PS09_lensing_solutions_modified

pdf

School

Rutgers University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

341

Subject

Physics

Date

Jan 9, 2024

Type

pdf

Pages

4

Uploaded by MagistrateWolfMaster936

Report
Physics 341: Problem Set #9 due November 29 by 2:00 PM in PDF format on Canvas [40 pts] You are encouraged to work in groups on these problems, but each student must write up the solutions individually. You must also list your collaborators on your solutions, and cite any external sources you used (other than the course notes or textbook). Using online solutions to these or similar problems is not allowed. Show your work and explain your reasoning. The number of points for each problem is listed; partial credit will be given. Be careful with units. Questions asking about concepts require at most a few sentences to answer. Please make your answers clear and concise . 1. You observe a galaxy to have three lensed images on the sky. What can you infer about the object doing the lensing? [5 pts] A. The lens is a single point mass. B. The lens consists of multiple points masses. C. The lens is an isothermal sphere. D. There is not enough information to infer anything about the lens. 2. This problem will give you a taste of how we model gravitational lens systems to measure galaxy masses. Imagine you observe a galaxy lens system with distances D l = 940 Mpc and D s = 1745 Mpc. One image appears at an angular position of θ + = 1 . 05 ” from the lens galaxy, while the other appears at an angular position θ = 0 . 35 ” on the opposite side of the galaxy. You may assume the lens is circularly symmetric. [15 pts] (a) Assume the galaxy can be modeled as a point mass. Find the Einstein radius and mass of the lens galaxy. The lens equation for a point mass is β = θ θ 2 E θ This must be satisfied for both θ + and θ , so we have two equations β = θ + θ 2 E θ + 1
β = θ θ 2 E θ for the two unknowns θ E and β . Since both have β on the left, we can equate the two right-hand sides and rearrange to write θ + θ = θ 2 E 1 θ + 1 θ Plugging in and solving for θ E gives θ E = 0 . 61 ′′ = 2 . 915 × 10 6 radians. Now solving for mass: M = c 2 4 G D l D s D ls θ 2 E = (3 . 0 × 10 10 cm s 1 ) 2 (2 . 915 × 10 6 ) 2 4(6 . 67 × 10 8 cm 3 g 1 s 2 ) (940 Mpc)(1745 Mpc) (1745 940) Mpc 3 . 086 × 10 24 cm 1 Mpc = 1 . 80 × 10 44 g = 9 . 0 × 10 10 M (b) Now assume the galaxy can be modeled as an isothermal sphere. Again find the Einstein radius and the mass enclosed by the Einstein radius. Now we suppose that the two images were created by an isothermal sphere lens. The two lens equations for an isothermal sphere are β = θ + θ E β = θ + θ E Equating the two right-hand sides and solving for θ E gives θ E = θ + θ 2 = 0 . 70 ′′ = 3 . 39 × 10 6 radians . The mass enclosed by the Einstein radius in this case is M = c 2 4 G D l D s D ls θ 2 E = (3 . 0 × 10 10 cm s 1 ) 2 (3 . 39 × 10 6 ) 2 4(6 . 67 × 10 8 cm 3 g 1 s 2 ) (940 Mpc)(1745 Mpc) (1745 940) Mpc 3 . 086 × 10 24 cm 1 Mpc = 2 . 44 × 10 44 g = 1 . 2 × 10 11 M You can see that making different assumptions about what kind of lens produces the images leads to different conclusions about the Einstein radius and the mass enclosed by the Einstein radius. However, the masses differ by less than 30%, which is not so bad for many astronomical problems! 2
3. We observe a galaxy, and measure a velocity dispersion of σ = 400 km/s. The galaxy has a radius of 20 kpc. [20 pts] (a) Assuming that the galaxy is an isothermal sphere, and has isotropic motion of the stars, what is the mass of the galaxy (in solar masses)? Using the virial theorem, we can estimate the mass of a galaxy as M = 3 β η 2 G . Assuming an isothermal, isotropic sphere, β = η = 1. Then M = 3(2 × 10 4 pc)(3 . 086 × 10 16 m/pc)(4 × 10 5 m/s) 2 6 . 67 × 10 11 m 3 kg 1 s 2 = 4 . 44 × 10 42 kg = 2 . 23 × 10 12 M (b) When observing this galaxy, we see two images of a more distant galaxy. These two images appear at 0.840’ and 0.540’ from the nearer galaxy (’ = arcminutes). Using your answer from part (a), and assuming the nearer galaxy is 10 Mpc away, how far away is the more distant galaxy? (You may ignore any effects from the expansion of the Universe in this problem.) We must first convert the image locations to radians: | θ + | = (0 . 840 )(1 / 60 )( π/ 180 ) = 2 . 44 × 10 4 | θ | = (0 . 540 )(1 / 60 )( π/ 180 ) = 1 . 57 × 10 4 . Then, we can relate the distance to the lens galaxy D = 10 Mpc to the mass of the lens galaxy M , the distance to the source D s , and the distance between the source and the lens D ℓs = D s D as M = c 2 4 G D D s D ℓs | θ + θ | = c 2 4 G D D s D s D | θ + θ | D s D D s = c 2 D 4 GM | θ + θ | 1 D D s = c 2 D 4 GM | θ + θ | D D s = 1 c 2 D 4 GM | θ + θ | = 1 (3 × 10 8 m/s) 2 (10 Mpc)(3 . 086 × 10 16 m/pc) 4(6 . 67 × 10 11 m 3 kg 1 s 2 )(4 . 44 × 10 42 kg) (2 . 44 × 1 . 57) × 10 8 = 1 0 . 898 = 0 . 102 D s = (0 . 102) 1 D = 9 . 82(10 Mpc) = 98 . 2 Mpc . 3
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
  • Access to all documents
  • Unlimited textbook solutions
  • 24/7 expert homework help
(c) One of the two images of the more distant galaxy is inverted, while the other has the same orientation in the sky as the actual galaxy. Which image is which? Explain. From above, the galaxy with negative magnification is also supposed to be in- verted. Images with positive magnification are not inverted. Alternatively, θ E < 0 . 840 and θ E > 0 . 540 . As a result, the image at θ = 0 . 840 is θ + and must have µ > 0, and have the same orientation as the actual galaxy. The image at 0 . 540 is θ and must have µ < 0 and be inverted. 4