- **Selective Historical Narration:** By emphasizing that only a small number of textbooks mention Wilson's racism, Loewen sheds light on the selective nature of historical narration in educational materials. This suggests a systemic issue within educational publishing that may prefer to present a sanitized version of history.
- **Impact on Understanding Leadership:** The quote argues that omitting these facts distorts students' understanding of the complexities of leadership. It underscores that learning about the flaws and prejudices of historical figures is essential for a nuanced perspective of history.
- **Racial Perspective Concerns:** The critique that textbooks presenting Wilson as a hero are written from a "white perspective" highlights the racial biases that can permeate historical education. It calls for a more inclusive approach that considers perspectives from different racial and ethnic backgrounds.
In summary, Loewen effectively argues that the omission of Wilson's racial policies in textbooks is not merely a matter of incomplete history but an active misrepresentation that impedes comprehensive education. This critical examination encourages educators to strive for more balanced and inclusive historical narratives.](/v2/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fcontent.bartleby.com%2Fqna-images%2Fquestion%2F4295bf62-da14-49f1-b3bf-6e678bc68de3%2F8f3733ab-a0c5-4776-9775-2f011f7b0a27%2Fmiug91u_processed.jpeg&w=3840&q=75)
Transcribed Image Text:### Analysis of Textbook Representations of Wilson's Racial Policies
In his discussion on page 20, Loewen highlights a critical gap in historical education: the omission of President Woodrow Wilson's racial policies in most textbooks. Loewen notes that only four textbooks address this aspect of Wilson's presidency. He supports his argument with a block quote from the textbook **Land of Promise** published in 1983, which serves as an example.
**Loewen's Quotation:**
> "Omitting or absolving Wilson's racism goes beyond concealing a character blemish. It is overtly racist. No Black person could ever consider Woodrow Wilson a hero. Textbooks that present him as a hero are written from a white perspective. The cover-up denies all students the chance to learn something important about the interrelationship between the leader and the led" (20-1).
**Analysis Questions:**
1. **How effective is Loewen's argument here?**
2. **Why? Explain fully.**
Loewen's argument is compelling due to several reasons:
- **Selective Historical Narration:** By emphasizing that only a small number of textbooks mention Wilson's racism, Loewen sheds light on the selective nature of historical narration in educational materials. This suggests a systemic issue within educational publishing that may prefer to present a sanitized version of history.
- **Impact on Understanding Leadership:** The quote argues that omitting these facts distorts students' understanding of the complexities of leadership. It underscores that learning about the flaws and prejudices of historical figures is essential for a nuanced perspective of history.
- **Racial Perspective Concerns:** The critique that textbooks presenting Wilson as a hero are written from a "white perspective" highlights the racial biases that can permeate historical education. It calls for a more inclusive approach that considers perspectives from different racial and ethnic backgrounds.
In summary, Loewen effectively argues that the omission of Wilson's racial policies in textbooks is not merely a matter of incomplete history but an active misrepresentation that impedes comprehensive education. This critical examination encourages educators to strive for more balanced and inclusive historical narratives.
Expert Solution
![](/static/compass_v2/shared-icons/check-mark.png)
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps
![Blurred answer](/static/compass_v2/solution-images/blurred-answer.jpg)