1. Carnegie, Sumner, and George were all writing during an era called the Gilded Age, a time of tremendous economic upheaval. Describe the relevant context of this era. What was happening in society that may have prompted them to write these sources? 2. Carnegie and Sumner disagree over what should be done about poverty. Compare the two authors' views on what the rich owe the rest of society.
1. Carnegie, Sumner, and George were all writing during an era called the Gilded Age, a time of tremendous economic upheaval. Describe the relevant context of this era. What was happening in society that may have prompted them to write these sources? 2. Carnegie and Sumner disagree over what should be done about poverty. Compare the two authors' views on what the rich owe the rest of society.
Related questions
Question
I need help with this assignment I’m not sure what to say to these questions!!!
Transcribed Image Text:Primary Source Analysis 1
Wealth and Poverty in the Gilded Age
Luke Manget
Readings:
Andrew Carnegie, The Gospel of Wealth
William Graham Sumner on Social Darwinism
Henry George, Poverty and Progress
The Populist Platform, 1892
* All sources are located in "Primary Source Packet Wealth and Poverty in the Gilded Age."
Instructions. Use these questions to guide your reading of the above sources. After you read each
source carefully, answer each of the following questions with typed, single-spaced answers. Be sure to
reference specific passages, including quotes, in the sources to support your broader claims. Each
answer should have two parts: (1) your 'short' answer (that is, one or two sentences in which you
directly address the prompt), and (2) specific evidence to support that short answer (references to
specific passages, quotes, etc., that help you make your case).
Questions:
1. Carnegie, Sumner, and George were all writing during an era called the Gilded Age, a time of
tremendous economic upheaval. Describe the relevant context of this era. What was
happening in society that may have prompted them to write these sources?
2. Carnegie and Sumner disagree over what should be done about poverty. Compare the two
authors' views on what the rich owe the rest of society.
3. Sumner and George lay out definitions of "Liberty" that are very different from each other.
Compare these two men's conceptions of liberty. What do they see as the biggest threats to
liberty?
that o
your
4. The Populist Platform is one of the most remarkable American political documents ever written.
What can it tell us about how the Populist Party viewed the inequality of the Gilded Age?
Between Carnegie, Sumner, and George, who was most likely to agree with the Populists? Why?
ool
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
This is a popular solution!
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 3 steps
