Capital Costs Annual ($) Annual User Salvage Costs ($) Alternative Maintenance Value ($) Costs ($) Present 15,000 600,000 condition Traffic signals | 340,000 10,000 5,000 450,000 25,000 12,000 Intersection 850,000 300,000 widening Grade 2,120,000 5,000 225,000 separation

Structural Analysis
6th Edition
ISBN:9781337630931
Author:KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Publisher:KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Chapter2: Loads On Structures
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1P
icon
Related questions
icon
Concept explainers
Question

Three designs have been proposed to improve traffic flow at a major intersection in a heavily traveled suburban area. The first alternative involves improved traffic signaling. The second alternative includes traffic-signal improvements and intersection widening for exclusive left turns. The third alternative includes extensive reconstruction, including a grade separation structure. The construction costs, as well as annual maintenance and user costs, are listed in the following table for each alternative. Determine which alternative is preferred based on economic criteria if the analysis period is 20 years and the annual interest rate is 15%. Show that the result is the same using the present worth, equivalent annual cost, benefit–cost ratio, and rate-of-return methods.

This table presents a cost analysis comparing different transportation infrastructure alternatives, highlighting the associated costs and estimated values for each option.

### Table Description

#### Column Headers:
- **Alternative**: Represents different strategies for traffic management and road infrastructure.
- **Capital Costs ($)**: Initial investment required for the implementation of each alternative.
- **Annual Maintenance Costs ($)**: Yearly costs incurred to maintain the infrastructure.
- **Annual User Costs ($)**: Costs borne by users annually, potentially reflecting fuel consumption, time delays, and wear on vehicles.
- **Salvage Value ($)**: The estimated residual value at the end of the infrastructure's useful life.

#### Alternatives:
1. **Present Condition:**
   - **Capital Costs**: $0
   - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $15,000
   - **Annual User Costs**: $600,000
   - **Salvage Value**: $0

2. **Traffic Signals:**
   - **Capital Costs**: $340,000
   - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $10,000
   - **Annual User Costs**: $450,000
   - **Salvage Value**: $25,000

3. **Intersection Widening:**
   - **Capital Costs**: $850,000
   - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $5,000
   - **Annual User Costs**: $300,000
   - **Salvage Value**: $12,000

4. **Grade Separation:**
   - **Capital Costs**: $2,120,000
   - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $5,000
   - **Annual User Costs**: $225,000
   - **Salvage Value**: $0

### Analysis Explanation
The table allows for a comparative analysis of different strategies based on their cost implications and potential savings. It provides a comprehensive overview for decision-makers to evaluate whether the long-term benefits outweigh the initial investment. Each alternative presents varied costs, reflecting different levels of efficiency and user convenience.
Transcribed Image Text:This table presents a cost analysis comparing different transportation infrastructure alternatives, highlighting the associated costs and estimated values for each option. ### Table Description #### Column Headers: - **Alternative**: Represents different strategies for traffic management and road infrastructure. - **Capital Costs ($)**: Initial investment required for the implementation of each alternative. - **Annual Maintenance Costs ($)**: Yearly costs incurred to maintain the infrastructure. - **Annual User Costs ($)**: Costs borne by users annually, potentially reflecting fuel consumption, time delays, and wear on vehicles. - **Salvage Value ($)**: The estimated residual value at the end of the infrastructure's useful life. #### Alternatives: 1. **Present Condition:** - **Capital Costs**: $0 - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $15,000 - **Annual User Costs**: $600,000 - **Salvage Value**: $0 2. **Traffic Signals:** - **Capital Costs**: $340,000 - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $10,000 - **Annual User Costs**: $450,000 - **Salvage Value**: $25,000 3. **Intersection Widening:** - **Capital Costs**: $850,000 - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $5,000 - **Annual User Costs**: $300,000 - **Salvage Value**: $12,000 4. **Grade Separation:** - **Capital Costs**: $2,120,000 - **Annual Maintenance Costs**: $5,000 - **Annual User Costs**: $225,000 - **Salvage Value**: $0 ### Analysis Explanation The table allows for a comparative analysis of different strategies based on their cost implications and potential savings. It provides a comprehensive overview for decision-makers to evaluate whether the long-term benefits outweigh the initial investment. Each alternative presents varied costs, reflecting different levels of efficiency and user convenience.
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 5 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Evaluation of Transportation Projects
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, civil-engineering and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Structural Analysis
Structural Analysis
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337630931
Author:
KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Publisher:
Cengage,
Structural Analysis (10th Edition)
Structural Analysis (10th Edition)
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9780134610672
Author:
Russell C. Hibbeler
Publisher:
PEARSON
Principles of Foundation Engineering (MindTap Cou…
Principles of Foundation Engineering (MindTap Cou…
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337705028
Author:
Braja M. Das, Nagaratnam Sivakugan
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Fundamentals of Structural Analysis
Fundamentals of Structural Analysis
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9780073398006
Author:
Kenneth M. Leet Emeritus, Chia-Ming Uang, Joel Lanning
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Sustainable Energy
Sustainable Energy
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337551663
Author:
DUNLAP, Richard A.
Publisher:
Cengage,
Traffic and Highway Engineering
Traffic and Highway Engineering
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781305156241
Author:
Garber, Nicholas J.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning