17. Two spheres of different diameters surround equal charges. Three students are discussingthe situation.ВStudent 1: The flux through spheres A and B are equal because they enclose equal charges.Student 2: But the electric field on sphere B is weaker than the electric field on sphere A. Theflux depends on the electric field strength, so the flux through A is larger than the flux through B.Student 3: I thought we learned that flux was about surface area. Sphere B is larger thansphere A, so I think the flux through B is larger than the flux through A.Which of these students, if any, do you agree with? Explain.

According to Gauss's law, the electric flux through a surface is given by : ϕE=qencε0 Where qenc is…

17. Two spheres of different diameters surround equal charges. Three students are discussing the situation. A B. Student 1: The flux through spheres A and B are equal because they enclose equal charges Student 2: But the electric field on sphere B is weaker than the electric field on sphere A. T flux depends on the electric field strength, so the flux through A is larger than the flux throug Student 3: I thought we learned that flux was about surface area. Sphere B is larger than sphere A, so I think the flux through B is larger than the flux through A. Which of these students, if any, do you agree with? Explain.

17. Two spheres of different diameters surround equal charges. Three students are discussing the situation. A B. Student 1: The flux through spheres A and B are equal because they enclose equal charges Student 2: But the electric field on sphere B is weaker than the electric field on sphere A. T flux depends on the electric field strength, so the flux through A is larger than the flux throug Student 3: I thought we learned that flux was about surface area. Sphere B is larger than sphere A, so I think the flux through B is larger than the flux through A. Which of these students, if any, do you agree with? Explain.

College Physics

11th Edition

ISBN:9781305952300

Author:Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille

Publisher:Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille

Chapter1: Units, Trigonometry. And Vectors

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 1CQ: Estimate the order of magnitude of the length, in meters, of each of the following; (a) a mouse, (b)...

See similar textbooks

Related questions

Q: (Challenge Problem) Charge is distributed throughout a spherical volume of radius R with a density p…

Q: If more electric field lines leave a closed (Gaussian) surface than enter it, what can you conclude…

A: The electric field at a point in space is defined as the ratio of the electric force experienced per…

Q: 4. Shown are an uncharged conductor and an uncharged insulator/dielectric (a material where charges…

Q: Two charges of -15pC and 40pC are inside a cube with sides that are of 0.4m length. Determine the…

A: Charges inside cube Q1= -15 pC Q2= 40pC Total charge inside cube Q =Q1+Q2 = 25 pC L = 0.4 m

Q: 2.Which of the diagrams below best represents the charge distribution on a metal sphere when a…

A: In the induction process, a charged object is brought near but not touched to a neutral conducting…

Q: Which of the following is not a property of a neutral conductor in a static electric field? a.The…

Q: 7.) Two conductive spheres are placed near (but not touching) each other on an insulated table.…

A: When sphere A is placed near sphere B, where A is carries a net positive charge and B is natural…

Q: 1 4 A E The figure above shows four very thin parallel planes of charge with equal separation…

Q: Part 1: The Charged Semi-Circular Hoop A thin plastic rod is bent into the shape of a semicircle of…

Q: 3. The electric field everywhere on the surface of a thin, spherical shell of radius 0.780 m is…

A: Given: Spherical shell radius r = 0.78 m Electric field E = 880 N / C

Q: A charge +Q is sitting at the origin (0,0,0). A closed sphere with a radius R surrounds the charge.…

Q: 3. Consider the electric dipole that we studied in our lecture on the last pages of Module 1. It had…

A: In the question, it is given that there are two charges +q and +q on the z-axis at distance

Q: 1. In the diagram below, a thin plastic rod is charged positively with +Q Coulombs of charge.…

A: Solution: 1). The principle of superposition gives the total electric field at point p due to the…

Q: The electric field at a distance of 1.0 m from a charged sphere is 100 N/C. At what distance from…

Q: 1. The following charges exist (given coordinates are (x, y) coordinates in the plane of the page):…

Q: 31. A solid ball with 0.5 meters radius has 10 µC electric charge in its center. Determine the…

A: Charge enclosed (Q) =10μCRadius of the ball (r) = 0.5 m

Q: A short, charged, thin, plastic rod of length 2a is placed on the y-axis. The total charge on the…

Q: Generalization A. Direction: Sketch the electric field around the following arrangements of small…

A: Sketch the electric field(E) of (a) An isolated positive charge. (b) an isolated negative charge.…

Q: 9. What is the magnitude of the electric field in the center of a ring with radius a having a charge…

Q: happens to the magnitude of the electric field at a radius that remains outside the balloon before…

A: According to Gauss law for the electric field, the electric flux through any closed surface is…

Q: 1. The charge per unit length on the thin semicircular wire with total charge 'q' shown below is λ.…

A: As the given axis is in the XY plane, the electric field at point P in the z direction is zero.

Q: (Multiple choice) If a spherical copper conductor with a charge of -Q is connected to another…

A: The charge on the copper conductor will be +Q

Concept explainers

Electric Charges and Fields

One of the fundamental properties is the electromagnetic property. Charge cannot be destroyed by any process and this contributes formally to the law of charge conservation.

Question

17. Two spheres of different diameters surround equal charges. Three students are discussing
the situation.
В
Student 1: The flux through spheres A and B are equal because they enclose equal charges.
Student 2: But the electric field on sphere B is weaker than the electric field on sphere A. The
flux depends on the electric field strength, so the flux through A is larger than the flux through B.
Student 3: I thought we learned that flux was about surface area. Sphere B is larger than
sphere A, so I think the flux through B is larger than the flux through A.
Which of these students, if any, do you agree with? Explain.

Expert Solution

This question has been solved!

Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.

This is a popular solution!

SEE SOLUTION Check out a sample Q&A here

Step 1

VIEW

Step 2

VIEW

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

SEE SOLUTION Check out a sample Q&A here

Knowledge Booster

Learn more about

Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, physics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.

Similar questions

Suppose a 11 cm diameter conducting sphere, surrounded by air, has 1.9 C of excess charge on it. Calculate the electric field strength near the surface of the sphere, in newtons per coulomb. E= What is unreasonable about this result? Multiple Choice a. There is nothing unreasonable about the result. b. The charge is too large for such a small sphere. None of these. C. d. The charge is too small for such a large sphere. e. An electric field couldn't be near a conducting sphere. Which assumptions are responsible for the unreasonable results? Multiple Choice a. The diameter of the sphere is too large. b. The excess charge on the sphere's surface is too great. C. None of these. d. The excess charge on the sphere's surface is too small. e. The excess charge and the diameter of the sphere are too large
If the number of electric field lines leaving a closed surface is greater than the number of electric field lines entering the surface, which one of the following statements is true? a. no charges lie inside the surface b. the net charge enclosed by the surface is positive c. the net charge enclosed by the surface is negative d. the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero
1. The main difference between an insulator and conductor is that:a. an insulator cannot obtain a net electric chargeb. an insulator will not allow charges to flow freelyc. a conductor will obtain only net negative chargesd. a conductor will not emit an electric fielde. a conductor will not allow charges to flow freely
Which of the following is (are) true? A.The electric flux through a closed surface whose volume holds a net charge Q depends upon both Q and the surface area. B.For charges at rest, Coulomb’s Law and Gauss’ Law are equivalent. Both A and B. Neither A nor B. The answer is 2-Neither. Why is A false?
The electric flux through each of the six sides of a rectangular box are as follows 4 =155 3 N-m/C, 4 = 236 4 N.m/C =-334 3 N.m/C ,-173 8 N.m/C 4--1118 N.m²/C d= 448 0 N m²/C. V Part A How much charge is in this box? PC Submit Previous Answers Request Answer * Incorrect Try Again; 5 attempts remaining
The following diagram shows the electric field lines in a region of space containing two small charged spheres (Y and Z). Which of the following statements is correct? O a. Y and Z both are negative. O b. Y is negative and Z is positive. O C. Y and Z both are positive. Od. a. Y is positive and Z is negative.
11. A charged insulating rod is shaped as a semicircle. The upper half (above the dashed line) has a total charge-Q uniformly distributed over it, whereas the lower half (below the dashed line) has a total charge +Q uniformly distributed over it. Which of the following statements best describes the electric field E at the point O? A. E points horizontally to the right. B. E points horizontally to the left. C. E points vertically upward. D. E points vertically downward. +Q E. E is zero.
2. Two charges are situated near point P. 9₁ = -2.5 μC and q2 = 3.5 μC. Find the electric field strength at point P. Note: For direction of the electric field, you can use one of the following: North, East, South, and West or Up, Right, Down, and Left P...... k 3.0 m r 91 + 2.5 m ¥1,2 92
Question 1 Consider the charge q1=1.6 microcolumbs at the origin. A. Find the magnitude of the electric field E1 from the point charge (3cm, 3 cm). B. Break the electric field into x and y components. C. If there is also an external electric field of E2=3.5*10^6 N/C ihat what is the net electric field at point (3 cm, 3 cm)?