Josh operated a restaurant in Welland. Josh rented the premises from Stefon. The Lease for the restaurant premises included a provision that the Tenant would complete all maintenance and repairs to the building and allowed the Landlord to complete periodic inspections. If an inspection revealed that any repairs were required the Tenant was required to correct any deficiencies within 60 days. The initial 5 year term of the Lease expired on September 30. The Lease included an option for the Tenant to renew the Lease for an additional 5 year term provided that notice exercising the option to renew was given to the Landlord by May 31. On April 1, Stefon completed an inspection and provided a list of deficiencies to Josh together with a notice that all deficiencies were to be corrected within 60 days. On April 10, Stefon advised Josh that he was listing the property for sale. Josh indicated that he was interested in purchasing the property and asked if the time for completing the repairs could be extended

FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING
10th Edition
ISBN:9781259964947
Author:Libby
Publisher:Libby
Chapter1: Financial Statements And Business Decisions
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1Q
icon
Related questions
Question
100%
Question 1
Josh operated a restaurant in Welland. Josh rented the premises from Stefon. The Lease for the restaurant
premises included a provision that the Tenant would complete all maintenance and repairs to the building
and allowed the Landlord to complete periodic inspections. If an inspection revealed that any repairs were
required the Tenant was required to correct any deficiencies within 60 days.
The initial 5 year term of the Lease expired on September 30. The Lease included an option for the Tenant
to renew the Lease for an additional 5 year term provided that notice exercising the option to renew was
given to the Landlord by May 31.
On April 1, Stefon completed an inspection and provided a list of deficiencies to Josh together with a notice
that all deficiencies were to be corrected within 60 days.
On April 10, Stefon advised Josh that he was listing the property for sale. Josh indicated that he was
interested in purchasing the property and asked if the time for completing the repairs could be extended
since he might make more extensive renovations if he owned the property. Stefon agreed and said that he
would allow Josh to match any offer he received.
On June 1, Stefon told Josh that he had received and accepted an offer to sell the property for $3,000,000.00
and that the Buyer required vacant possession. He also delivered notice to Josh terminating the Lease since
Josh had breached the Lease by not completing the repairs within 60 days.
On April 10, Stefon advised Josh that he was listing the property for sale. Josh indicated that he was
interested in purchasing the property and asked if the time for completing the repairs could be extended
since he might make more extensive renovations if he owned the property. Stefon agreed and said that he
would allow Josh to match any offer he received.
On June 1, Stefon told Josh that he had received and accepted an offer to sell the property for $3,000,000.00
and that the Buyer required vacant possession. He also delivered notice to Josh terminating the Lease since
Josh had breached the Lease by not completing the repairs within 60 days.
Josh said that:
(i)
he would commence and complete the repairs within 60 days;
(ii)
he was exercising his right to renew the Lease;
(iii)
he would match the offer to purchase for $3,000,000.00.
Stefon said it was too late and that Josh did not have a legal right to do any of those things, nor did Stefon
have any further legal obligations to Josh.
Josh comes to you for advice.
Required:
to the facts of this case and the positions taken by the parties. What is the likely result of any legal action?
Explain in detail the applicable legal principles and provide an analysis of how they apply
Transcribed Image Text:Question 1 Josh operated a restaurant in Welland. Josh rented the premises from Stefon. The Lease for the restaurant premises included a provision that the Tenant would complete all maintenance and repairs to the building and allowed the Landlord to complete periodic inspections. If an inspection revealed that any repairs were required the Tenant was required to correct any deficiencies within 60 days. The initial 5 year term of the Lease expired on September 30. The Lease included an option for the Tenant to renew the Lease for an additional 5 year term provided that notice exercising the option to renew was given to the Landlord by May 31. On April 1, Stefon completed an inspection and provided a list of deficiencies to Josh together with a notice that all deficiencies were to be corrected within 60 days. On April 10, Stefon advised Josh that he was listing the property for sale. Josh indicated that he was interested in purchasing the property and asked if the time for completing the repairs could be extended since he might make more extensive renovations if he owned the property. Stefon agreed and said that he would allow Josh to match any offer he received. On June 1, Stefon told Josh that he had received and accepted an offer to sell the property for $3,000,000.00 and that the Buyer required vacant possession. He also delivered notice to Josh terminating the Lease since Josh had breached the Lease by not completing the repairs within 60 days. On April 10, Stefon advised Josh that he was listing the property for sale. Josh indicated that he was interested in purchasing the property and asked if the time for completing the repairs could be extended since he might make more extensive renovations if he owned the property. Stefon agreed and said that he would allow Josh to match any offer he received. On June 1, Stefon told Josh that he had received and accepted an offer to sell the property for $3,000,000.00 and that the Buyer required vacant possession. He also delivered notice to Josh terminating the Lease since Josh had breached the Lease by not completing the repairs within 60 days. Josh said that: (i) he would commence and complete the repairs within 60 days; (ii) he was exercising his right to renew the Lease; (iii) he would match the offer to purchase for $3,000,000.00. Stefon said it was too late and that Josh did not have a legal right to do any of those things, nor did Stefon have any further legal obligations to Josh. Josh comes to you for advice. Required: to the facts of this case and the positions taken by the parties. What is the likely result of any legal action? Explain in detail the applicable legal principles and provide an analysis of how they apply
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Similar questions
Recommended textbooks for you
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING
Accounting
ISBN:
9781259964947
Author:
Libby
Publisher:
MCG
Accounting
Accounting
Accounting
ISBN:
9781337272094
Author:
WARREN, Carl S., Reeve, James M., Duchac, Jonathan E.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning,
Accounting Information Systems
Accounting Information Systems
Accounting
ISBN:
9781337619202
Author:
Hall, James A.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning,
Horngren's Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis…
Horngren's Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis…
Accounting
ISBN:
9780134475585
Author:
Srikant M. Datar, Madhav V. Rajan
Publisher:
PEARSON
Intermediate Accounting
Intermediate Accounting
Accounting
ISBN:
9781259722660
Author:
J. David Spiceland, Mark W. Nelson, Wayne M Thomas
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Financial and Managerial Accounting
Financial and Managerial Accounting
Accounting
ISBN:
9781259726705
Author:
John J Wild, Ken W. Shaw, Barbara Chiappetta Fundamental Accounting Principles
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education