Reflection 3
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of Toronto, Scarborough *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
A01
Subject
Religion
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
1
Uploaded by ProfArt11715
"Black Mountain" encapsulates a symbolic clash between divergent
worldviews, questioning whether the changing landscape of globalization will
foster a harmonious synthesis of ideas or intensify conflict in the quest to
preserve perceived religious truths.
Its important to note that the concept of syncretism, blending religious
traditions, becomes feasible primarily among practitioners with limited
knowledge. The tensions manifest in various ways, however they arise from
a lack of knowledge dissemination, creating an environment where radical
groups, exemplified by Hindu political factions in the film, exploit this
information gap to manipulate their followers with fabricated beliefs.
Contrasting AbdurRahim's Islamic teachings, where this concept of
syncretism lost its foothold and was only embraced by a minority, reflecting
the impractical naure of syncretism.
Navigating these tensions requires understanding and dialogue between
different perspectives, acknowledging the diversity within religions, and
respecting varying interpretations while fostering mutual respect and
coexistence
From the syncretism and academic perspectives, in the film, there are
indications of syncretic religious practices, particularly in the worship of
Pachmai Pir, which seems to have elements of both Hindu and Muslim
traditions. Academic perspectives often emphasize the syncretic nature of
religions, highlighting how cultural and religious traditions can blend and
influence each other over time. The shrine's history reflects a syncretic past
where the community had a more inclusive approach to religious practices.
However, from the fundamentalist opposition perspective, the arrival of a
Muslim priest, Abdarahim, from Pakistan signals a shift in the community's
religious practices. The priest condemns the worship of Pirs, emphasizing the
singular worship of Allah in Islam. Fundamentalist views, as portrayed in the
film, reject syncretism and advocate for a purer, more orthodox form of
religious practice. This is reflected in the opposition to visiting shrines and
the rejection of syncretic practices.
Consider how globalization may have played a role in the spread of
fundamentalist ideologies, as seen through the arrival of Abdarahim from
Pakistan. Globalization can both expose communities to diverse perspectives
and, in some cases, contribute to the spread of fundamentalism as people
react to perceived threats to their cultural or religious identity. In summary,
the tensions between syncretic practices and fundamentalist views in "Black
Mountain" reflect broader debates within religious communities about purity,
identity, and the impact of globalization on religious ideologies.
Discover more documents: Sign up today!
Unlock a world of knowledge! Explore tailored content for a richer learning experience. Here's what you'll get:
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help