averting another such depression. ...Such safeguards restored confidence in the discredited banking system and established a firm economic foundation that performed well for decades thereafter. The Now Deal was also responsible for numerous other notable changes in American life. In the space of a decade government laws eliminated sweatshops, severely curtailed child labor, and established enforcement standards for hours, wages, and working conditions.... The New Deal's safety net … . . firmly established the principle that the government had an obligation to assist the needy." Roger Biles, historian, 1991 "My principal problem with Roosevelt and the Now Deal [is] not over specific reforms or his social programs, but with the failure of the United States to recover from the depression during the eight peacetime years that he and his policies governed the nation.... There were certainly positive contributions under the New Deal, but they may not have outweighed the negative aspects of the period. When one examines the full range of New Deal proposals ... the outline emerges of a form of government alien to any definition of liberalism except that of New Dealers themselves. Historians need to weigh more thoroughly and objectively the implications for the United States if Roosevelt's programs had been fully implemented. They also need to assess the costs in human misery of the delay in recovery, and of reduced U.S. influence abroad at a critical time in world affairs owing to its economic prostration." Gary Dean Best, historian, 1990 a) Briefly explain ONE major difference between Biles's and Best's historical interpretations of the New Deal. b) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Biles's interpretation. c) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Best's interpretation.

icon
Related questions
Question
"The New Deal economic policies ... implanted several 'stabilizers' that have been... successful in
averting another such depression. ... Such safeguards restored confidence in the discredited banking
system and established a firm economic foundation that performed well for decades thereafter. The New
Deal was also responsible for numerous other notable changes in American life. In the space of a decade
government laws eliminated sweatshops, severely curtailed child labor, and established enforcement
standards for hours, wages, and working conditions... The New Deal's safety net ... firmly established
the principle that the government had an obligation to assist the needy."
Roger Biles, historian, 1991
"My principal problem with Roosevelt and the New Deal [is] not over specific reforms or his social
programs, but with the failure of the United States to recover from the depression during the eight
peacetime years that he and his policies governed the nation.... There were certainly positive
contributions under the New Deal, but they may not have outweighed the negative aspects of the perlod.
When one examines the full range of New Deal proposals... the outline emerges of a form of government
alien to any definition of liberalism except that of New Dealers themselves. Historians need to weigh more
thoroughly and objectively the implications for the United States if Roosevelt's programs had been fully
implemented. They also need to assess the costs in human misery of the delay in recovery, and of reduced
U.S. influence abroad at a critical time in world affairs owing to its economic prostration."
Gary Dean Best, historian, 1990
a) Briefly explain ONE major difference between Biles's and Best's historical interpretations of the New Deal.
b) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not
mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Biles's interpretation.
c) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not
mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Best's interpretation.
Transcribed Image Text:"The New Deal economic policies ... implanted several 'stabilizers' that have been... successful in averting another such depression. ... Such safeguards restored confidence in the discredited banking system and established a firm economic foundation that performed well for decades thereafter. The New Deal was also responsible for numerous other notable changes in American life. In the space of a decade government laws eliminated sweatshops, severely curtailed child labor, and established enforcement standards for hours, wages, and working conditions... The New Deal's safety net ... firmly established the principle that the government had an obligation to assist the needy." Roger Biles, historian, 1991 "My principal problem with Roosevelt and the New Deal [is] not over specific reforms or his social programs, but with the failure of the United States to recover from the depression during the eight peacetime years that he and his policies governed the nation.... There were certainly positive contributions under the New Deal, but they may not have outweighed the negative aspects of the perlod. When one examines the full range of New Deal proposals... the outline emerges of a form of government alien to any definition of liberalism except that of New Dealers themselves. Historians need to weigh more thoroughly and objectively the implications for the United States if Roosevelt's programs had been fully implemented. They also need to assess the costs in human misery of the delay in recovery, and of reduced U.S. influence abroad at a critical time in world affairs owing to its economic prostration." Gary Dean Best, historian, 1990 a) Briefly explain ONE major difference between Biles's and Best's historical interpretations of the New Deal. b) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Biles's interpretation. c) Briefly explain how ONE specific historical event or development during the period 1932-1940 that is not mentioned directly in the excerpts could be used to support Best's interpretation.
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 3 steps

Blurred answer